Ban
Speech in
Haiti After UN
Dodges Legal
Papers About
Cholera
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS, July
14 -- Five
days after
Inner City
Press asked
the UN about
cholera and if
Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon was
traveling to
Haiti mid-July
(and the UN
dodged), now
Ban has given
a speech there
about cholera.
But he did not
even address
the overwhelming
evidence that
the UN
introduced
cholera into
Haiti.
Nevertheless,
he ended his speech
saying "you
can count on
me and the UN
to do our
part." Really?
A question is
whether Ban while
there be
served with
legal papers
about the UN
bringing
cholera to
Hispanola,
another topic
on which Ban's
spokespeople
dodged and
worse.
From the UN's
July 9
transcript:
Inner
City Press:
yesterday
there was a
filing in the
Haiti cholera
case and it
also included
an attachment,
a letter from
OLA [Office
for Legal
Affairs]
addressed to
Samantha Power
earlier this
year, I mean,
from this
letter I
wanted to ask
you the
following:
it said, the
UN is
basically
claiming,
“We’re totally
immune unless
we waive
it.” And
so, I don’t
know if, but I
want to ask
you
this:
has the
Secretary-General
ever
considered
waiving the
UN’s immunity,
at least
partially, in
this
case?
And also, can
you, is it
true that the
Secretary-General
is going to
the Dominican
Republic in
the middle of
July, and will
he also go to
Haiti and
inaugurate a
soccer
stadium?
Spokesman
Dujarric:
I don’t have
any official
announcement
on travel at
this
point.
As far as
Haiti and the
legal
standing, our
position has
not changed.
Inner City
Press:
But did he
ever consider,
at some
earlier stage,
had he ever
considered and
rejected it?
Spokesman: As
I said, what
we’ve said
about Haiti
and the legal
position
remains the
same.
And, as I’ve
also said, our
work with the
Government in
Haiti on
addressing the
cholera spread
is
continuing.
I think there
was a meeting,
in fact, this
morning of the
Joint
Commission run
by the UN and
the Government
of
Haiti.
And, we
continue to
appeal for
funds and we
continue to
work in
partnership
with the
Government of
Haiti on that.
Now, this
announcement.
The
UN almost
certainly
introduced
cholera to
Haiti;
thousands of
Haitians have
died. On June
23, Inner City
Press asked
Ban's
spokesman,
YouTube
video here:
Inner
City Press: I
wanted to ask
you about the
service of
papers on the
Secretary-General
on Friday on
the Haiti
cholera suit.
I e-mailed you
on Friday, but
still have yet
to get an
answer from
you. Farhan
Haq is quoted
by some media
as saying that
he slapped
them away or
that his guard
stepped in the
way. What is
the case? How
would you
explain what
seems to be
kind of an
evasive
approach to
the Haiti
cholera issue
by the
Secretary-General?
Spokesman
Dujarric:
I don’t agree
with your
description of
evasive. I
think the
legal position
of the United
Nations has
been clear,
has been often
stated from
this from this
podium, by
myself and by
Martin, so
that position
is clear and
unchanged...
Clear?
Earlier this
year when
legal papers
for a lawsuit
were posted on
the door of
Ban Ki-moon's
UN-provided
residence on
Sutton Place,
his
spokespeople
repeatedly
refused to
confirm or
deny to Inner
City Press
that the legal
papers had
been received.
The Free
UN Coalition
for Access
has protested
the UN's
increased
stonewalling.
Now, a
new low.
Hearing that
Ban had
finally been
handed legal
papers in a
second Haiti
cholera
lawsuit while
he went to
give a speech
about Syria at
the Asia
Society on
Friday
morning, Inner
City Press e-mailed
Ban's top two
spokespeople
to ask: “Can
you please
confirm or
deny asap that
the Secretary
General got
handed or
served with
legal papers
in one of the
Haiti cholera
lawsuits, on
information
and believe
this morning
near the Asia
Society?”
Even
as Ban's
spokesperson's
office murkily
distributed a
report on
Syria which
mirrored Ban's
speech (review
of speech here,
of
distribution
here),
neither
spokesperson answered,
even to
confirm
receipt of the
question.
Now it
emerges that
Haq replied to
the Miami
Herald to the
same question,
telling
“the Herald he
was standing
behind ban
during the
alleged
encounter and
Ban did not
take the
papers. 'No
one at the UN
took the
papers,' Haq
wrote in an
email.”
The Free
UN Coalition
for Access
will have more
on this.
* * *
These
reports
are
usually also available through Google
News and on Lexis-Nexis.
Click here
for Sept 26, 2011 New Yorker on Inner City
Press at UN
Click
for
BloggingHeads.tv re Libya, Sri Lanka, UN
Corruption
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
UN Office: S-303,
UN, NY 10017 USA
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest service,
and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2014 Inner City Press,
Inc. To request reprint or other permission,
e-contact Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
|