By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
January 22, updated
twice -- .With
the death of Saudi
King Abdullah
Bin Abdulaziz
Al Saud being
eulogized by
US President
Barack Obama
and,
apparently
from Davos, by
UN Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon, it is
striking how
the issue
of striking,
or flogging,
blogger Raif
Badawi has
simply
disappeared.
For diplomats,
perhaps it's
one thing. But
on the evening
of January 22,
Al Jazeera
English ran
footage of a
person they
identified
with Human
Rights Watch
praising the
King as a
reforming, including
on freedom of
expression.
Here's the
quote, memorialized
online:
"'During
King
Abdullah's
reign, he has
inspired a
greater
openness in
two particular
areas: role of
women and
freedom of
expression.
And there is
[an] outburst
of criticism,
social
criticism and
of government
policy that
happened in
Saudi Arabia
with the
tolerance to
some degree of
the Saudi
government,'
Christoph
Wilcke, former
Middle East
researcher at
Human Rights
Watch, told Al
Jazeera."
The quote was
given earlier
this year, but
Al Jazeera
rebroadcast it
on the night
of the King's
death. As to
being
"formerly"
with HRW,
online Wilcke
is still
listed with
them, here:
"Christoph
Wilcke is
senior
researcher in
Human Rights
Watch's Middle
East and North
Africa
Division for
Jordan, Saudi
Arabia, and
Yemen. He
joined the
organization
in 2005, and
has more than
15 years of
experience in
the Middle
East. Prior to
joining Human
Rights Watch,
Wilcke worked
with the
International
Crisis Group,
the
International
Peace Academy
(now
Institute),
and Save the
Children UK. A
native German,
Wilcke
obtained a
Master of
Philosophy
degree in
Modern Middle
East Studies
at St.
Antony's
College,
Oxford
University, in
2001."
His
Twitter
account now
lists him at
Transparency
International.
To not speak
ill of the
dead, we're
asking about
this, what was
said and who
broadcast it.
Update
of January 23,
5:30 am --
Human Rights
Watch writes
that the quote
attributed to
HRW about the
King "is very
old reflecting
early days of
the King's
rule and sadly
not at all our
current
assessment. We
have an
obituary out
or soon out
that reflects
current view.
Christoph has
not worked for
HRW in two
years, was
former
researcher."
We're happy to
add the above,
and link to
any HRW
obituary. The
interview /
quote was
broadcast on
Al Jazeera English
on January 22,
2015 after
being published
online by Al
Jazeera on
January 5,
2015 ("Christoph
Wilcke, former
Middle East
researcher at
Human Rights
Watch, told Al
Jazeera").
Will those,
and this,
be corrected
or amended?
Update
of January 23,
7:38 am --
Human Rights
Watch, noting
that the
Wilcke quote
that Al
Jazeera ran in
2015 was from
2010, has forwarded
its obituary
of the King.
It's long
(full version
online here),
but says in
pertinent
part:
"The
government
continues to
control the
appointment of
newspaper
editors and
punish Saudis
who criticize
members of the
royal family,
government
policies, or
senior
clerics. Under
King Abdullah,
Saudi
authorities
prosecuted
human rights,
civil society,
and pro-reform
activists for
nothing more
than
exercising
their right to
freedom of
expression.
After 2011,
Saudi courts
began imposing
prison
sentences of
over 10 years
for
speech-related
crimes."
How did a
video clip
from 2010
re-appear in
2015, without
notation of
when it was
from? How many
other such
clips exist,
and by whom?
Finally, for
now, we note
that the IMF's
Christine
Lagarde, in
Davos today,
is quoted that
King Abdullah
was strong
advocate of
women "in a
very discreet
way." Yeah.
On January 8,
Inner City
Press on
behalf of the
Free
UN Coalition
for Access
asked UN
Spokesman
Stephane
Dujarric about
Saudi Arabia
preparing to
flog a
blogger, video
here:
Inner
City Press /
FUNCA:
There’s a
blogger in
Saudi Arabia
called Raif
Badawi, he’s
been sentenced
to 10 years in
prison and
1,000 lashes
for his
blogs.
And according
to Amnesty
International,
he’s going to
be receiving
50 flogs a
week for the
next 20 weeks
and it begins
Friday.
So I wanted to
know… this
seems pretty
extreme.
Spokesman:
Listen, I
have… I have
not seen that
report.
I will take
look at it.
Seven hours
later, there
was nothing,
even as others
have commented
on the
impending
flogging of
this blogger.
On January 6,
Inner City
Press on
behalf of the
Free
UN Coalition
for Access
asked UN
Spokesman
Stephane
Dujarric about
attacks by
Turkey on
Dutch
journalist
Frederike
Geerdink whose
home in
Diyarbakir was
searched amid
dark
self-serving
of terrorism.
UN Spokesman
Dujarric
replied he
hadn't heard
of the case. Video here.
Also on
January 6,
FUNCA asked UN
Spokesman
Dujarric about
Kuwait
sentencing to
one year and
eight months
in jail Saqr
Al-Hashash for
insulting -
Tweeting
against -- the
Emir. The UN's
response was a
platitude. But
FUNCA will
continue.