For Molotov Cocktails At
NYPD 2d Circuit Reply Filed To Mattis and
Rahman Being Freed
By Matthew
Russell Lee, Patreon Soundcloud
BBC
- Guardian
UK - Honduras
- The
Source
FEDERAL
COURTHOUSE, June 3 –
Amid protests about the murder
of George Floyd, late on May
30 the U.S. Attorney for the
Eastern District of New York
got a complaint signed
by Magistrate Judge
Sanket J. Bulsara about a
Molotov cocktail attack on an
NYPD vehicle. Inner City
Press, which covered the
protested in Foley Square and
at One Police Plaza on May 29
(video here
and edited here),
and aftermath
on Fifth Avenue on May
30, publishes the
complaint (later-written song
on Soundcloud).
"Defendants
Colinford
Mattis and
Urooj Rahman,
both residents
of Brooklyn,
were arrested
in a van early
Saturday
morning while
allegedly in
possession of
explosive
device
components
shortly after
Rahman hurled
a Molotov
cocktail at an
NYPD vehicle
before fleeing
with Mattis.
As detailed in
the complaint
charging
Mattis and
Rahman, an
NYPD
surveillance
camera
recorded
Rahman tossing
a Molotov
Cocktail at an
unoccupied
NYPD vehicle
parked near
the 88th
Precinct in
Brooklyn, New
York and then
fleeing in a
tan minivan.
Officers
pursued the
minivan and
arrested
Rahman and
Mattis, who
was the
vehicle’s
driver. The
NYPD recovered
several
precursor
items used to
build Molotov
Cocktails,
including a
lighter, a
bottle filled
with toilet
paper and a
liquid
suspected to
be gasoline in
the vicinity
of the
passenger seat
and a gasoline
tank in the
rear of the
vehicle."
On the
afternoon of June
1, the defendants
were presented
before EDNY
Magistrate
Judge Steven
M. Gold."
Inner City
Press covered and live
tweeted it, here.
Samantha
Shader did not
seek bail, and
is detained. Both Rahman
and Mattis
were ordered
released on
$250,000 bond
- but the US
Attorney
sought and got
a stay of
release,
pending appeal
to the Part 1
Judge,
District Judge
Margo K.
Brodie.
Inner City
Press live tweeted
that
proceeding at
as well,
here. Judge
Brodie upheld
Magistrist
Judge Gold's
order of
release. At the
end, she denied
Assistant
US Attorney
Ian
Richardson's
request for a
24 hour stay
in order to
confer with
the Solicitor
General for an
appeal to the
Second Circuit
Court
of Appeals.
It was
confirmed that
the "U.S.
Attorney’s
Office intends
to appeal
Judge Brodie’s
decision to
the Second
Circuit," per
Office's
Public
Information
Officer John
Marzulli.
On
June 2,
the appeal was filed, full
text on
Patreon here. And
now on June 3 an EDNY
reply (to a filing we
hope to
also obtain
and publish),
including that
"In order to
firebomb the
NYPD vehicle,
the defendants
had to: (1)
purchase or
gather the
bottles,
incendiary
liquid, and
other
materials
necessary to
construct
Molotov
cocktails; (2)
prepare the
incendiary
device; (3)
search for an
NYPD vehicle
to attack; and
(4) conduct
the attack. In
addition, the
defendants
sought to
equip others
with such
explosives and
to encourage
them to attack
law
enforcement.
The defendants
did not make
one bad
decision “in
the heat of
civil
protest”; they
carefully and
rationally
planned and
executed this
attack, and
played
bomb-maker for
others to do
the same. The
defendants
claim they are
not “thugs or
anarchists,”
but those
assurances
ring hollow in
light of their
actions. 5.
The defendants
also appear to
minimize their
conduct by
describing the
NYPD vehicle
as “empty and
previously
vandalized.”
Id. at 2. But
even if the
defendants had
been certain
the vehicle
was 3
abandoned,
their attack
had obviously
foreseeable
and dangerous
consequences:
the risk to
civilians in
the vicinity,
as well as to
law
enforcement
who would
investigate
the fire and
firefighters
who would try
to extinguish
it. 6. Second,
the defendants
argue that the
government has
not
established
“irreparable
injury”
because the
likelihood
that the
defendants
will commit
another
violent attack
is
“theoretical.”
See June 3,
2020
Declaration of
Sabrina Shroff
at 2." Full
EDNY filing on
Patreon here.
Complaint:
"ELAINE SILADI, being duly
sworn, deposes and states that
she is a Special Agent
with the Federal Bureau of
Investigation, duly appointed
according to law and
acting as such.
Causing Damage by Fire and
Explosives – Police
Vehicle On or about May
30, 2020, within the Eastern
District of New York,
the defendant SAMANTHA
SHADER did knowingly,
intentionally and maliciously
damage, and attempt to
damage and destroy, by means
of fire and one or more
explosives, a vehicle
and other real property used
in interstate and foreign
commerce and in an activity
affecting interstate and
foreign commerce, to wit: a
New York City Police
Department vehicle in
Brooklyn, New York.
(Title 18, United States Code,
Section 844(i)) 2
The source of your deponent’s
information and the grounds
for her belief are as
follows:
On or about May 30, 2020 at
approximately 1:12 a.m., an
individual, later
identified as the defendant
SAMANTHA SHADER, approached a
New York City Police
Department (“NYPD”) vehicle
parked in the vicinity of
Eastern Parkway and
Washington Avenue in Crown
Heights, Brooklyn. A video
provided to law
enforcement from a
witness captured the events.
The video
initially shows the defendant
SHADER light an
incendiary device –
specifically, a bottle
containing an incendiary
chemical (sometimes
referred to as a “Molotov
cocktail” device) – while an
unidentified male attempts to
shield SHADER from
onlookers. SHADER thereafter
throws the Molotov cocktail at
the NYPD 1 Because the
purpose of this Complaint is
to set forth only those facts
necessary to establish
probable cause to arrest, I
have not described all the
relevant facts and
circumstances of which I am
aware. 3 vehicle,
which was occupied by four
NYPD officers. The Molotov
cocktail shattered two
windows of the NYPD vehicle on
impact and caused internal
damage to the NYPD
vehicle. An image of the
defendant Shader throwing the
Molotov cocktail is shown
below and the video
provided by the witness is
appended by reference." Watch
this site.
***
Your
support means a lot. As little as $5 a month
helps keep us going and grants you access to
exclusive bonus material on our Patreon
page. Click
here to become a patron.
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle
500 Pearl Street, NY NY 10007 USA
Mail: Box 20047, Dag
Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest
service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2019 Inner City
Press, Inc. To request reprint or other
permission, e-contact Editorial [at]
innercitypress.com for
|