UN
Evicts News
Agency of
Nigeria, FUNCA
Questions
Double
Standards
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS, June
4 -- The UN,
which since
its founding
has assigned
office space
to media to
cover it, has
thrown the
News Agency of
Nigeria out.
The Free
UN Coalition
for Access
opposes the
move,
particularly
since other privileged
media have
been allowed
to leave
their assigned
offices empty
and unused for
long periods
- the
rationale used
by the UN.
Since
the old UN
Correspondents
Association
board, rather
than defend
media, have
shown a
willingness to
try to get
other media
thrown out,
FUNCA soon
after its
founding asked
the UN to at
least be more
transparent in
its decisions
that impact
media,
including not
only
accreditation
but loss of
work space.
The
New
York Civil
Liberties
Union asked
the UN to
publicly
implement due
process rights
for the
journalists
which cover it
-- but the UN
has
yet to do so.
FUNCA
continues to
push for this,
and for
example for
the UN to
belatedly take
some action on
French
Ambassador Gerard
Araud, in the
middle of a UN
press
conference in
the UN Press
Briefing Room,
telling a
correspondent,
“You are not a
journalist,
you are an
agent.”
But the UN
would not
convey, even
in its
typically wan
fashion, the
stated
position that
correspondents
should
be treated
with respect
to Araud or
the French
Mission to the
UN. And UNCA,
the UN's
Censorship
Alliance,
"dragged its
feet,"
according to
the correspondent
to whom Araud
said, "You are
not a journalist,
you are an
agent."
Nigeria
is
a member of
the Security
Council; its
Permanent
Representative
Joy
Ogwu
held ten
question and
answer
stakeouts during
her presidency
of
the Security
Council in
April. (South
Korea held
only three
stakeouts
during its May
presidency,
by contrast.)
So why is the
News Agency of
Nigeria having
its UN work
space taken
away?
Here
is a flier the
Free
UN Coalition
for Access
put
out, soon
after its
founding,
about double
standards
(it referred
to a previous
configuration
of offices,
over the UN's
Dag
Hammarskjold
Library)
FUNCA
Asks a
Question:
Double
Standards
Much?
The
New York Times
has an office
inside of UN
Headquarters.
But its door
has been
closed,
without
opening, for
months. A
thick pile of
fliers,
months old,
clogs the
doorway.
There’s dust
everywhere.
But
the UN is
doing nothing,
because it
won’t apply
its rules
equally
to all.
In
fact,
reporters who
want to cover
the UN are
being denied
access to
UN
Headquarters –
on the grounds
that there’s
just not
enough
space to go
around. And
Big Media gets
handed big
offices that
some
of them never
even use.
The
UN’s media
guidelines say
that reporters
need to come
in the UNHQ
three times a
week in order
to keep their
office space.
It’s a
catch-22: if
you don’t have
an office, you
also can’t get
the
right kind of
press pass
that lets you
move freely in
and out of
Headquarters.
And
plenty of
small
newspapers
have lost
their desks
because they
couldn’t keep
up with the
attendance
requirement.
But of course,
these
standards
aren’t applied
across the
board: the New
York Times
hasn’t even
opened the
door to their
space since
October.
What
kinds of
conditions are
these? Is it
any wonder
that we see
less and
less reporting
on
international
affairs, or
that
newspapers
increasingly
rely on wire
services for
their news?
What other
options
are open to
small media?
UN
correspondents
have launched
the Free
United Nations
Coalition for
Access, a
group
dedicated to
guaranteeing
equal access
for all
reporters
looking to
cover the UN.
We
formed FUNCA
after a small
group of big
media – the UN
reporters
from Reuters,
AFP,
and Voice
of America
— banded
together to
try
and
dis-accredit
Inner City
Press, an
independent
news site that
produces
tough,
watchdog
reporting on
the UN.
Then
the head of
the UN’s
Peacekeeping
Department,
Herve Ladsous,
announced that
he was no
longer taking
questions
from Inner
City
Press – a
policy which
he has
bizarrely,
blithely kept
going for
months. This
means he
hasn’t had to
answer
questions
about, say,
the UN’s role
in allowing
rapes in the
Congo, or
working with
the
rapists, or in
bringing
cholera to
Haiti. Far
from putting
pressure
on him, most
of the UN
press corps
has sat by
silently and
let Mr.
Ladsous turn a
deaf ear to
all the tough
questions.
FUNCA
wants to fill
the press
freedom
vacuum. Right
now, we’re
advocating
along other
things for the
rights of
freelancers
who have been
denied
UN credentials
(even as other
freelancers
have
credentials
and big
offices).
We’re pushing
more UN
officials to
give on the
record
briefings to
the press
corps. And we
now work with
journalists
around
the world,
from
Somaliland to
Colombia to
Burundi - and
Nigeria.
Note
that despite a
commitment
that while
UNCA maintains
a glassed in
bulletin board
in front of
the large
office the UN
gives it --
while
News Agency of
Nigeria is
thrown out --
FUNCA can post
fliers on a
separate
board, not
glassed in,
recently these
have been torn
down,
including one
about the need
for the UN to
take action
after French
Ambassador
Araud told a
correspondent,
“You are not a
journalist,
your are an
agent.”
We are
inquiring into
these flier
tear-down,
just another
form of
censorship at
the UN.
Watch this
site.