On
Mali, Koenders
on Dutch
Copters, Rape
Probe Not
Finished But
Foretold
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS, April
23 -- Back in
January
regarding gang
rape charges
against UN
peacekeepers
in Mali the UN
told Inner
City Press, "the
Government of
Chad has
further
advised the
Department of
Peacekeeping
Operations
that it has
completed the
national
investigation."
On April 9,
Inner City
Press asked
DPKO chief
Herve Ladsous
what
the results of
the completed
investigation
had been, but
he refused to
answer, click
here for that.
And so on
April 23 Inner
City Press put
the question
to the UN's
Mali envoy Bert
Koenders. More
than three
months after
the DPKO told
Inner City
Press the
investigation
was completed,
Koenders said
it will only
be finished in
"two or three
weeks." Video
here, from
Minute 3:39.
Even though by
his account
the
investigation
is not
finished, he
said "we have
found very
little
evidence of
sexual violence
by Chadian
troups... at
first glance
some of the
accusations
have not bee
proven."
While Koenders
unlike Ladsous
at least purported
to respond to
this question,
and one about
Dutch attack
helicopters
bound for Mali,
there is a
lack of clarity.
Beyond the
"completed"
investigation
by Chad, is
there another,
UN
investigation?
Are there preliminary
findings based
on which
Koenders said
what he did?
As with the
rapes in Minova
in the
Democratic Republic
of the Congo
by DPKO's
partners in
the Congolese
Army, we will
continue to
pursue this
issue.
Inner City
Press also
asked about
the five Dutch
helicopter's
Mali's foreign
minister Abdulaye
Diop had told
it about
earlier in the
morning.
Koenders said,
"We welcome
contribution
of Dutch
government,"
specifying
three Apache
attack
helicopters in
May, and two
transport
helicopters in
September or
October.
Koenders cited
all
information
fusion, being
the ears and
eyes on
extremist
groups.
Earlier, Inner
City Press
asked Foreign
Minister Diop
if such
information
will be shared
with his
government, or
only within
MINUSMA and
its troop
contributing
countries.
Diop said he
didn't know.
So this, too,
will require
clarification
As an aside,
later on April
23 the UN's
envoy to
Somalia
Nicholas Kay
complained of
the lack of
helicopters
from the
AMISOM
mission. It
left one
wondering
about how the
UN is run: did
the
Netherlands
give the
copters to
Mali because
one of its
nationals is
the UN's envoy
there? We hope
to have more
on this.
On April 23
when Inner
City Press
asked Malian
foreign
minister Diop
for an update
on dialogue in
Kidal, and on
the stated
investigation
of the
shooting of
civilian
demonstrators
there, he replied
that he is too
new in the
position to
answer on the
probe. He said
there is a new
chief
negotiator for
the armed
groups and
what he
called, in a
Nixonian
phrase, the
"silent
majority."
Where did the
last ten weeks
go?
Back on
January 16 the
UN
Spokesperson's
Office sent
Inner City
Press this
response,
which does not
answer
the question
of
accountability.
But here it
is, in full:
Subject:
Your
question on
Mali
From: UN
Spokesperson -
Do Not Reply
[at] un.org
Date: Thu, Jan
16, 2014 at
3:23 PM
To:
Matthew.Lee
[at]
innercitypress.com
In
response to
your question
about the
follow-up to
the
allegations of
sexual assault
by United
Nations
peacekeepers
in MINUSMA in
September
2013, we have
received the
following
information:
The
Department of
Peacekeeping
Operations
officially
notified the
Government of
Chad of these
allegations in
late
September. The
Government of
Chad
officially
responded,
saying that it
would take
responsibility
for the
investigations.
The Government
of Chad has
further
advised the
Department of
Peacekeeping
Operations
that it has
completed the
national
investigation,
and the United
Nations awaits
advice on the
outcome of the
investigations
and follow-up
accountability
measures as
appropriate.
The UN is
waiting for
"advice" --
but will it
ever make it
public? How
else can the
UN's stated
Human Rights
Due Diligence
Policy be
assessed?
On January 17,
Inner City
Press asked UN
acting deputy
spokesperson
Farhan Haq
about it. From
the UN's
transcript,
video
here and
embedded
below:
Inner
City Press: On
Mali, I wanted
to thank you
for this
written answer
you gave
yesterday
afternoon that
Mali has said
that its
completed its
investigation
of the alleged
rape in Mali
by the Chadian
troops. And it
said that the
UN awaits
advice on the
outcome of the
investigation.
And what I
wanted to know
is whether…
what part of
that is going
to be made
public, given
both the human
rights due
diligence
policy,
etcetera? I
appreciate you
saying that
the
investigation
is finished,
but, has… did
they clear the
soldiers? Were
the soldiers
found guilty?
Where does it
stand?
Acting
Deputy
Spokesperson
Haq: As we
emailed to
you, the
Mission does
await advice
on the outcome
of the
proceedings.
We know that
there have
been
proceedings
regarding the
case. You know
this is a case
regarding
sexual assault
and so, we
await further
information
from that.
We’ll try to
make public
what we can of
the
information
that we
receive.
Inner
City Press:
So, they
literally just
told you that
it’s complete,
but…no
indication on
what was done?
I guess I
wonder when --
Acting
Deputy
Spokesperson:
The
information I
have in the
email that was
sent to you is
the
information we
have. If we
have any
further
updates, we’ll
share it with
you at that
point.
Two
weeks later,
nothing. So
what will
members of the
Security
Council ask,
find and make
public?
One of the
UN's other
too-few
criticisms of
military
action in
north Mail,
the shooting
into a crowd
of protesters
in Kidal on
November 28,
was disputed
in the
Security
Council on
January 16.
In a statement
prepared like
a defense
attorney,
trying raise
reasonable
doubt, Mali's
Permanent
Representative
Sekou Kasse
said that the
UN Mission
MINUSMA
elements
closest to the
shooting were
400 meters
away,
precluding
them from
"objective"
testimony.
The argument
made was one
must wait for
the ballistic
analysis
ordered by the
Malian
government
itself.
Inner
City Press
asked Mali's
foreign
minister on
April 23.
Watch this
site.
* * *
These
reports
are
usually also available through Google
News and on Lexis-Nexis.
Click here
for Sept 26, 2011 New Yorker on Inner City
Press at UN
Click
for
BloggingHeads.tv re Libya, Sri Lanka, UN
Corruption
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
UN Office: S-303,
UN, NY 10017 USA
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest service,
and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2014 Inner City Press,
Inc. To request reprint or other permission,
e-contact Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
|