In Other Media-eg New Statesman, AJE, FP, Georgia, NYT,  Azerbaijan, CSM Click here to contact us     .

By Matthew Russell Lee, Periscope

UNITED NATIONS, December 6 – Just how far into scandal and lack of transparency today's UN of Secretary General Antonio Guterres and his Deputy Amina J. Mohammed has fallen was on display on the morning of December 6. Inner City Press arrived at the UN, through the tourist entrance, at 9:15 am for the 9:45 am swearing-in of Guterres' "Global Communications" chief Alison Smale. But unlike all previous such swearings-in, including of Amina Mohammed before the UNanswered rosewood corruption scandal she is in, this one was Closed Press. Inner City Press could not get the reason from Smale or her Media Accreditation unit, which it informed it would Periscope broadcast from the UN lobby stakeout (which Smale's deputy seems to believe is not a stakeout). Heading up to the secret ceremony were Atul Khare, Catherine Pollard, Alicia Barcena and others. Periscope here. Is there a new script for the swearings-in? We'll have more on this. This as the Guterres and his DPI chief Alison Smale, set to belatedly be sworn in on December 6, ignored the calls of thousands as an environmental and corruption matter to investigate Amina Mohammed's UNanswered scandal of mass-signing certificates for endangered rosewood already shipped to China and as a media freedom matter to stop subjecting the Press which pursue UN corruption stories to more restrictions than other, some no-show, outlets. Smale has been on the job, or in the UN, since September. She has yet to respond to four separate inquiries despite in October saying she recognized the need to show the courtesy of a response. (Two days later her DPI issued a new threat to Inner City Press' accreditation). Guterres has yet to take questions on why his UN used $1 million from China Energy Fund Committee even after CEFC chief Patrick Ho was indicted for bribery in the UN. Amina Mohammed has refused to answer Press rosewood questions. Meanwhile Guterres is trying to sell purported reforms,When UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres presented his proposed "Management Reform" to the UN Fifth (Budget) Committee on December 4, along with the usual platitudes member states asked where the actual savings were and if Guterres has worked to get sufficient UN staff buy-in. The answer to the former is don't know; to the latter, no. On December 5, after Guterres
 spokesman Stephane Dujarric dodged Inner City Press' questions about the session, the UN Department of Public Information's Media Alert for December 6 did not provide notice of or access for Guterres' belated swearing in of his censor in chief at DPI, Alison Smale. Photos here. Inner City Press immediately wrote to the so-far UNresponsive Smale and Guterres, and MALU, with this: "Hello. The UN MALU Media Alert for December 6 has just been e-mailed out at 8:12 pm and Inner City Press has a question that it needs answered: SG Guterres' schedule for Dec 6 lists the swearing in of three senior officials including DPI's Alison Smale for 9:45 am. But DPI's Media Alert lists its first event at 10 am. Until now, swearings-in of USG have always been public, open to independent Press and in the Media Alert. Was this a mistake by DPI, or is there now even less transparency in this, as in other matters, by the UN? Inner City Press and FUNCA need to know now, to plan arrival at MALU at 9:15 am for the 9:45 am swearing in. This also informs you, as Maher Nasser was informed on the record in August, that the no-show, no-question Egyptian state media Akhbar al Yom assigned Inner City Press' long time shared work space S-303 has not come in in weeks, and has asked a single question in two years. Reversal is required." Watch this site. On December 4 in the Budget Committee Guterres' Deputy Secretary General Amina J. Mohammed, who has refused for a full month to answer Press questions about signing 4000 certificates for endangered rosewood already exported from Nigeria and Cameroon to China, wasn't there. But in the back row was long-time UN official Alicia Barcena. Next to Guterres was Cameroon's Ambassador Tommo Monthe, now joining Guterres' Department of Public Information under Alison Smale in issuing Press threats due to coverage. Earlier on December 4 Guterres' spokesman had said he had done nothing for the past two days to look into, as he'd promised, threats in Cameroon by Monthe's boss 35-year ruler Paul Biya. There's no reform there, nor in the UN. At an event later on December 4, UN staff openly complained about Guterres' lack of energy, lack of transparency, lack of inspiration. Members states can't be as honest, at least not with Smale's UNTV broadcasting, except from a breakdown in Australia's microphone, in Conference Room 1. But off-camera amid corruption scandals and arrogance, and Press censorship, the reviews are getting increasingly negative. Now Guterres and its seems Mohammed are set up to be sold for $1200 on Wall Street on December 15, even amid these scandals including China Energy Fund Committee, just like Ban Ki-moon was, at the annual outrage in which access to Ban was sold to now-convicted briber Ng Lap Seng. We'll have more on this. It was for coverage of this connection that the UN evicted and now under Guterres, Mohammed and Smale still daily restricts Inner City Press. We'll have more on this. Back on November 10 when Guterres presented his proposed “peace and security” reform to the General Assembly in UN Conference Room 2 on November 9, it was initially going to be in a closed meeting. Inner City Press asked about it two days in a row and, an hour before the meeting, it was changed to open “but no UN webcast.” (But see below). Then on November 10, when Guterres and his Deputy Amina J. Mohammed already then embroiled in the "Rosewood Racket" scandal touching on not only Nigeria but also Cameroon, presented their development reform proposals in ECOSOC, Inner City Press could only cover it with a minder. Other correspondents could go there freely - but did not. Even with the minder still required by the UN Department of Public Information's Alison Smale, the UN Security officer in front of ECOSOC indicated he'd make sure Inner City Press remained "minded," even as tourists wandered freely. This is censorship. Inside ECOSOC, questions included what the role of states would be in appointing Resident Coordinators? Ecuador for the Group of 77 said the process must be transparent - on a day the UN canceled its noon briefing, and did not answer Inner City Press' e-mailed questions. Mexico said it wants ECOSOC to be more of debate or deliberative body. The US spoke (briefly) against duplication and waste. In the middle of this, Mohammed tweeted about the Sahel: a robo-tweet? The duo, set to leave New York, left with UN Security and entourage, no answers. Earlier on November 10 Guterres has gotten even less transparent. When he left a media stakeout for which the day's noon press briefing was canceled after a mere three questions, none on Yemen much less Cameroon, it was not disclosed where he was going. Guterres' public schedule did not list anything after this. But it emerges Guterres is at the Lotte Palace Hotel, in the Villard Ballroom on the second floor. Previously, Guterres' spokesman Stephane Dujarric has refused to tell Inner City Press with whom Guterres had a one on one lunch meeting on the 38th floor of the UN before flying off on the public dime to his home in Lisbon. But how could this one not be on his public schedule? Dujarric, before refusing to answer any follow up questions, told Inner City Press, "The UN70 is a group of member states and they are organizing the retreat. It’s an internal meeting." In the Lotte Palace, tweeted by at least six states? On November 9, Inner City Press told the UN it would Periscope and was led to the photo booth; there due to Kafka-esque threats from the UN, it unilaterally decided only to broadcast what Guterres, paid by the global public, said. It was a mouthful: Guterres called Kenya's Ambassador Kamau “sincerely unfair; as the meeting was gaveled closed he turned on his microphone to tell Djibouti how support to AMISOM in Somalia would be effected. Russia raised many questions; others provided rote support. Reviews afterward were mixed. But Inner City Press remains under restrictions imposed by the UN Department of Public Information 20 months ago for covering UN corruption. It raised the issue again to the head of DPI on November 9; watch this site. When  Guterres held his pre-General Assembly week press conference on September 13, Inner City Press asked him about reform, in light of the Ng Lap Seng UN bribery guilty verdicts and new reports of peacekeepers' sexual abuse. Guterres responded on the latter, see below. Now a month later, Guterres is pitching a reform plan that many do not understand, and others don't agree with. Inner City Press went to cover Guterres' presentation to the UN's Fifth (Budget) Committee on October 11, but was quickly told by UN Security, "No Press." So it went to the photo booth and streamed a Periscope video, here. Guterres sat next to Cameroon's Ambassador, here. There were speeches by Ecuador, Trinidad and Tobago (fresh off its elimination of the US from the World Cup), the EU and Australia. Then Guterres left, before the US spoke. There was nothing else on his schedule for the day. We'll have more on this. Here's a sample Guterres "reform" proposal: "A Standing Principals’ Group of Under Secretaries General (USGs) and the EOSG, to provide leadership for all strategic, political and operational functions and ensure a coherent 'whole-of-pillar' approach... Interaction with the global operational support and management departments would be facilitated at the level of the Standing Principals’ Group as well as through dedicated capacity within the Departments at the strategic and operational levels, including within the integrated operational team [IOT] concept." Sources close to Guterres exclusively complain to Inner City Press this is little more than "Lacroix' DPKO trying to grab the IOTs." They point to the lame duck status of Jeffrey Feltman at the Department of Political Affairs as leading to DPA "losing the turf war with Peacekeeping." Meanwhile, the sources say, there is increasing frustration on the UN's 38th floor at the "message" not getting out, even talk of hiring outside communicators, rather than holding those already getting paid accountable. The new head of Global Communcations, Alison Smale, never responded to a detailed petition to her before the General Assembly week, nor to one after the week - nor since (it was raised to her again on November 9). Ah, Communications, f/k/a DPI which evicted and still restricts Inner City Press which every day asks questions and reports, in favor of no-show state media like Egypt's Akhbar al Yom which has not asked a single question during Guterres' tenure. The UN is UNreformed. From the UN's September 13 transcript: Inner City Press: Matthew Lee, Inner City Press, on behalf of the Free UN Coalition for Access, hoping for readouts of your diplomatic merry-go-round upstairs during the GA week.  I want... you speak the lot about reforms. It's something I tried to ask at the stakeout but thanks for giving me the question. This case of John Ashe, who I know has deceased~-- may he rest in peace, but there was a court decision this summer in which basically it painted a picture of the UN as being quite susceptible to bribery. There was a Chin... a Macau-based businessman, Ng Lap Seng, was found guilty. So, I won't go through it all except to say, I wanted to know what your view of whether the UN... beyond just some reforms to the PGA's (President of the General Assembly) office, whether it has instituted enough reforms. Your... your... the former PGA yesterday sitting here said that there are crows picking around the side of the UN. There are a lot of business interests... basically, they try to buy their way into the UN by hooking up with a small state.  So, I wanted to know whether your reforms will address that. And there's also a Code Blue report out today about sexual abuse where they say that, of cases they've uncovered, many of them are not disclosed in the conduct and discipline website. What's your plan during this GA week to try to address the sexual abuse issue of peacekeeping? Secretary-General:  Well, in addition to the sexual abuse, as you know, we have taken already a number of measures. A global victims advocate was appointed, and four victims advocates were appointed in the four situations that are more dramatic in several African contexts.  We are preparing a compact to be signed with Member States in order to make sure that there is effective commitment in relation to this. I'm creating a circle of leadership with Heads of Government and State to assume engagement of states in making sure that everything is investigated properly. And so, we are really committed to make the best we can in this area, knowing the difficulties and the problems and sometimes even the... especially, my main concern is with the victims that sometimes have an enormous problem in coming with their cases because of the risks that they might face in different conditions with the community or even with the country or even if the UN Mission is not properly organised. So, we are deeply committed to that.  But the best protection in relation to abuses is the whistleblower policy protection. We have introduced a first group of measures to enhance the whistleblower protection when I assumed functions immediately in January. So, it's probably my first measure.  And after that, we have introduced a number of other reforms, which I believe are bringing our whistleblower protection policy to the state of the art. And if that's not the case, if there are other things to be suggested, we are ready to introduce them, because that is the best guarantee that people can detect and denounce things that happen and that they will be protected if they do so. This is, for me, an absolute must and the best possible guarantee an organisation can have in relation to the risks of abuse of power or abuses of any other kind or of corruption or whatever.  So this is a big concern for me, and I think we are acting as we can but with total determination to address the problem." We'll have more on this.

***

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.

Feedback: Editorial [at] innercitypress.com

Past (and future?) UN Office: S-303, UN, NY 10017 USA
For now: Box 20047, Dag Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017

Reporter's mobile (and weekends): 718-716-3540

Other, earlier Inner City Press are listed here, and some are available in the ProQuest service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.

 Copyright 2006-2017 Inner City Press, Inc. To request reprint or other permission, e-contact Editorial [at] innercitypress.com for