By
Matthew
Russell Lee,
Follow Up on
Exclusives
UNITED
NATIONS,
January 11, more
here --
After the January
2 expiration
of the
deadline for
the FDLR
militia to
disarm or be
"neutralized"
by the UN's
Force
Intervention
Brigade under
the command of
Herve Ladsous,
a UN operation
began in
Eastern
Congo...
against the
FNL rebels of
Burundi.
Reference was
made to a
summit set up
in Luanda, Angola,
to speak more
about the
deadline,
perhaps to extend
it. Except
that now, Angola itself has
canceled this
summit. As
Google-translated:
"Canceled
Luanda Summit
on the
disarmament of
the FDLR: The
joint summit
ICGLR / SADC
is canceled on
the
disarmament of
the FDLR,
negative
forces
operating in
the eastern
Democratic
Republic of
Congo,
initially
scheduled for
January 19 in
Luanda. The
cancellation
of the meeting
was announced
at a press
conference
Friday, 09/01,
in Luanda, by
the minister
of Foreign
Affairs,
Georges
Chikoti, which
informed that
the command of
the operation,
will now be
assumed by the
United
Nations, and
takes a
compulsive
character.
According to
the head of
the Angolan
diplomacy, the
Rwandan
Democratic
Liberation
Forces, FDLR,
did not comply
with the
moratorium of
six months,
given by the
International
Conference on
the Great
Lakes Region,
to disarm
voluntarily."
So now what?
As Inner City
Press exclusively
reported on
January 9,
MONUSCO's
Martin Kobler
has been proffered
for the UN's
top
humanitarian
job; Ladsous
still refuses
to answer
Press
questions;
some Force
Intervention
Brigades,
consonant with
Ladsous, resist
acting on the
FDLR.
On January 9,
Inner City
Pres
staked-out the
meeting of the
DR Congo
Sanctions
committee,
speaking afterward
to the chair
and a half
dozen members.
That the FDLR
put forward
non-combatants
with non-functional
weapons for disarmament
seems to be
recognized. So
now what?
Meanwhile the
new DR Congo
sanctions
Group of
Experts
report,
obtained by
Inner City
Press, has
paragraphs on
the lack of
substance in
FDLR
disarmament to
date,
continued
recruitment
and
collaboration
with the
Congolese
Army.
Inner
City Press
previously
exclusively
published the
full text of
Group of
Experts report
and may do so
in this
instance. For
now, given the
deadline,
consider these
paragraphs,
quoted in
full:
"51.
According to
DDRRR data
available to
the Group at
the Walungu
camp,
many of the
combatants
were over 40
years old,
among whom
were a blind
man and a man
with only one
arm. In August
2014, two
former FDLR
combatants
from South
Kivu told the
Group they
thought FDLR
commanders had
sent older and
non-essential
combatants for
disarmament in
order to
prolong the
disarmament
process; a
MONUSCO staff
also expressed
this view to
the Group. In
addition,
during the
Group’s visit
to Walungu,
FDLR
combatants
told the Group
they were part
of the
'Leopard
Battalion;'
however,
battalion
structures no
longer exist
within FDLR."
This is
relevant to
consider when
much is being
made of FDLR
disarmament to
date. So is
this, about
new
recruitment:
"72.
According to
former FDLR
child soldiers
and
combatants,
FDLR has also
continued to
recruit
combatants
during 2014,
including
children
(paras.
123-124). A
former FDLR
combatant
based in
Lemera, South
Kivu, told the
Group that in
February, FDLR
forcibly
recruited
about 25
people,
including
children, in
the villages
of Kitopo and
Miki, where
there are many
Rwandan
refugees."
And
this, on
collaboration:
71.
In its
mid-term
report, the
Group
recounted
continuing
collaboration
at the local
level between
FARDC and FDLR
(S/2014/428
para 54-55).
Three former
FDLR
combatants,
including a
former FDLR
radio operator
based at the
FDLR
headquarters
who was
receiving
messages from
FDLR units,
told the Group
that FDLR
often obtained
ammunition
from FARDC
elements.
72.
According to
former FDLR
child soldiers
and
combatants,
FDLR has also
continued to
recruit
combatants
during 2014,
including
children
(paras.
123-124).
A former FDLR
combatant
based in
Lemera, South
Kivu, told the
Group that
in
February, FDLR
forcibly
recruited
about 25
people,
including
children, in
the villages
of Kitopo and
Miki, where
there are many
Rwandan
refugees.
After a closed
door meeting
of the UN
Security
Council on
January 5, a
Secretariat
representative
-- not Ladsous
who refuses
all Press
questions,
video here,
but another --
said
operations
have begun.
But those
inside the
meeting
pointed out it
is called
"shaping" the
operations,
targeting
another group
altogether.
Deadline? What
deadline?
On January 2,
Inner City
Press asked
the UN for SG
Ban Ki-moon's
or his USG for
Peacekeeping
Herve Ladsous'
comment or
action.
A press
release in
French from
the envoys was
the response,
now sent to
some by the UN
in English,
here:
"International
Envoys for the
Great Lakes
Region call
for decisive
actions
against the
FDLR
"Nairobi, 02
January 2015 –
Today, 2
January 2015,
marks the
expiration of
the six month
grace period
granted by the
International
Conference on
the Great
Lakes Region
(ICGLR) and
the Southern
African
Development
Community
(SADC) for the
full and
unconditional
surrender and
demobilization
of the
Democratic
Forces for the
Liberation of
Rwanda (FDLR).
The Team of
International
Envoys,
comprised of
UN Special
Envoy for the
Great Lakes
Said Djinnit,
UN Special
Representative
and Head of
MONUSCO Martin
Kobler, AU
Special
Representative
for the Great
Lakes Boubacar
Diarra, EU
Senior
Coordinator
for the Great
Lakes Koen
Vervaeke, US
Special Envoy
for the Great
Lakes and the
DRC Russell D.
Feingold and
Belgium
Special Envoy
for the Great
Lakes Frank de
Coninck, note
with concern
that the FDLR
has not met
this deadline.
Instead, the
FDLR has used
this six-month
grace period
to continue to
commit human
rights abuses
against
innocent
people in
Eastern DRC,
recruit
combatants,
and champion
its
illegitimate
political
agenda. Ending
the threat of
the FDLR is
not just a DRC
responsibility;
it is a
regional and
international
responsibility.
We all have a
deep
commitment to
ensuring
accountability
for those
responsible
for war
crimes, crimes
against
humanity, and
genocide.
By failing to
fully comply
with the
decisions of
the ICGLR,
SADC, and the
United Nations
Security
Council, the
FDLR has left
the region and
the
international
community with
no other
option than to
pursue the
military
option against
those within
the armed
group that are
unwilling to
voluntarily
disarm. The
Envoys
recalled the
Communique
issued by the
1 December
meeting of the
Guarantors of
the Peace,
Security and
Cooperation
Framework
(PSCF) for the
DRC and the
region in
which they
"stressed the
binding and
non-negotiable
character of
the 2 January
2015
deadline".
Indeed, there
is no
justification
for further
delaying the
neutralization
of a group
that is
responsible
for a long
history of
heinous
crimes.
The Envoys
hereby call
upon the DRC
Government and
MONUSCO,
including its
Force
Intervention
Brigade (FIB),
to take all
necessary
measures to
disarm the
FDLR, in line
with Security
Council
resolutions
2098 (2013)
and 2147
(2014). The
Envoys commend
the troop
contributing
countries
(TCCs) of
MONUSCO,
particularly
those of the
FIB, for their
commitment to
peace and
security and
for their many
sacrifices in
their efforts
to protect
civilians and
neutralize
other armed
groups in
eastern DRC.
The Envoys
note that the
international
community’s
expectations
for the FIB
are enshrined
in MONUSCO’s
mandate.
MONUSCO and
its FIB must
now engage in
counter-FDLR
operations, as
directed by
its leadership
and in support
of the DRC
government, in
fulfillment of
their mandate
to neutralize
all armed
groups.
The Envoys
emphasize
again to FDLR
combatants and
their
dependants
that, at any
point, they
can choose a
peaceful path
by entering
into the
existing
DDR/RR
program, which
continues to
successfully
repatriate
former FDLR to
Rwanda.
Over the
years, several
thousand
ex-FDLR
combatants
have safely
and
successfully
returned to
Rwanda. The
Envoys remain
fully
supportive of
the DDR/RR
process for
FDLR
ex-combatants,
while
encouraging
the countries
in the region
to work
together to
ensure that
those FDLR
leaders
responsible
for serious
human rights
abuses are
held
accountable.
"The Envoys
also encourage
the signatory
countries
of the
PSCF to
fulfill all
their
commitments,
including
respecting
each other’s
sovereignty as
well as the
commitment to
“neither
harbor nor
provide
protection of
any kind to
persons
accused of war
crimes, crimes
against
humanity, acts
of genocide,
or crimes of
aggression, or
persons
falling under
the United
Nations
sanctions
regime”. The
Envoys further
stress the
importance for
a
comprehensive
approach in
addressing the
root causes of
conflict and
instability,
and encourage
efforts of the
regional
leaders aimed
at promoting
confidence,
understanding
and
cooperation
between the
countries of
the region."
The
UN has still
not answered
Inner City
Press'
question about
the DR Congo
government's
crackdown on
the Panzi
Hospital.
Back on
December 7,
after more
attacks in
Beni in
Eastern Congo,
UN envoy
Martin Kobler
called for
joint UN and
Congolese Army
actions
against the
perpetrators.
Not addressed
are
allegations
that the
Congolese Army
FARDC has
colluded with
these and some
other rebels,
including the
FDLR.
Questions
have only
grown as to
why the UN's
Force
Intervention
Brigade was
deployed only
against the
M23, and not
the ADF or
FDLR.
Put
atop UN
Peacekeeping
is Herve
Ladsous, who
argued for the
escape of FDLR
genocidaires
into East
Congo as France's
Deputy
Permanent
Representative
in 1994.
Ladsous has
refused to
answer Press
questions
about this - videos here - and now about
covering up
rapes in
Darfur, here.
Earlier in the
week amid
continued
slaughter in
Eastern Congo,
with the
government
having thrown
UN rights
expert Scott
Campbell out
of the
country, on
December 2
there was an
"urgent" press
release by the
Team of
Special
Envoys.
The Envoys on
December 2
called for
action to be
taken against
the ADF and,
once again,
the FDLR. Now
on December 7,
Kobler's call,
Google
translated:
Kinshasa,
December 7,
2014 - "I am
deeply shocked
by the brutal
massacres last
night in the
localities of
Ahili and
Manzanzanba. I
condemn in the
strongest
terms these
despicable
acts that aim
to maintain a
climate of
terror in the
region,
"railed the
Special
Representative
of the UN
Secretary
General in the
DRC.
"The
proliferation
of joint
actions
MONUSCO-FARDC
is vital
urgency and I
call on all
partners to
strengthen
cooperation to
enable more
immediate
interventions
and increase
preventive
patrols,"
insisted
Martin Kobler.
Note to
editors:
1. A team of
MONUSCO and
the FARDC and
PNC are on
hand to check
the facts and
secure the
area.
2. The
killings took
place in the
two localities
Ahili and
Manzanzanba
west of
Maimoya in the
great north of
the North Kivu
province.
3. On December
3, the Head of
MONUSCO, the
Ambassador of
Great Britain
in DRC, Tim
Morris, and
representatives
of the US
embassies and
France had
visited
Blessed to
express the
same voices
concern after
the terrorist
attacks in
recent weeks
in the
territory of
Beni.
4. On 5
December, Mr.
Kobler had
returned to
Erengeti call
for stronger
joint action
MONUSCO-FARDC.
He also asked
the people to
maintain
direct contact
with the
forces of
MONUSCO to
facilitate
immediate
interventions.
As to the
Congolese Army
FARDC, it's
worth noting
that US
Ambassador
Samantha Power
tweeted last
week, "Nov 20
ADF massacre
of 80+ in DRC
just latest
appalling
atrocity. If
true, reported
FARDC
collusion
deplorable.
Need
investigation
&
justice."
The Envoys'
statement make
no mention of
this possible
FARDC
collusion.
The Special
Envoy's making
today's call
are UN Special
Envoy for the
Great Lakes
region Said
Djinnit, the
US Special
Envoy for the
Great Lakes
Russ Feingold,
the African
Union Special
Representative
for the Great
Lakes region
Boubacar
Diarra, the
European Union
Senior
Coordinator
for the Great
Lakes region
Koen Vervaeke,
the Belgium
Special Envoy
for the Great
Lakes Franck
de Coninck and
UN SRSG Martin
Kobler.
Back on
October 27
with the
Democratic
Republic of
the Congo the
topic in the
UN Security
Council, Inner
City Press put
questions to
UN envoy
Martin Kobler
and Great
Lakes envoy Said
Djinnit
after the
meeting, video
here.
On the FDLR,
Inner City
Press asked
Kobler of
Rwandan
Ambassador
Gasana's
statement that
Rwanda told
the UN of
locations
where the FDLR
was not mixed
in with
civilians, but
not action was
taken.
Kobler said
that the
region had put
the deadline
for
disarmament at
January 2 --
two days after
Rwanda's two
year Security
Council
membership
ends -- and
Djinnit added
that "pressure
should start"
on January 2.
Start?
Inner City
Press'
question about
the more than
100 disarmed
fighters who
died of
starvation in
a DRC Army
camp was not
answered.
After Kobler
referred to
the UN's
stated Human
Rights Due
Diligence
Policy, Inner
City Press
asked him if
any UN support
was withdrawn
over the DRC
Army's 130
rapes in
Minova and
only two
convictions.
Kobler's
answer did not
mention any
aid suspended.
Finally, as
Kobler said "au
revoir,"
Inner City
Press asked
why another
MONUSCO drone
had crashed.
Kobler to his
credit
returned to
the microphone
and cited
weather, while
saying the
investigation
is not
complete.
We'll have
more on this.
Earlier in the
Council,
Kobler
recounted an
attack on the
UN base in
Beni and
praised
"decisive
action" by
peacekeepers
to turn it
back.
But
wire services
reported that
UN
"peacekeepers
fired live
rounds to
disperse
hundreds of
people
protesting
outside a UN
base in the
eastern
Congolese town
of Beni."
Inner City
Press on
October 22
asked UN
Deputy
Spokesperson
Farhan Haq to
confirm or
deny this live
fire.
Haq, who had
read-out a
vague account
of events in
Beni, video
here, said
that's not the
information
the UN has. So
has the UN
sought any
correction
from Reuters,
and from Voice
of America
which despite
its budget
just re-ran
the Reuters
story?
Later in the
UN Security
Council
meeting,
Rwanda's
Ambassador
Gasana noted
that while the
UN is spending
$2 billion a
year on its
mission in the
DRC, the FDLR
militia is
still there.
Not present at
the meeting
was UN
Peacekeeping
chief Herve
Ladsous: 1994
memo here,
2014
Vine here.
The DRC's
speech,
eight pages in
length,
defended the
government's
expulsion of
UN human
rights
official Scott
Campbell,
mentioning him
eight times -
but did not
update or
mention even
once the DRC
Army's 130
rapes in
Minova, for
which only two
soldiers were
convicted.
We'll have
more on this.
And overall,
should the UN
be using live
fire on
protesters?
Should the UN
be working
with the
Congolese
security
forces who
unquestionably
use such live
fire, even
according to
the UN?
After
the DR Congo
government of
Joseph Kabila
threw UN human
rights
official Scott
Campbell out
of the
country, on
October 21
Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon called
for the
Security
Council to
consider
taking action
on it.
But why does
his Department
of
Peacekeeping
Operations
under Herve
Ladsous
continue
working with
the Congolese
security
forces, as it
continued even
with the Army
units involved
in 130 rapes
in Minova in
November 2012?
On
October
21, Inner
City Press asked Ban's
spokesman
Stphane
Dujarric:
Inner
City Press:
Let me ask on
the Scott
Campbell
expulsion, it
seems like the
Secretary-General
is asking the
Security
Council to
take action
but the
Secretariat
itself has the
power.
Can you say
that… what
would you say
to those who
say MONUSCO
continues to
actively work
with the DRC
army and
police and to
provide
material
support to
FARDC [Forces
armées de la
République
démocratique
du Congo]
actions.
This is
something that
DPKO itself
could
suspend.
Are they
asking the
Security
Council to
tell them to
enforce some
policy, or
what?
Spokesman
Dujarric: The
Security
Council will
have to decide
what it needs
to do.
MONUSCO
obviously has
a mandate that
it's
implementing.
It's
continuing to
work to
implement its
wide
mandate.
I think the
Secretary-General's
call to the
Government of
the DRC could
not be
clearer.
Inner City
Press: But
does MONUSCO
work in
support or in
conjunction
with the units
named in Mr.
Campbell's
report in
terms of the
Congolese
police?
Does the human
rights due
diligence
policy of DPKO
apply to this
instance?
Spokesman
Dujarric: I
will… my
understanding
is they do
not, but we'll
see what more
details we can
dig up.
Twenty four
hours later,
no "details"
had been dug
up, or at
least none
were provided
to Inner City
Press. So
Inner City
Press asked
Haq, yes or
no, does
MONUSCO work
with those
Congolese
security
units. Video
here.
Haq
said they are
police, not
the army. So?
Does the UN
not know who
it is working
with? Or does
it only not
want to say?
Back
on Friday
October 17
Inner City
Press asked
Dujarric:
Inner
City Press: I
wanted to ask
the Government
of the
Democratic
Republic of
the Congo said
it’s throwing
Scott
Campbell, the
human rights
UN person in
the country,
out of the
country.
And Lambert
Mende has been
quoted saying
this has taken
place.
What’s the
reaction to
that?
Dujarric had a
prepared
statement,
beginning "On
the issue of
Scott
Campbell,
we’ve seen the
reports.
None of these
reports have
been confirmed
to us." (Full
exchange on video here.)
But Campbell
has already
LEFT the DRC
by then: a UN
statement
issued on
October 19
says "Mr.
Campbell left
the DRC on
Friday for
long planned
holidays."
UN
Peacekeeping
under Herve
Ladsous still
supports the
DRC Army units
which
committed over
130 rapes in
Minova in
November 2012
after losing a
battle to the
M23 rebels,
despite only
two soldiers
being
convicted of
rape. What
message did
Ladsous send
by non
enforcing the
UN's claimed
Human Rights
Due Diligence
Policy?
And after
using its
Force
Intervention
Brigade to
"neutralize"
the M23 -
dozens of the
disarmed
fighters were
put in a DRC
Army camp and
starved to
death --
Ladsous'
MONUSCO has
yet to even
try to
neutralized
the
genocide-linked
FDLR. What
message has
that sent?
When Kabila
was in
Washington in
August, his
entourage beat
up protesters
and left the
country
without
prosecution,
as recounted
below.
Six
weeks after
Inner City
Press began
asking the UN
questions
about its
MONUSCO
mission flying
the FDLR's
sanctioned
leader from
Eastern Congo
to Kinsasha,
on August 7
the Press was
able to ask
MONUSCO chief
Martin Kobler
directly. Video here and embedded below.
But the night
before
Kobler's
appearance,
along with
Mary Robinson
and Russ
Feingold, at
the UN
Security
Council's
Democratic
Republic of
the Congo
debate, DRC
President
Joseph
Kabila's
bodyguards
were beating
up protesters
200 miles
south in
Washington. US
State
Department
deputy
spokesperson
Marie Harf on
August 8 said:
"We
are troubled
by the attacks
against
several
protesters by
members of the
official
delegation
from the
Democratic
Republic of
the
Congo.
It was
Wednesday
evening.
Take the right
to freedom of
expression
very
seriously, and
violence
against
peaceful
protesters is
totally
unacceptable.
We
communicated
our concern to
the delegation
in the
strongest
possible
terms.
We requested
waivers of
immunity to
permit those
involved to
face
prosecution,
and if such
waivers were
not issued, we
required that
the immediate
departure from
the country of
the
individuals
involved.
They did not
waive immunity
and the
individuals
involved left
the country on
Thursday."
So amid
the speeches
in the
Security
Council on
Thursday,
August 7,
officials from
the DRC were
leaving the US
after
attacking
protesters and
refusing to
waive
immunity.
On
August 7 in
New York,
Kobler said it
had been
transparent,
than when the
UN Security
Council's
sanctions
committee
denied the
waiver
requested by
Herve Ladsous,
the FDLR
leader was
returned "to
the bush."
Inner City
Press asked,
isn't he
subject to an
arrest warrant
in Rwanda?
Kobler said he
was unaware of
that.
On the mere
two
convictions
for the 130
rapes by the
Congolese Army
in Minova in
November 2012,
Kobler said
the legal
process was OK
-- video
here --
but that the
investigation
was not
sufficient.
The third
Press
questions,
which Kobler
did not
answer,
concerned the
rehabilitation
of General
Amisi after a
failure to
investigate
the charges
against him.
We will have
more on this.
On back June
27 amid
reports that
the UN flew a
sanctioned
militia leader
of the FDLR
militia on a
UN aircraft in
the Democratic
Republic of
the Congo,
Inner City
Press asked
UN spokesman
Stephane
Dujurric about
it at the UN
noon briefing
on June 27:
Inner
City
Press: why did
MONUSCO
[United
Nations
Organization
Stabilization
Mission in the
Democratic
Republic of
the Congo] fly
him to Goma to
Kisangani and
then to
Kinshasa when,
in fact, I
think there’s
an arrest
warrant for
him?
Spokesman
Dujarric:
I’m not aware
of any other
services
provided to
him by
MONUSCO.
But
it turns out
that UN
Peacekeeping
under Herve
Ladsous flew
the sanctioned
FDLR leader
from Eastern
Congo to
Kinshasa.
Rwanda
complained
about this, in
writing, on
June 26.
On July 16,
Inner City
Press asked
Rwanda's
Deputy
Permanent
Representative
what has been
Ladsous'
Department of
Peacekeeping
Operations'
response.
There has BEEN
no response -
in more than
three weeks. Video here, and embedded below.
Little more
than an hour
later, Ladsous
floated into
the Security
Council to
talk about
Central
African
Republic --
without having
answered a
written
complaint from
a Security
Council member
in more than
three weeks.
We call this:
unaccountable.
Dujarric
on June 27,
and in the
subsequent
times Inner
City Press
asked,
insisted that
not only Mary
Robinson (who
today left her
post as the
UN's Great
Lakes envoy)
but also US
envoy Russ
Feingold
requested the
waiver, and
that the FDLR
leader Gaston
Iyamuremye a/k/a
Rumuli had not
traveled to
Rome, arguing
that only that
was important.
Inner City
Press
disagrees --
why would UN
Peacekeeping
under Herve
Ladsous given his
history on
Rwanda,
representing
France in the
Security
Council in
1994
arguing for
the escape of
the
genocidaires
into Eastern
Congo, fly a
sanctioned
FDLR figure
linked to the
genocide
around?
On July
15, Haq
said
Rumuli
was escorted
from Kinshasa
back to the
east. Video
here.
Inner City
Press asked
about MONUSCO
escorting
Rumuli.
Haq said what
he had read
did not say
MONUSCO did
the escorting.
So who did?
And if not the
UN, how does
the UN know
where Rumuli
went? Watch
this site.