On
Gaza, UN
Offers Canned
Statements
After
UNdisclosed
Gifted Travel
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
July 26, more
here -- As
the death
count in Gaza
rose after the
UN Security
Council's emergency
meeting on Sunday,
July 20, what
was the
response at
the UN?
Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon flew
around the region,
first on a
Qatar-funded
private jet,
then a Saudi
jet -- then
his
spokespeople
stopped
answering
Inner City
Press on whose
jet or dime
Ban was
flying.
At the
Security Council,
there was talk
about the
Jordan or Arab
Group draft
resolution.
But on July 24
on his last
day in the
Council,
French
Ambassador
Gerard Araud
said that no
vote had been
scheduled on
the draft.
When UN
Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon
finally spoke
in Cairo on
July 25, it
was about a
mere 12 hour
humanitarian
pause.
And
before any
press
questions, it
was said "Mr.
United Nations
Secretary-General
has to leave."
But where to?
On whose
plane? Because
the UN has
stonewalled,
the questions
have to be
asked and
pursued.
US Secretary
John Kerry, to
whom nearly
all of the
media
questions were
directed,
denied that
Israel's
cabinet had
voted down the
larger
proposal;
Kerry headed
to Paris to
meet with the
foreign
ministers
including
those of
Turkey and
Qatar.
But there, no
deal was
announced. Al
Jazeera put
online a draft
they said
Israel had
rejected; an
Israeli columnist
criticized
what he called
the draft
Kerry
submitted and
was
criticized.
One
issue was
whether a
ceasefire or
humanitarian
pause should
involved Israel
pulling its forces
out of Gaza.
But Ban,
flying on
undisclosed
aircraft,
issued canned
statements
that did not
address the
issue.
Intentions for
peace are not
enough.
On the most
basic
transparency,
at the July 25
noon briefing
Ban's deputy
spokesperson
Farhan Haq
refused to
tell Inner
City Press on
what kind of
plane, paid by
whom, Ban
traveled to
Cairo.
After
belatedly
telling Inner
City Press Ban
took a
Qatar-funded
private jet to
Doha, and
later a Saudi
plane, now the
UN won't
answer basic
questions
about Ban's
most recent
outside-funded
trips.
Ban's
announcement
was a shift
down from
remarks the UN
had sent out,
then
retracted. At
7:22 AM
Eastern Time
in the US,
Ban's Office
of the
Spokesperson
emailed out
Ban's
remarks.
Seven minutes
later at 7:29
AM they
e-mailed
again: "PLEASE
RETRACT -
Secretary-General's
remarks to
press in Cairo
have not been
delivered."
While not
required,
Inner City
Press decided
to hold off
reporting any
of this,
expecting Ban
to speak with
US Secretary
of State John
Kerry soon
thereafter.
Two hours
later, the
Wall Street
Journal's Jay
Solomon published
a story quoting
what Ban was
"expected to
say" --
"'On
this, the last
Friday of
Ramadan, I
call for an
immediate,
unconditional
humanitarian
pause in the
fighting in
Gaza and
Israel,' Mr.
Ban is
expected to
say Friday,
according to a
draft of his
prepared
comments. 'We
can build on
this
initiative by
supporting
international
efforts to put
in place the
elements of a
longer-term
cease-fire
plan.' A
spokesperson
for Mr. Ban
said the
transcript was
mistakenly
released by
the U.N. on
Friday.”
While still
awaiting Ban's
expected --
changed? --
remarks with
John Kerry (a
reporter on
the scene says
the UN flag
has been
placed and
replaced at
the site of
the press
availability),
it's worth
asking, how
does the UN
get "its"
press corp to
sit on Ban's
remarks
released, with
no embargo,
and then
"retracted"?
Inner City
Press has reported
on, and
the Free
UN Coalition
for Access seeks
to counteract,
this dynamic,
for
example here
when the UN's
Correspondents
Assocation -
known for more
than one
reason as the
UN's
Censorship
Alliance --
provided Ban
with a soccer
photo op.
Significantly
in these
pre-released
remarks, Ban
once again
cites the
bombing of the
UNRWA school
in Beit Hanoun
without saying
anything about
who did it -
despite for
example the
widely
reported
series of IDF
tweets. So
again: why was
Ban's
pre-released
statement sat
on?
The Free UN
Coalition for
Access also
asks: how can
it be that the
UN does not
disclose when
Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon
accepts free
travel on a
private jet,
and on July 24
would not tell
Inner City
Press how and
on whose plane
Ban flew to
Iraq? Video
here.
We
note that,
along with a Newsweek
piece that
credited
Inner City
Press'
exclusive,
Solomon is one
of two
reporters
trailing Kerry
who've asked /
tweeted about
Ban using the
Qatar funded
private jet.
Agence France
Presse reported
Ban's later
retracted
remarks, so
for without
correction.
But AFP did
not mention
Ban's silence
on who bombed
the UNRWA
school in Beit
Hanoun.
When Inner
City Press
asked UN
spokesperson
Haq about the
AFP report,
Haq said AFP
had been
spoken to. But
the report(s)
remained
online.
This follows
the UN's only
belated
acknowledgement,
after Inner
City Press
asked several
times, that
Ban began his
Gaza-related
tour by flying
on a
Qatar-funded
jet to Qatar,
then Cairo.
Bigger
picture, does
the UN, while
claiming to
abide by its
own stated
ethics rules,
simply not
have time for
them and waive
them?
When Inner
City Press
asked on July
23, UN Deputy
Spokesperson
Farhan Haq
said, if you
are here as a
lawyer,
"You're not
entitled to be
at the noon
briefing." Video here from Minute
4:26.
Here's the
July 24, 2014,
video:
On the audio
file, Haq
referred to UN
Radio. Here
it is, for
download at
mp3 - but it
cuts off the
question asked
of Ban about
the
Qatar-funded
plane, that
the State
Department
transcribed.
The
UN has previously
censored its
transcripts to
omit the
Free UN
Coalition for
Access and
what was said
to Ban; when
Haq answered
Inner City
Press that
Pakistani
journalist
Hamid Mir was
dead, he
"corrected"
this in the
transcript
without ever
telling Inner
City Press
that his
answer was
wrong, or had
been
"disappeared"
in the
transcript.
On July
24 after Inner
City Press
asked for
basic UN
financial
information --
last ten free
trips -- Haq
said, "You are
not a
prosecutor." Video here.
And here's the
July 23, 2014
video:
On
July 21, the
UN belatedly
answered Inner
City Press'
July 19
inquiry about
Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon
accepting a
free
Qatar-funded,
British
registered
private jet
for his
current travel
about Gaza. Video here and embedded below.
We'll have
more on this.
* * *
These
reports
are
usually also available through Google
News and on Lexis-Nexis.
Click here
for Sept 26, 2011 New Yorker on Inner City
Press at UN
Click
for
BloggingHeads.tv re Libya, Sri Lanka, UN
Corruption
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
UN Office: S-303,
UN, NY 10017 USA
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest service,
and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2014 Inner City Press,
Inc. To request reprint or other permission,
e-contact Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
|