At UN
High Level
Political
Forum US
Amendments
Shot Down As
UN Bans Press
By Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED NATIONS,
July 18 – For four days the UN
has hosted the “High Level
Political Forum on Sustainable
Development.” Inner City
Press, banned from the UN by
Secretary General Antonio
Guterres for two weeks and
counting for covering the July
3 meeting of the UN Budget
Committee, has tried to follow
it from outside the UN gates.
Fox News story
here,
GAP blogs I
and II.
On July 18,
after Guterres
gave a HLPF
speech, the US
proposed two
amendments to
Paragraph 28
of the outcome
document. The
first one, on
which Egypt
for the G77
called for a
recorded vote,
the US lost
with 50 yes to
its proposal,
107 against
and three
abstentions.
Then the US'
second
amendment, to
cut a
reference to
the World
Trade
Organization,
lost with only
Israel voting
with the US,
155 against
and three
abstentions.
On the
Ministerial
Declaration
overall, here
(see esp Paragraphs
28, 12 and 16)
on which the
US called for
a recorded
vote, it again
had only Israel
with it, with
164 votes
going the
other way, for
the document.
These were
referred to,
less than an
hour before
the vote, in
an event at
the Heritage
Foundation in
Washington
featuring
Nikki Haley.
We'll have
more on this.
On July 17 Inner City Press
was able to ask Swiss Federal
Councillor Doris Leuthard,
minister of the environment,
transport, energy and
communications, five
questions.
First,
Inner City Press asked
Leuthard what benefit, if any,
there would be to sustainable
development from Secretary
General Antonio Guterres' push
to grab the UN Resident
Coordinator system from UNDP
and give it to his deputy,
Amina J. Mohammed. (Neither
has answered Inner City Press'
questions about this or the
program budget implications,
choosing instead to physically
oust and now have their head
of DPI Alison Smale ban Inner
City Press for two weeks and
counting).
Leuthard replied that
“Switzerland supports the
reforms, this is a cross
cutting issue, a lot of
agencies have to collaborate.”
But when Inner City Press
asked if Switzerland will be
contributing to the fund
Guterres' change means he must
raise, she said, “On the
budget I have no idea, it's
the Ambassador,” gesturing at
Ambassador Jürg Lauber.
Inner City
Press is correctly identifying
Lauber, unlike Smale's former
employer the New York Times,
which at least initially
attributed his quotes to
Valentin Zellweger, Swiss
ambassador to the United
Nations in Geneva. See NYT
correction here;
Smale's NYT did not, however,
correct the inaccuracy that on
the migration compact, “Louise
Arbour, a longtime United
Nations diplomat from Canada
who is its special
representative for
international migration, was
responsible for leading the
process to create the
agreement.” Actually, Lauber
and Mexico's Ambassador Juan
José Gómez Camacho led the
process. But Smale sees fit to
have Inner City Press
physically assaulted and now
banned. Meanwhile the NYT
story bylined no fewer than
three NYT staff, Megan Specia,
Rick Gladstone and Satoshi
Sugiyama - not one of whom has
seen fit to report a single
word, or even ask a single
question, unlike The
Independent, about the
ouster and banning of Inner
City Press by their ex-NYT
colleague Alison Smale.
Inner City
Press next asked Leuthard
about Lauber chairing the UN
Peacebuilding Configuration on
Burundi, another question
Inner City Press was told to
ask the Ambassador himself,
“we are in different
departments.”
Finally, Inner City
Press asked Leuthard about the
carbon impacts of flying to
the conference, and the
hypocrisy of the UN having on
the press floor Inner City
Press is banned from reporting
from garbage cans that purport
to separate for recycling cans
and bottles from garbage but
in fact mix it all up.
Leuthard replied and everyone
can do better, concluding that
“Without flying around we
can't move... From time to
time, you cannot avoid that.”
She was polite throughout, the
holding the press encounter
outside of the increasingly
corrupt and censoring UN was
appreciated. Leuthard will be
joining the UN UN "High-Level
Panel on Digital Cooperation,
so she will have to deal with
the UN censorship sooner
rather than later. Watch this
site.
***
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
UN Office: S-303,
UN, NY 10017 USA
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other,
earlier Inner City Press are listed here, and some are available in
the ProQuest service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright
2006-2015 Inner City Press, Inc. To request reprint or other
permission, e-contact Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
for
|