With
UN
Ban
in Bangkok, Political Gatherings Banned, Myanmar Voting on
Giri Back Burner?
By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
October
26 -- The Asian tour of UN Secretary General Ban
Ki-moon began in Thailand, with all
political
gatherings banned. Ban
gave a speech saying that Thai problems are for Thais to solve,
reported then as “internal affairs.”
When
Inner
City
Press asked Ban's spokesman Martin Nesirky for Ban's view the right
to assemble for the redress of grievances, Nesirky replied that Ban
had received a letter of protest, from the Red Shirt movement. But
does that replace the right to assemble? Ban's spokesman wouldn't
answer. Video here
from Minute 29:12.
In
Nesirky's read
out of Ban's time in Thailand, he did not mention the critique by the
UN's special rapporteur on the right to health Anand Grover of
violent anti-drug programs in the region. (When Inner City Press
asked Anand, he said he would raise it with Ban Ki-moon or the
Secretariat, video here.)
Myanmar
was
raised
by Ban Ki-moon, but it is not clear how. In New York, the Good Office
on Myanmar team, created by the General Assembly, have been
reassigned to do other work under the Department of Political Affairs
Tamrat Samuel.
The shift,
without GA approval, is not mentioned in
the Secretariat's “Special Political Missions” submission to the
Advisory Committee on Administrative and Budgetary Questions.
Inner
City
Press
asked the UN's humanitarian chief Valerie Amos about media
reports
that
the UN's officer to help Myanmar with Cyclone Giri were
rebuffed.
UN's Ban & Thai Abhisit, political gatherings and Myanmar vote not
shown
She said that
“joint assessments” -- the same term used
by the UN in Sudan -- have begun and indicate that the damage may be
much larger than first thought, up to 400,000 people.
Can
a free, fair
and transparent election be held among the impacted people, Inner
City Press asked Ms. Amos, in Arakan State and elsewhere? She said
this couldn't be known until the joint assessment is completed. The
election is slated for November 7. Ban Ki-moon's next stops are
Vietnam and Cambodia, where violent anti-drug programs are most
extreme. Watch this site.
From
the
UN
transcript of October 25, 2010 --
Inner
City
Press:
I want to ask about the Secretary-General’s impending
trip to Asia. There is a report to the Third Committee by the
Special Rapporteur on the right to health about, among other things,
what he sees as the violated practices in anti-drug programmes in
many of the countries that Ban Ki-moon is going to be visiting —
Cambodia, Viet Nam, Thailand — and he calls very strongly for the
UN to move against people who are incarcerated. This is all
according to his report. I just wonder: of the many issues obviously
on the Secretary-General’s agenda as he visits these countries, is
he aware of that? And there is a separate issue in Cambodia, where
people has said that they are going to try and rally in front of Ban
Ki-moon about evictions, forced evictions, in Cambodia. Are these…
Can you sort of… Can we get a run-down of what issues he is
planning to raise, and I just wonder whether these two are among
them?
Spokesperson
Martin
Nesirky:
Sure. And again, I seem to recall that Farhan gave
you a bit of a run-down on the trip last week, sitting here. As the
trip progresses, we will be giving details. The Secretary-General
and his delegation are en route at the moment to Thailand where, as
you know, the visit starts. They then move to Cambodia and on to
Viet Nam for this UN-ASEAN [Association of South-East Asian Nations]
meeting and then to China, where, as you know, the Secretary-General
will be visiting Shanghai, Nanjing and Beijing. On the question of
health, the very specific point that you raised, we can find out and
probably tell you as the visit progresses. The same goes for the
second part that you mentioned.
* * *
Pro-Asia
Mahbubani
Says
Myanmar “Doing Badly,” Ban Ki-moon “In a Rough
Patch”
By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
October
22 -- Elite pro-Asia academic Kishore Mahbubani,
speaking Friday at the Council on Foreign Relations in New York, said
that Myanmar
is “doing badly.”
Also
in response to a question
from Inner City Press about the UN Secretary General, Mahbubani's
first response was that S-G Ban Ki-moon “has hit a rough patch.”
Given
that
in
other response Mahbubani said that Deng Xioping should have gotten
the Nobel Peace Prize and that Asia is a much more serious power than
the Muslim world, that he nevertheless could not present a story of
an upward trend line about Myanmar or Ban Ki-moon is significant.
By
contrast, Ban
told
Seoul's
Yonhap that he is confident in receiving a second terms
as S-G (Team Ban contests the translation) and that the reviews of
his performance by the international
community have been “very positive.” But even Mahbubani could not
deliver a positive review.
Mahbubani's
remarks
were
delivered in a wood paneled room over Park Avenue and
68th Street, lined with oil painting of somber Caucasian old men.
This was largely the audience, too, but for two younger women who
spoke of human rights.
In response,
Mahbubani said that human rights
cannot be spread by sanctions, and that “after Guantanamo Bay, no
one takes the US State Department Human Rights Reports seriously.”
Among
the
audience
were the sister of Senator John Kerry, who works at the US Mission to
the UN, and Ban Ki-moon's speechwriter Michael Myer, among with John
Brademas and David Denoon of NYU, both of whom asked questions.
Listed
but
not
questioning was “Judith Miller, Journalist.” One wondered what
she thinks of Mahbubani's analysis that the US wrongfully spends 80%
of its foreign policy on the Muslim world, including Iraq, while it
should be devoting those resources to countering China's rise.
Mahbubani, when he was Singapore's PR to the UN,
with Sri Lanka's Kohona
While
Mahbabani
said
that China overplayed its hand in strong-arming Japan to return
its ship captain, one also wonders what he'd make of China's
moves to block the
release of a UN Sudan Sanctions Committee report asserting
that Chinese bullets were found in Darfur after an attack on UN
peacekeepers there. The event ended at 9 am, and Mahbubani said he
had to catch at 10 am train.
Footnotes:
Mahbubani
told
the audience that he is used to being attacked, most
recently on by a historian while taping this week's Fareed Zakaria
GPS show on CNN. He praised Zakaria's piece which praises India -- a
regular circle of praise.
Just
as Tom Friedman editorialized about
conversation with Mahbubani over tea, Mahbubani recounted a talk with
a “senior State Department official over tea.” In these heady
circles, the UN and Ban Ki-moon are an afterthought, going through a
rough patch. Watch this site.
Mahbubani's
talk was reminiscent of Tom Plate's
"Giants of Asia" talk at the Singaporean Mission to the UN earlier this
year, and his book series by that name which now, Inner City Press
has been told, will not include Ban Ki-moon. We'll see.
* * *
On Myanmar, Ban Ignores Quintana's Call for Inquiry,
Daewoo Win-Win Unanswered
By Matthew Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
October
21 -- While on Myanmar
the UN's own Special
Rapporteur Tomas Ojea Quintana has called for a Commission of Inquiry
into crimes against humanity, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on
October 12 issued a report on human rights in Myanmar, A/65/367,
which did not even mention the Commission of Inquiry idea, or
accountability.
On
October 21,
Inner City Press asked Quintana to honestly assess the Secretary
General's performance on Myanmar. Quintana said “you cannot ask me
to tell him what to do,” but also acknowledged the absence of the
commission of inquiry idea or accountability from Ban's report.
Quintana
said
he
had met with Ban's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar -- not with Ban, who
will however be in his office in New York on October 22 -- and
discussed not only the November 7 election but also “justice and
accountability.”
Since
Nambiar
has
played a role in Ban setting up a purported Panel of Experts into war
crimes in Sri Lanka which has no investigative powers, no
spokesperson and no presence, Inner City Press asked Quintana is this
is what he has in mind for Myanmar.
Quintana
said
he
has in mind the “finding of facts” -- expliclitly NOT what Ban's
Sri Lanka panel is about -- but then diplomatically said that perhaps
the Sri Lanka panel is a model.
He also after
Inner City Press asked
about the plight of the Rohingya diplomatically thanked the Myanmar
military government for cooperating and allowing him to “meet
political prisoners” -- but not Aung San Suu Kyi.
Inner
City
Press
asked for Quintana's view on multinational corporations' engagements
with the Myanmar junta, including Total, Toyota and South Korea's
Daewoo. Quintana said that corporations might become complicit.
Quintana on Oct 21 on accountability, Ban Ki-moon not shown
Ban
Ki-moon when
he was South Korea's Minister of Foreign Affairs and Trade said that
a Daewoo pipeline across Myanmar was a “win win” proposition. Inner
City Press has asked Ban's Spokesperson's Office to get from
Ban whether he still views it this way, without avail. Watch this
site.
* * *
As
Myanmar
Bars
Foreign
Press, UN Empties “Good Offices” for Other
DPA Use
By
Matthew
Russell
Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
October
18
-- As Myanmar
moves to
bar foreign journalists
and elections observers from its impending November 7 polling, the
UN
on Monday churned out a prepared statement that did not directly engage
with the
exclusion of the media.
Inner
City
Press
asked
acting Deputy Spokesman Farhan Haq to confirm or deny that
staffers of the UN's “Good Office” on Myanmar operation, set up
by General Assembly resolution, have been even at this critical
juncture been redeployed to other non-Burma work within the UN
Department of Political Affairs, despite being in GA voted budget
lines not supposed to be changed by DPA.
Haq
said he
wouldn't comment on “budget lines,” but said that the prepared
statement showed that Good Offices work continued. That wasn't the
question, of course. And the UN's Myanmar and other such statements
are largely cut and paste.
Inner
City
Press
is
informed by well placed sources that the Department of Political
Affairs under B. Lynn Pascoe had “made a play” for staffers of the UN
Good Offices on Myanmar, “under-occupied”
with Ban Ki-moon's chief of staff Vijay Nambair "monlighting" in the
position since the departure for Darfur of Ibrahim Gambari. These staffers have
been assigned work for Tamrat Samuel of DPA.
Vijay Nambiar & Lynn Pascoe, "Good Offices"
power play not shown
There
is
a
problem,
however, the sources say. The Myanmar office is not directly
under DPA, and
its resources, specifically approved by the General Assembly, are not
supposed to be redeployed in this way. It is unclear why Haq feels it
is legitimate, in this context, to minimize and refuse to answer
“budget line” questions.
These
are
questions
of
separation of powers -- and of coddling a dictatorship.
Under Ban Ki-moon, these sources say, the GA's Myanmar office has
been turning into a husk. Watch this site.
Click here
for an Inner City Press YouTube channel video, mostly UN Headquarters
footage, about civilian
deaths
in Sri Lanka.
Click here for Inner City
Press' March 27 UN debate
Click here for Inner City
Press March 12 UN (and AIG
bailout) debate
Click here for Inner City
Press' Feb 26 UN debate
Click
here
for Feb.
12
debate
on
Sri
Lanka http://bloggingheads.tv/diavlogs/17772?in=11:33&out=32:56
Click here for Inner City Press' Jan.
16, 2009 debate about Gaza
Click here for Inner City Press'
review-of-2008 UN Top Ten debate
Click here for Inner
City Press' December 24 debate on UN budget, Niger
Click here from Inner City Press'
December 12 debate on UN double standards
Click here for Inner
City Press' November 25 debate on Somalia, politics
and this October 17 debate, on
Security Council and Obama and the UN.
* * *
These
reports are
usually also available through Google
News and on Lexis-Nexis.
Click here
for a Reuters
AlertNet piece by this correspondent
about Uganda's Lord's Resistance Army. Click
here
for an earlier Reuters AlertNet piece about the Somali
National
Reconciliation Congress, and the UN's $200,000 contribution from an
undefined trust fund. Video
Analysis
here
Feedback: Editorial
[at] innercitypress.com
UN
Office:
S-453A,
UN,
NY
10017
USA
Tel:
212-963-1439
Reporter's
mobile
(and
weekends):
718-716-3540
Other,
earlier
Inner
City
Press
are
listed
here,
and
some are available
in the ProQuest service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright
2006-08
Inner
City
Press,
Inc.
To
request
reprint
or
other
permission,
e-contact
Editorial [at]
innercitypress.com -
|