FEDERAL COURT,
Nov 5 --
On November
5,
months
after the DC
Circuit's
decision in US
v. Munchel, DDC Judge Trevor
N. McFadden
had before him
the case of two
Capitol
breach
defendants,
Robert Morss
and Geoffrey
Sills. They wanted
to have the
same lawyer, who
called out DC
Jail
Corrections
Officer Armstrong
before
the proceeding
went sealed. Inner
City Press live
tweeted it here
Judge
McFadden: I
don't like
getting
involved in
telling the
U.S. Marshals
where to move
people.
Defense: The
info we
received is
serious. But
we'll wait to
see the
government's
response.
Judge
McFadden: I
don't know
what to do on
the motion to
substitute
counsel.
Judge
McFadden: Has
anyone seen
Mr. Kiyonaga?
Defense: We
took the train
down from
Philadelphia.
Voice: I saw
him in the
building.
Judge
McFadden: On
the sixth
floor? What is
being alleged
about Mister
[Geoffrey]
Sills?
Now
he's here,
John C.
Kiyonaga.
Judge
McFadden: I
have some
concerns about
strategy as
the case goes
on. Both
defendants are
detained.
There could be
conflicting
interests.
Assistant
US Attorney:
Morss is on
one side of
the collapsing
line, as
officers held
that door. Mr.
Sills joins
the ground at
2:40 pm and
steals a baton
from one of
the officers.
Kiyonaga:
The government
is arguing
that I have to
prove a
negative if I
want to keep
representing
both
defendants.
The salient
feature is,
neither one of
these men is
accused of
conspiracy.
They did not
coordinate.
Kiyonaga:
I've search my
brain, it may
not be the
most capacious
one, I can't
find a
conflict.
Judge
McFadden: Ms.
Jackson and I
have found
some.
Kiyonaga: The
argument is
that I could
only represent
one drug
dealer, one
murderer.
Kiyanaga:
There are
lawyers
representing
more clients
that I am in
this overall
case. It's the
government's
decision who
to put in
which
indictment.
Excuse me, my
mouth is
really dry.
Judge
McFadden:
There's water
back there.
Kiyanaga:
In the video,
I see nothing
that looks
like Ranger
training. It's
like 5th
grade. Both
Mr. Morss and
Mr. Sills have
agreed to
waive
potential
conflict. The
contours of
that day are
far from clear
at this point.
Judge
McFadden: What
about
severance? I
can't imagine
running a 9
defendant
trial.
AUSA:
If we split
the 9 in half,
those detained
would go
first.
Morss'
6-months
lawyer: Our
client is
educated. He's
been a
teacher.
Morss' 6-month
lawyer is with
the Public
Defenders'
office in
Philly, which
has 11 January
6 clients. She
says, the
defense
lawyers have a
list-serv to
share
information.
Mr. Morss had
a right to
choose his
counsel.
Judge
McFadden: Can
I ask the
defendants to
approach the
podium. Mr.
Morss, how old
are you?
Morss: 28. I
have a
bachelors
degree. Sills:
30.
Judge
McFadden: You
are in the
upper echelon
of the case,
felonies and
assault.
Morss:
I want Mr.
Kiyanaga
because he is
a veteran like
me. A Ranger,
a step above
the average.
It is a
blessing.
Judge
McFadden: I
was prepared
to side with
the US, but
Mr. Kiyanaga
has made some
good points.
Severance
would solve
it, except for
sentencing.
Judge
McFadden: I
will allow Mr.
Kiyanaga to
represent both
defendants.
Kiyanaga:
Could Mr.
Morss be
transferred
immediately to
Alexandria? I
witnessed the
vindictive
status of the
CTF staff
where they
tried to pin a
bogus charge
on him. He was
set upon
Kiyanaga:
The C.O.'s
name is
Armstrong. If
Mr. Morss goes
back he will
suffer
retaliation.
Put him in
Alexandria.
Judge
McFadden: Do
you want to
speak under
seal? Counsel
approach.
Inner
City Press
previously published
a song
about Guy
Reffitt, here.
Inner
City Press
live tweeted
Riley June
Williams on
January 25, here.
Your
support means a lot. As little as $5 a month
helps keep us going and grants you access to
exclusive bonus material on our Patreon
page. Click
here to become a patron.
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle
500 Pearl Street, NY NY 10007 USA
Mail: Box 20047, Dag
Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest
service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2021 Inner City
Press, Inc. To request reprint or other
permission, e-contact Editorial [at]
innercitypress.com