UNITED NATIONS,
June 4 – Even seventeen hours
after the London Bridge
attacks, from the UN, its
Secretary General Antonio
Guterres and his spokesman
(other than a retweet not of
his boss but London's Mayor)
there remained radio silence.
As for example Donald Trump's
near-immediate linkage of the
attack to his proposed travel
ban was widely debated, still
after eighteen hours Guterres'
last three tweets were about
the Paris Agreement and
climate action. For 12 hours
his spokesman Stephane
Dujarric's last was at 8 pm on
Saturday in New York, about
the French consulate in New
York being empty.
Then, after critique, Dujarric
sprang to life with a retweet,
not of any UN official but of
London's Mayor. Finally after
18 hours, Dujarric emailed out
this: "The Secretary-General
strongly condemns the
terrorist attacks in London
last night. He expresses his
condolences to the families of
the victims and wishes the
injured a swift recovery. He
hopes that those responsible
for this unjustifiable
violence will be quickly found
and brought to justice. The
Secretary-General expresses
his solidarity with the people
and the Government of the
United Kingdom as they fight
terrorism and violent
extremism. This is a struggle
in many parts of the globe
that compels the international
community to join up efforts
to bring to justice those who
use such inhuman tactics while
also protecting and promoting
the fundamental values, rights
and principles that terrorists
so fervently seek to
undermine. Stephane Dujarric,
Spokesman for the
Secretary-General, New York, 4
June 2017." Inner City
Press has repeatedly asked
Dujarric for simple
information such as, Where IS
the Secretary General? On what
continent? What Dujarric
doesn't answer, at least not
the Press he chose to throw
out of the UN Press Briefing
Room and the UN, where he
still keeps it restricted.
Today's UN is not living up to
the most basic standards.
While there was talk of UN
reform when Guterres was
elected or selected as the
Secretary General to replace
Ban Ki-moon, now in another
example Guterres is proposing
to "freeze" new (and some old
but withdrawn) entries onto
the UN Children and Armed
Conflict list of shame. This
itself is shameful, a caving
to the Saudi-led Coalition
that continues airstrikes
leading to famine and cholera
in Yemen. On June 2, Inner
City Press asked Guterres'
Deputy Spokesman about it, video here, UN transcript here:
Inner city Press: I
wanted to ask you about the
Children and Armed Conflict
mandate. As I'm sure you
know, Secretary-General is the
addressee at least of a letter
of 41 non-governmental
organizations urging him not
to freeze the list. Is
it true that he intends to… in
order to not address,
apparently, the Saudi-led
Coalition issue and other
issues, to issue a report with
no new individual… no new
parties on it? And if
so, what would you say to
those that basically this is a
rollback of human rights
name-and-shame by the UN?
Deputy Spokesman: Well,
first of all, my basic point
is that this is a report
that's still in the process of
being written. The
information for it is still
being collected. Unlike
previous years, there's a few
more months that will be given
to the writing and composition
of this report given the fact
that there's a new head of the
office on children and armed
conflict, Virginia
Gamba. And so, we expect
the report to come out much
later this summer. I'd…
so I'd urge you to wait until
then, and we can then judge
the report on its
contents. It's clear
that the office is trying to
write as strong a report as it
can, and it's trying to
evaluate the information that
it receives. So, we'll
have a bit more decision down
the line about what it comes
up with.
Inner
City Press:
When Ms. [Leila] Zerrougui
left and before Ms. Gamba
came, it was said from this
podium repeatedly that there's
an entire team working on it,
that there would be no delay
by having a new person.
Now has a decision been made
to delay? And if so, for
how long? And how does
it jive with what was said
previously?
Deputy Spokesman: Well,
you know, Ms. Gamba is now in
charge of the report.
She's trying to evaluate the
material, and so there will be
some more information being
accumulated. So, it's
not coming out right away in
June, but, like I said, closer
to where it's the end of the
summer. And we'll let
you know once it's ready about
that, but, at that point, you
can evaluate the report and
its annexes.
Inner
City Press:
But are these 41
non-governmental
organizations… they're totally
off-base saying… thinking that
the Secretary-General is at
least contemplating a
freeze? And if he is
contemplating it, can you
explain… can you address the…
the… the issues that they're
raising?
Deputy Spokesman: Well,
as is the normal case, you
know, we intend… or the office
intends to update its report
and its list to reflect
changes that have been made at
the country level. In
those cases where parties to
conflict have fulfilled their
commitments, including in
action plans, they'll be
delisted and a sustained
dialogue on ending and
preventing violations has
already been initiated with
parties who are at risk of
being listed in the
report. So, we are in
that dialogue, and we'll see
where that heads.
Inner
City Press:
But, is that… does that imply
that there's not a freeze for
people coming off the list,
but there will be a freeze for
people going on the list?
Deputy Spokesman: Well,
what it implies is, right now
at this stage, what we are
focusing on and the purpose of
this list is to have a change
in behaviour. When
parties are in danger of being
listed, what we're trying to
do is open a dialogue with
them about what they need to
do to improve their records,
and so, that process has
already begun. And we'll
see where we can get with
that.
Inner City Press: One
last one. Is the
Saudi-led Coalition in danger
of being listed? Would
you… is there a dialogue?
Deputy Spokesman: At
this stage, like I said, the
report is still being worked
on. I wouldn't be able
to talk about any specific
countries or specific
circumstances while we're in
that stage of preparation.
Its a
partial freeze: you can get
off, but no one will go on.
France's Ambassador Francois
Delattre, when Inner City
Press asked him on June 2, had
no answer, said "I will get
back to you." Video
here. Nor should
this be considered the
"preventive diplomacy" that
Guterres continues to speak
about, while ignoring such
tests as Cameroon, see below.
While most sell-outs of reform
are taking place with too
little push back in the UN
(Inner City Press which asks
about it, including of
Guterres himself,
continues to be restricted
to minders to even enter the
UN's 2d floor), in this case
we'll await Guterres' response
to the letter he's gotten from
41 groups: Amnesty
International, War Child
International, Norwegian
Refugee Council, Johns Hopkins
University, Terre des hommes,
Nonviolent Peaceforce, Human
Rights Watch, Physicians for
Human Rights, International
Rescue Committee, Defense for
Children
International/Palestine
Section, Save the Children,
Global Centre for the
Responsibility to Protect,
Roméo Dallaire Child Soldiers
Initiative, Child Soldiers
International, CRIN, Center
for Civilians in Conflict,
ChildFund Alliance and
InterAction. On
Cameroon, after Inner City
Press repeatedly asked
Guterres and his spokesman
about 34-year President Paul
Biya's Internet cut-off and
abuses, the UN's answer was
that its Central Africa envoy
Francois Lonseny Fall would be
visiting in May. It turns out
it will be in (early) June,
and it will be about Boko
Haram. And, representative of
the UN system as a whole, the
UN Committee on the Rights of
the Child when it met about
Cameroon's report on May 30
did not ask a single recorded
question about the Anglophone
areas, the Internet cut-off or
the GCE scam. It seems it is
today's UN that is a scam.
Marie-Therese Abena Ondoa,
Minister for the Promotion of
the Woman and the Family of
Cameroon, sung the praises of
the 34-year Paul Biya
government. The UN's
Rapporteur on Cameroon, the
former Minister of Health from
Togo, Suzanne Aho Assouma,
joined in the praise, as if
like France's Ambassador to
the UN told Inner City Press
the Internet cut off was never
heard of. Call it
FrancAfrique, reaching all the
way into today's UN
Headquarters. Also on May 30
Inner City Press asked
Guterres spokesman Stephane
Dujarric, UN transcript here:
Inner City Press: I wanted to
ask you, on Cameroon, you'd
said that in May Mr. Francois
Loncény Fall would be going to
the country. I don't
know if that's true. I
know that he's going in early
June. And I just wanted
to make sure that you were
referring to this meeting of
regional security that seems
to be almost entirely about
Boko Haram and [Central
African Republic]. Is
there anything… can you say
what his agenda is there and
if he's going to raise the
Anglophone issue?
Spokesman: I will check.
Eight
hours later, typically,
nothing. Cameroon's UN
Ambassador Tommo Monthe, who
told Inner City Press that
Paul Biya stands ready to cut
the Internet again, and
partied with UN Secretary
General Antonio Guterres'
Deputy SG and chief of staff
while singing songs for
Chantal Biya, is already at
the meeting Fall will attend.
Tommo Monthe is quoted, "We
need to exchange views on all
these insecurity situations
before we bring it back to the
UN during its forthcoming
general assembly session." On
May 29 Fall issued this canned
quote: "We will continue to
support efforts of the
subregion in its determination
to prevent, to combat and to
bring an end to the
uncontrolled flow of arms in
Central Africa. This would
strengthen confidence among
states and reassure the
population, the main victims
of this phenomenon, which is
also a hindrance to the
sustainable development of
Central Africa." This is the
focus on Lonseny Fall's
much-hyped visit to Yaounde,
while Guterres' Deputy SG and
chief of staff party with Paul
Biya's representative amid songs for Chantal Biya and
French champagne. We'll have
more on this. Well over a week
ago, Inner City Press asked UN
Secretary General Antonio
Guterres' holdover spokesman
Stephane Dujarric about
Cameroon administering in
areas to which it cut off the
Internet for 94 days a General
Certificate of Education test,
specifically citing UNESCO.
Dujarric said he would look
into it. Having received no
answer even as Guterres'
Deputy and Chief of Staff
appeared at Cameroon's
(boycotted) national day, on
May 23 Inner City Press asked
again about this, and Amnesty
International's press
conference on 10 year
sentences to students (whose
jokes included the GCEs) being
shut down. After Dujarric on
May 25 had no answer on this,
on May 26 Inner City Press
asked his deputy, Farhan Haq,
UN transcript here:
Inner City Press: Do you have
anything on Cameroon and
Amnesty, the closing down of
the Amnesty press conference
about 10-year jail sentences
for students that I asked
Stéphane about two days ago?
Deputy Spokesman: What
we can say is simply that we
hope that the freedom of
expression and freedom of
assembly will be respected in
Cameroon. Have a good
weekend, everyone.
That's it?
On May 24 Dujarric said he had
an answer from UNESCO - that
he never provided to Inner
City Press, and apparently
would never have, if not asked
again. From the UN transcript:
Inner City Press: today in
Yaoundé, Cameroon, Amnesty
International had scheduled a
press conference about three
teenager students sentenced to
ten-year prison sentences for
joking in text messages about
Boko Haram. So, I wanted
to know, they… basically, this
was closed down. The press
conference was
disallowed. Many human
rights groups have said it's
an outrage. And I noticed
yesterday evening, the Deputy
Secretary-General and the Chef
de Cabinet were both at the
National Day of Cameroon on
73rd Street in New York.
So, I wanted to know, what
does the UN think of… of this
country that just recently
celebrated its National Day
with these two officials
shutting out Amnesty
International, sentencing
students to ten-year prison
sentences…
Spokesman: I'll look
into the case. I have
not…
Inner City Press: Did
you ever look into the testing
thing? I'd asked you
about administering a test…
Spokesman: Yes, I think…
we were given some guidance by
UNESCO...
Now here it is:
"Your question on the Cameroon
tests: Regarding a previous
query on a test being
administered in the Anglophone
regions of Cameroon despite
the regions being affected by
school closures and a internet
blackout, while this is not an
issue covered by UNOCA, but
rather UNESCO, UNOCA has
informed that there have been
reports of abstentions from
the examinations in the North
West and South-West regions of
the country. We are not aware
of any reports of these tests
being taken at gunpoint.
Nonetheless it is of concern
that these examinations
[General Certificate of
Education] were held, despite
school closures and the
internet blackout for over
three months, which disrupted
normal activities. However
that is an issue for the
relevant national authorities
to respond to. UNOCA, in close
cooperation with the Acting
Resident Coordinator, is
monitoring the situation in
the North West and South West
regions of Cameroon and will
continue to liaise with the
authorities to promote a
peaceful resolution to the
grievances of the Anglophone
population."
While the UN
Security Council visited
Cameroon during the 94 day
Internet cut off and said
nothing publicly about it (but
see below), Inner City Press
has obtained and has
exclusively published
on Patreon and now Scribd,
here Cameroon's "Urgent
and Confidential" letter to
the UN Security Council, about
weapons. On May 23, Inner City
Press went to the New York
event for Cameroon's
"National" Day, which was
boycotted in the Anglophone
regions of the country. In New
York, however, UN Deputy
Secretary General Amina J.
Mohammad and Antonio Guterres'
Chef de Cabinet Maria Luiza
Ribeiro Viotti attended, along
with French Permanent
Representative to the UN
Francois Delattre, Burundi's
Albert Shingiro and others.
Video here.
Periscope
inside was not possible due,
ironically, to a lack of
Internet. There were toasts in
French for Chantalle Biya and
for the UN officials; on the
way out UN staffers told Inner
City Press it was sure to
criticize them. What matters,
as always, is what happens
going forward. Italy is a
member of the Security Council
this year, and on the morning
of May 18 including in light
of Italian President
Mattarella's meetings this
year with Cameroon's 34 year
president Paul Biya, Inner
City Press asked Italy's
Mission to the UN: "your
Mission was part of the
Security Council's trip
including to Cameroon earlier
this year, during the
country's 94-day Internet shut
off to millions of people in
the Northwest and Southwest
(or Anglophone) regions. The
IMF, for what it's worth, told
Inner City Press the
government's Internet cut off
is among other things a
financial risk in 2017. Could
you comment on your Mission's
aware of the issue, during the
Security Council visit to
Cameroon and since, and on
whether you believe the
Secretary General and DPA, as
a matter of prevention of
conflict, may have a greater
role to play in this
long-standing, UN-related
conflict or dispute?" Eight
hours later, the Italian
Mission's spokesperson
Giovanni Davoli replied on
Cameroon that "the situation
you are mentioning was not in
the agenda of the UNSC visit."
To his credit, Swedish
diplomat Carl Skau tells Inner
City Press, "I can confirm
that the issue was raised by
the delegation in meetings."
Now Italy's spokesman insists,
"I confirm: it was not in the
agenda of the visit. Whether
it was raised, it is another
matter on which I have no
elements." Meanwhile, party in
interest France has yet
to respond, while
Emmanuel Macron is in Mali.
We'll have more on this. On
May 17, Inner City Press asked
UN Secretary General Antonio
Guterres' spokesman Stephane
Dujuarric what if anything
Guterres is doing about
Cameroon. From the UN transcript:
Inner City Press: there are
people saying that António
Guterres' strategy of being
Secretary-General is to sort
of downplay the peacemaking
powers of it and engage in
quiet diplomacy. And I
guess the reason I'm asking
you is just objectively
speaking, compared to the
previous administration, there
are many fewer readouts,
there's less… there's less
being said. Maybe it's
to the good. But, does
he believe that… that this
approach is bearing fruit, and
if so, what fruit can you
point to?
Spokesman: I think the
Secretary-General is a
believer in the need for
discreet contacts to be had in
order to resolve crisis.
And I think it's something I…
well, I think we've all
observed since he's come into
office. And I think it's
an important tool and not the
only tool, but it's an
important tool in the tools
available to the world's top
diplomat.
Inner City Press: I want
to ask this very specifically
because I've asked you this a
couple of times. I keep
hearing from people at various
high floors that, in fact, the
UN is concerned about Cameroon
and not just the Internet, but
what seems to be a case of
preventive diplomacy.
So, I wanted to ask you, is
there anything actually being
done? Am I missing some
secret work that the UN…?
Spokesman: I think if…
well, if it's secret, it's
secret. Mr. [Francois
Lonceny] Fall has been
following and is the point
person for the UN on this
issue.
Fall is
failing. Or, Fall is the fall
guy for Guterres. Now there is
the use of what residents call
another weapon: the
devaluation and even
destruction of the GCE
education system, by
purporting to administer the
test after a period where no
instruction or learning took
place. UNESCO has said
nothing, just as the UN stayed
quiet during the Internet cut
off. On May 15, Inner City
Press asked the UN's holdover
spokesman Stephane Dujarric,
video here,
UN transcript here:
Inner City Press: In hearing
UNESCO [United Nations
Educational, Scientific and
Cultural Organization], I've
been meaning to ask you
this. There's a
controversy in Cameroon where
a school… a test is being
administered today in the
areas that didn't have
internet for 94 days and the
schools were closed. And
a lot of people are saying the
test… it's basically to
destroy the Anglophone
education system, and people
are taking a test at
gunpoint. And many
people there said UNESCO said
nothing. I don't know
whose role it is. Is it
[Francois] Loncény Fall?
Is there anyone in the UN
system that's looking at
what's taking place there…?
Spokesman: I'll take a
look that report. Okay.
Thank you.
We'll see.
Some in UN headquarters
approach Inner City Press
where they can, since the UN
Department of Public
Information still restricts
the Press, and say there's
concern "upstairs" about
events in Cameroon. But
despite the claimed focus on
preventative diplomacy, where
is there UN action on this?
Despite the restrictions,
Inner City Press will be
pushing forward with the
story. Watch this site and this one, where it
is reported that France
blocked any European Union
action on Cameroon and Paul
Biya's 94-day cut off of the
Internet in the Anglophone
regions, in part to keep its
hand in to compete
economically with China in
"its" FrancAfrique. When the
EU's Federica Mogherini came
to the UN Security Council
stakeout on May 9 for
questions, no Press questions
on Cameroon were allowed,
similar to Antonio Guterres'
spokesman disallowing
the question three times at
the recent joint African Union
stakeout. Nor was the Cameroon
question Inner City Press submitted
to Guterres' paid-entrance,
not livestreamed London
Q&A posed. We'll have more
on this.
This comes amid
reports that armaments
Cameroon got ostensibly to
fight Boko Haram have been
spotted in the Anglophone
regions. On May 2 when Inner
City Press told the UN's
spokesman Stephane Dujarric
that it had a question on
Cameroon, he walked off the
podium, as he has done before.
He and the UN Department of
Public Information, whose
Cameroon mis-information is
profiled below, worked
together to evict and still
restrict Inner City
Press.
***
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
UN Office: S-303,
UN, NY 10017 USA
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other,
earlier Inner City Press are listed here, and some are available in
the ProQuest service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright
2006-2015 Inner City Press, Inc. To request reprint or other
permission, e-contact Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
for
,
