On
Cameroon, Inner City Press
Asks UN Zeid For Death Count,
He "Has To Check," Wants
Access
By Matthew
Russell Lee, Video,
1st
Person, this
UNITED
NATIONS, March
19 -- The deference
of the
UN system's
and many of
its member
states to
Cameroon's
corrupt
36-year
president Paul
Biya, and
their
complicity in
his
recent
crackdown,
continues. UN
Deputy
Secretary
General Amina
J. Mohammed
was in Abuja
as 47 people
were illegally
refouled to
Cameroon; she
has been
silent on
that, as on
continuing
restrictions
on the Press
in her UN. On
March 19,
while
contrained
with a minder
and a roped in
cage, Inner
City Press
asked UN High
Commissioner
for Human
Rights Prince
Zeid if he had
any updated
death count,
since he
stopped at 10.
Video here.
He replied he
needs to look
at the
statistics, I
can't recall,
the important
issue is to
have access.
Inner City
Press pointed
to the visit
or access of
UN envoy
Francois
Lounseny Fall
(who equated
secessionists
with
extremists,
justifying the
crackdown).
Zeid replied
"like in West
Papua, I am
asking for
access." But
not asking as
loudly as
elsewhere. On
March 19 Inner
City Press
asked Antonio
Guterres'
spokesman
Staphane
Dujarric, UN
transcript here: Inner
City Press:
since you're
going to look
into the
Deputy
Secretary-General's
trip to
Nigeria, I'd
wanted to
know,
previously,
when she was
there, the
issue of the
47 Cameroonian
— many of them
UNHCR [Office
of the United
Nations High
Commissioner
for Refugees],
you know,
accredited or
whatever —
designated
refugees being
refouled to
Cameroon,
[will she ask,
[oes the UN
know any more
about where
those 47
people are…
Spokesman:
Nothing more
than what
we've said at
the time." Can
you head the
golden statue
Guterres
accepted from
Biya in
October, and
Amina J.
Mohammed
calling Buhari
"my
president"?
The UN has
enabled Biya
in equating
Boko Haram
with the
restorationist
forces, as he
did in his
cabinet
meeting on
March 15 with
this line:
"Thanks to the
firm action of
our defense
and security
forces, we
have been able
to drastically
curb the
atrocities
perpetrated by
criminal
groups in the
Far North,
North-West and
South-West
Regions." The
violence in
the Far North
is entirely
different from
that in North-West
and South-West
Regions. But
it was the UN
Secretary
General
Antonio
Guterres'
envoy Francois
Lounceny Fall
who equated
separatists
with
extremists; it
was Guterres
who stopped by
Yaounde and
took Biya's
golden statue
back in
October. On
March 16,
Inner City
Press asked
Guterres'
deputy
spokesman
Farhan Haq, UN
transcript here: Inner
City Press:
since it's so
rare, I got
asked
today.
The President
of Cameroon,
Paul Biya,
held his a
Cabinet
meeting for
the first time
since 2015,
second one in
the last six
years, and one
of the quotes
coming out of
it is to
congratulate
his defence
and security
forces for
their… to
drastically
curb the
atrocities
perpetrated by
criminal
groups in the
far north,
north-west,
and south-west
regions.
And "the far
north" seems
to be a
reference to
Boko Haram,
but
"north-west"
and
"south-west"
are the
Anglophone
regions, where
there's a
dispute about
whether that
part of the
country is…
actually is
part of
Cameroon.
So I wanted to
know, given
what's been
said by
François Fall
and others
about
dialogue, if
they took note
of the speech,
if they have
any thought on
it. And
I had also…
and also on
the issue that
you had been
talking about,
about investigating
leaks, I
wanted to ask
a very
specific
question.
If an internal
UN memo
concerning
Cameroon, not
submitted by
the Government
of Cameroon,
but simply the
UN's own
analysis on
why it might
make sense to
not speak out
or to speak
out, were to
be leaked, is
that the type
of leak that
would be
investigated,
since you said
that it's done
at the behest
of or in order
to protect
Member States'
ability to
give
information to
the UN, if I
understood you
correctly?
Deputy
Spokesman:
And part of
what I said is
that those are
decisions to
be taken
ultimately by
the managers
who deal with
the various
files. I
wouldn't
answer on any
particular
hypothetical
circumstance.
Inner
City Press:
But is there
any guidance…
I know… Is
there any
guidance from
the top of…
are there
cases where,
from the top,
the UN would
say this is
not an
appropriate
thing to
investigate
because it
chills
whistle-blowers?
Deputy
Spokesman:
Obviously,
you're aware
of what the
whistle-blower
protections
are, and all
managers are
aware of
those.
Regarding your
question on
Cameroon and
the behaviour
of the
security
forces, we've
also made
clear our
concerns about
any excessive
use of force,
and we want to
make sure both
that security
forces,
wherever
they're
deployed,
avoid
excessive use
of force,
abide by
international
human rights
norms, and in
this
particular
case, of
course, we
want to make
sure that
nothing is
done to
forestall any
efforts at
dialogue.
Have a good
weekend,
everyone."
Guterres is in
Lisbon, again,
for the
weekend.
Cameroon's UN
ambassador
Tommo Monthe
is back - he
said he was in
Kingston for
"the Seabed" -
ready to chair
the UN budget
committee
which plays
host to
Guterres'
"reform"
proposals. The
Biya
government is
destroying historic
places like
Boa Bakundu,
alongside the
illegal
refoulement to
Yaounde from
Nigeria, and
other ongoing
crackdowns.
The UN's
Central Africa
representative
Francois
Lounceny Fall,
who on UN
Radio equated
secessionists
and extremists
then ran from
Press questions
in UN
Headquarters,
deigned to
visit Buea,
along with the
UN's resident
coordinator
Allegra Maria
Del Pilar
Baiocchi, more
focused on
promoting the
UN than trying
to prevent
conflict and
the killing of
civilians. She
has tweeted
photos about
the visit,
nothing on the
burned motor
bikes and
people, much
less the
illegal refoulement.
The same was
true of the
visit of
Guterres'
Assistant
Secretary
General Ursula
Mueller of
Germany. She
didn't got to
the Anglophone
areas, her
trip was
quickly follow
by a German
government KFW
contribution
to other
parts of
the country
and now it
emerges that
the website of
the Germany
embassy in
Cameroon,
while
purportedly in
both French
and English,
has virtually
no information
to apply for a
visa in
English. In
fact, the site
says "This
Website is
currently
under
construction.
In the
meantime,
please check
our french or
german Website
version for
more
Information
regarding the
visa
procedure."
Photo here.
This in a
country that
is purportedly
bilingual.
We'll have
more on
this.
From the UN's
February 28 transcript:
Inner City
Press: I
wanted to ask
you about
Cameroon.
I've seen that
François Fall
has… or at
least his
office is
tweeting that
he's in the
south-west
region in
Buea, saying
he's having
some great
meetings.
Given that the
Government
side there has
asked for a…
for a… an
alert and that
young people's
motorcycles
are being
burned,
destroying
their
livelihood,
I'm just
wondering, are
we going to
get a
readout?
Was that said
in advance…?
Spokesman:
Let me see
what I can
get. Inner
City Press: It
seems like Mr.
Feltman didn't
actually know
it was taking
place. I
tried--
Spokesman:
Well, he may
not be the
only
one. I
was not aware
of the visit."
A full 24
hours later,
without
sending Inner
City Press any
update or
response to
its question,
Dujarric at
the noon
briefing read
this out:
"Turning to
Cameroon, the
Special
Representative
of the
Secretary-General
for Central
Africa,
François
Louncény Fall,
is indeed in
Cameroon to
consult on and
assess recent
developments
in the
south-west and
north-west
regions of the
country and
encourage a
peaceful
resolution of
the crisis
through
dialogue and
in accordance
with
international
standards of
human rights
and
humanitarian
law. Mr. Fall
held
consultations
in Yaoundé, in
Douala and in
the two
concerned
regions,
including with
Government
officials,
political
stakeholders,
the diplomatic
corps and
civil society,
among
others.
His visit to
Cameroon will
end on 4
March." Inner
City Press
asked, vide here,
UN transcript
here:
Inner City
Press:
on Cameroon,
on the thing
you read out?
What I wanted
to know is
that… you
know, it all
sounds great
and thanks for
coming back
with the
statement.
It seems like
at the same
time that he's
there with
this
statement, the
Government is
actually
deploying its
special forces
to… to
increasingly
militarize the
conflict.
So I wanted to
know, did… did
he witness
that while he
was there?
Spokesman:
I'm not aware
that [he
witnessed it]…
Inner City
Press:
Did he raise
the issue of
the… what he
had called
separatists,
what they call
restorationist
leaders, that
are… have been
detained and
not seen for
months?
Spokesman:
I think the
situation in
the Anglophone
area was
raised, as we
said it
was.
Thank you." So
what DID Fall
witness?
Guterres'
humanitarian
deputy
official
Ursula Mueller
offered
"congratulations"
to Biya's
foreign
minister
Mbella Mbella.
Photo and
UNanswered
Press question
here.
Now on
February 26
after four day
Mueller has
issued a
funding plea
for Biya's
Cameroon, with
a perfunctory
reference to
the western
regions at the
end:
"Concluding a
four-day visit
to Cameroon,
the United
Nations
Assistant
Secretary-General
for
Humanitarian
Affairs and
Deputy
Emergency
Relief
Coordinator,
Ursula
Mueller,
called on the
international
community and
the Government
to step up
support to
humanitarian
actions in the
country.
During the
visit, she met
with the
Minister of
External
Relations and
the Governor
of the Far
North.... Ms.
Mueller’s
visit was also
an opportunity
to discuss
other crises
that Cameroon
is facing,
with an
increased
influx of
refugees from
the Central
African
Republic and
sociopolitical
tensions in
the north-west
and south-west
regions."
Yeah. This
comes after
Inner City
Press asked
Guterres'
spokesman
Stephane
Dujarric if
Mueller would
stop in the
Anglophone
zones, and
since not, why
not? He
replied that
the overall
humanitarian
situation
would be
discussed. So
on February
23, Inner City
Press asked
Dujarric
again, video here,
UN transcript
here:
Inner City
Press: I had
asked you
before Ursula
Mueller's
trip, whether
the… the
situation in
the anglophone
zones of
Cameroon would
come up, and I
just want to
say I saw… I
guess she
tweeted a
picture of
herself with
the Foreign
Minister of
Cameroon
yesterday,
saying…
congratulating
the Cameroon
Government,
entirely
positive.
And I just
wanted to
know… you
seemed… you
seemed to
indicate that
the overall
humanitarian
situation
would
arise.
Given even…
even on the
issue of
refugees,
given that
there were 47
people sent
back seemingly
illegally,
refouled from
Nigeria, is
this… is she
unaware of
that in giving
these
congratulations?
Spokesman:
Her mission
focused on the
Lake Chad
Basin, on the
situation in
the Lake Chad
Basin which,
as you know,
has led to
mass… to a
humanitarian
situation
that's
impacted at
least 10
million
people.
She discussed
a wide range
of
humanitarian
concerns with
the government
of Cameroon,
including the
Boko Haram
crisis in the
far north, the
situation of
refugees from
the CAR
[Central
African
Republic] in
the east, and
the growing
food
insecurity
across the
country, as
well as the
situation in
the Anglophone
regions."
Really? With
congratulations,
echoes of the
golden statue
that Guterres
took in
October?
Meanwhile in
Nigeria people
are being
prosecuted for
sheltering
refugees from
Cameroon, and
Guterres and
the UN are
silent. We'll
have more on
this. A new
report details
Biya's long
stays outside
of the country
in Geneva,
while his
military kills
Anglophones
and the
country
declines. Biya
has spent four
and a half
years in
Geneva, at a
cost of $65
million in
hotel fees and
$117 million
for chartered
private plane,
sometimes left
"on stand-by"
for weeks at a
time. The
report goes
one level
down: "One of
Biya’s closest
confidants,
Joseph Fouda,
a military
officer and
special
advisor, has
accompanied
him on at
least 86
trips,
amounting to
more than
three years of
travel since
1993. He
prefers a room
on a top floor
of the
Intercontinental.
Another close
confidant,
Martin Belinga
Eboutou, 78,
has spent
nearly three
years
travelling
with the
president
starting in
1987, when he
was Cameroon’s
ambassador to
Morocco. The
president
attempted to
buy a brand
new private
jet in 2004,
but his staff
reportedly cut
corners on the
deal, buying a
defective
plane covered
by a fresh
coat of paint
that nearly
crashed on its
first flight.
Since then,
the president
has chartered
at least
several
private
aircraft,
including a
luxury jet
formerly owned
by the
government of
Kazakhstan."
Still UN
Secretary
General,
himself a murky
first class
flyer,
smilingly took
Biya's golden
statue and has
done nothing;
his advisers
Khassim Diagne
and the
outgoing head
of Political
Affairs have
assured him of
Biya's bona
fides or the
wisdom of
doing...
nothing. The
UN has failed.
The UN refugee
agency UNHCR
in Abuja early
on January 30
told Inner
City Press
that it has as
yet no comment
on the blatant
forced
repatriation
or refoulement
to Cameroon of
Sisiku Ayuk
Tabe and 46
others while
it seeks
"explanations
through
official
channels."
(Later UNHCR
issued a short
statement.) On
January 31,
Inner City
Press again asked
UN Secretary
General
Antonio Guterres' Spokesman
Stephane
Dujarric, UN
transcript
here and
below. When
Inner City
Press on
February 8 put
the
refoulement
question to
Francois
Delattre, the
UN Ambassador
of France
which has
supported Paul
Biya's 36-year
rule, Delattre
replied that
"We always
have views but
no comment
from me at
this stage."
Video here.
That is
irresponsible
- or another
sign of
France's
responsibility
for what is
happening in
the region.
We'll have
more on this -
and now on
Germany. Angela
Merkel's
"personal
representative
for Africa" Gunter
Nooke
showed up in
Yaounde on
February 15
trying as he does
elsewhere to
drum up business. With
him was
Ambassador
Hans Dieter
Stell; there
was according
to CRTV "the
exchange of
gifts symbolic
of Cameroon's
legendary
hospitality."
Another golden
statue like
UNSG Guterres
took? At UN
headquarters,
as
Inner City Press
alone asked,
Germany's
Ambassador
procured a
publicly
funded post
for his wife
by merely
emailing
Guterres'
chief of
staff. Inner
City Press asked
Dujarric and his
deputy Haq -
no real answer
- while
the only other
question asked
about it was
how the
information
about the job
had leaked.
The media asking that
is given full
access to the
UN by the UN
Department of
Public
Information of
British Alison
Smale, a major
Germanophile
who
continues to
have Inner
City Press
restricted, its long
time work
space given to
a no-show
no-question
Egyptian state
media.
We'll have
more on this.
The
United Kingdom's silence about
the plight of Anglophone
residents of the former
British Southern Cameroons
persists even in the face of a
Freedom of Information Act
request from Inner City Press.
More than five
months ago on 15 August 2017
Inner City Press asked the UK
government for records
concerning Cameroon. After
repeatedly extending the time
to response, now the UK has
denied access to all
responsive records, letter here,
saying that "the release of
information relating to the
UK’s discussion on UN business
could harm our relations and
other member states of the
United Nations (UN)."
Here
on Patreon is the full denial
letter, from which Inner City
Press is preparing an appeal,
on Yemen as well - it has 40
working days.
This is shameful
- the UK is also exiting
transparency.
On February 6 in
front of the UN Security
Council, Inner City Press
asked the United Kingdom's
Deputy Ambassador Jonathan
Allen for the UK's comment on
Nigeria's forced repatriation
of 47 to Cameroon. From the UK
transcript: Inner City Press:
Nigeria did a forced
repatriation of 47 Cameroonian
leaders. The UNHCR said it was
illegal. The US has commented
on it. Does the UK have any
view? Amb Allen: I’m afraid I
wasn’t aware of that before.
I’ll have to get back to you
on the details." Video here.
At day's end, a UK Mission
spokesperson sent Inner City
Press a short comment, here.
As
Inner City
Press pursues
these
questions at
the UN, again
it remains restricted
to minders by
the head of
the UN
Department of
Public
Information
Alison Smale,
who it is
noted is
British - and
functionally a
censor. A
retaliator,
too? As noted,
Smale has not
explained why
Inner City
Press' long
time work
space is
assigned to
no-show,
no-question
Egyptian state
media Akhbar
al Youm.
On Cameroon
and Yemen, UK Denies Inner
City Press FOIA Request
After 170 Days, Preparing
to Appeal, 40 Work...
by Matthew
Russell Lee on Scribd
Meanwhile
the French government, which
claims at the UN and elsewhere
that human rights is in its
DNA, has ignored the
refoulement, limited its
condemnation instead, via Foreign
ministry
spokeswoman
Agnes Von der
Muhll, on "new
killings of law enforcement
officials that took place on 1
February in Cameroon."
In Yaounde,
France's Ambassador Gilles
Thibault is focusing, like
Reuters' ostensibly charitable
arm, on the cultivation of
pepper, see here.
This is colonialism.Are these
the relations that the UK
claims would be hurt by
complying with FOIA? Watch
this site.
***
Your
support means a lot. As little as $5 a month
helps keep us going and grants you access to
exclusive bonus material on our Patreon
page. Click
here to become a patron.
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
Past
(and future?) UN Office: S-303, UN, NY 10017 USA
For now: Box 20047,
Dag Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest
service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2018 Inner City
Press, Inc. To request reprint or other
permission, e-contact Editorial [at]
innercitypress.com for
|