By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
July 3 -- Is
it the
function of
journalists
ostensibly
covering an
institution to
provide photo-ops
for the head
of the
institution?
That's what's
happening at
the UN, where
a group called
the UN
Correspondents
Association
promoted
Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon's
appearance at
their soccer
game with
ambassadors
they also
purport to
cover.
While Ban did
a mere
ceremonial
kick-off, UNCA
pushed out
pictures of it
-- as it props
up that they
are close to
the UN -- and
predictably
the UN's own
UN News Centre
and UN
Spokesperson
Stephane
Dujarric and
even the UN's
main twitter
account did
the same.
And
on July 3,
France 24
showed
footage, even
after Dujarric
continued
dodging on the
UN flying
around the
leader of the
sanctioned
FDLR militia
Is this
appropriate?
Particularly
when Ban has
reneged on
previous
commitments to
hold monthly
on the record
press
conference,
replacing
these with
“press
encounters” of
which the
press is not
told until
afterward, and
even
interviews
with LinkedIn
- is this
appropriate?
It is
symbiosis: the
scribes want
to be seen as
having access,
and in this
case the group
UNCA
which has a
documented (by
FOIA) history
of trying to
get investigative
media thrown out of
the UN,
doing nothing
when the News
Agency of
Nigeria was
evicted from
the UN due to
a lack of
space when
the UN gives
UNCA a big
room that sits
empty and dark
most days --
UNCA is
grateful to be
promoted by
Ban's
spokesman. But
why is he
doing it?
The UN's
Office of the
Spokesperson
these days
even more than
before won't
give straight
answers, from
the Democratic
Republic of
the Congo
to Darfur
to South
Sudan,
while
increasingly
on the margins
of issues like
Iraq
and Ukraine,
it's now a
time for bread
and circuses.
Or rather for
softball
soccer between
UN-based
officials and
those who are
ostensibly
supposed to
hold them
accountable.
On July 2,
moments after
UN Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon's
spokesman
Stephane
Dujarric had refused
to explain his
inaccurate or
misleading
answer to
a Press
question about
the UN flying
a sanctioned
FDLR militia
leader around
the Democratic
Republic of
Congo on June
27 (Inner City
Press video
here), he
was invited to
play soccer or
football with
a group of
some
reporters. UN
Video here,
Minute 16:22.
This
group, the old
UN
Correspondents
Association,
in 2012
demanded the
censorship of
Inner City
Press
reporting on
its screening
in the UN of
Sri Lanka's
goverment film
denying war
crimes, which
noted
that UNCA's
President had
previously had
a financial
relationship
with Sri
Lanka's
Ambassador.
And there at
the game,
which the UN's
own Twitter
account
promoted along
with its
handpicked
scribes, the
former UNCA
president was
in his UNCA
jersey. To
whom is he
renting now?
UNCA itself promoted
without irony
or comment the
participation
of "Egypt
Ambassador
Mootaz
Ahmadein
Khalil" --
which push
came to shove,
or push-over,
there was no
mention of
#FreeAJstaff.
Here
was Ban with
Egypt's
Permanent
Representative,
here.
Now on July 3,
an UNCA board
member from
Reuters tries
to re-purpose
the
promotional
photograph
as....
Journalism is
not a crime. A
day late - and
this is the
same Reuters
which has via
a bogus
Digital
Millennium
Copyright Act
filing
gotten Google
to ban from
its Search a
copy of
Reuters "for
the record"
complaint trying
to get Inner
City Press
thrown out of
the UN. The
DMCA filing is
here, via
the Electronic
Frontier
Foundation's
ChillingEffects.org;
the
(now half
censored)
underlying
filing with
Dujarric is
here.
After
similarly
trying to get
removed from
the Internet
factual
coverage of
the UNCA
president's
diplomatic
rental income,
the UNCA
Executive
Committee not
only tried including
through
Dujarric
to get Inner
City Press thrown out of
the UN --
they also
refused to
implement any
reforms or
best practices
in its
relationships
those it is
ostensibly
covering.
Financial
relationships?
No problem,
apparently.
Nor has UNCA
adopted any
rule that it
will not seek
to censor or
get
journalists
thrown out of
the UN - it
continues as
the UN's
Censorship
Alliance.
So
Inner City
Press quit
UNCA, to whose
Executive
Committee it
had been
elected, and
it co-founded
the new Free
UN Coalition
for Access,
which is for
example
pushing for,
wonder of
wonders,
accurate
answers in the
UN Press
Briefing Room
by the UN
Spokesperson.
Typically,
when on April
15 outgoing
French
Ambassador Gerard
Araud right in
the Briefing
Room told a
Lebanese
reporter, who
had paid dues
to UNCA, that
"you are not a
journalist,
you are an
agent,"
UNCA dragged
its feet.
The Free UN
Coalition for
Access
formally asked
Dujarric to
convey to
Araud and the
French mission
the stated
position, that
accredited
journalists
should be
treated with
respect.
But Dujarric
declined.
This
is the context
of the
(softball)
soccer game
that UNCA
President
Pamela Falk
promoted,
including with
photographs
of a jersey
branded “UNCA”
just as she
(and Dujarric)
try to brand
each UN press
conference
with the name
“UNCA.”
And the UN's
main Twitter
account
promoted UNCA,
just as Ban's
UN gives a
large room
which sits
empty and dark
most days,
even as the UN
evicted the
News Agency of
Nigeria
claiming it
needed space.
Other
journalists
working at the
UN have no
workspace. But
UNCA's big
wigs need
space to
practice - to
flop?
They
said a
ceremonial
kick-off would
be performed
by Ban
Ki-moon, who
hasn't held a
press
conference in
New York in
months,
instead
faux "press
encounters"
and now an interview,
on LinkedIN.
And it was,
after Ban
Ki-moon left
an event on
the death
penalty, which
on his first
day he said is
a matter for
each member
state.
They whispered
that Ban's
senior adviser
Kim Won-soo
would play on
the
“Ambassadors”
team - and he
did.
Some
ambassadors
were told this
confab is of
all
journalists
covering the
UN -- it is
not. Several
Permanent
Representatives
asked Inner
City Press if
it or FUNCA
would
participate --
the answer is
no -- and some
more
questioned the
appropriateness
of the
marketing,
including by
the UN, and of
UNCA's
direction
generally. So
it goes - for
now: softballs
with censors.
Watch this
site.