Among
with UN
Impunity, Its
Censorship
Inconsistent
With NY Law
& Values
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
December 6 --
When Mayor
Bill de
Blasio's
Commissioner
for
International
Affairs Penny
Abeywardena took
questions
about the
United
Nations'
impact on New
York City on
December 6,
there was an
initial joke
about parking
tickets, as if
that would be
the extent of
issues New
Yorkers might
care about.
But
while the
City's study
enumerates
people
directly
employed by
the UN
Community,
their lack of
labor and
other rights
due to
immunity was
not
acknowledged
in the study.
Inner City
Press covers
both the UN
and its
headquarters
city, New
York, and
routinely
receives
complaints
from
diplomats'
domestic
workers and
drivers about
work place
abuse and lack
of benefits,
and the lack
of any
recourse. Due
to immunity,
not only
defrauded
workers but
those subject
to physical
abuse are left
without
rights.
What about the
UN having
brought
cholera to
Haiti and
killed 10,000
people,
leaving sorrow
and economic
harm in many
New York City
communities -
does the de
Blasio
administration
have a
position on
that?
Abeywardena
did not
answer,
leaving the
question for
the UN
moderator
Cristina
Gallach.
But Gallach,
as mentioned
even in the
New York Times,
is responsible
for the ouster
and eviction
of the
investigative
Press from the
UN, and its
confinement to
minders to
cover events
on the UN's
second floor
for the past
nine months
and for the
foreseeable
future.
Gallach
is giving
Inner City
Press'
longtime
shared UN
office to an
Egyptian state
media, Akhbar
al Yom, which
rarely comes
into the UN
and never asks
any questions.
Abeywardena
answered Inner
City Press'
second round
of questions
by saying the
City works
with the UN on
such issues as
testing for
Legionnaires
Disease -
something
legally
required for
(other)
buildings in
New
York.
We
question
whether the
City
administration
is doing or
should do
anything to
ensure that
the UN lives
up to the
basic
principles,
applicable
right outside
the UN's
gates, of
press freedom
and due
process.
Gallach's
pretext for
throwing Inner
City Press out
and
restricting it
since was
Inner City
Press' attempt
to cover an
event in the
same UN Press
Briefing Room
on January 29,
as part of its
coverage of
the ongoing Ng
Lap Seng UN
bribery case
set for trial
in the US
District Court
for the
Southern
District of
New York in
January 2017.
Inner
City Press
left the
briefing room
- which had no
“closed” sign
on it - as
soon as a
single UN
Security
officer said
to, at the
request of UN
spokesman Stephane
Dujarric.
But three
weeks later,
without once
speaking with
Inner City
Press, Gallach
ordered it
out on two
hours notice.
When Inner
City Press was
physically
thrown out
onto First
Avenue on
Gallach's
orders on
February 19,
2016 (audio
here) and
its laptop
thrown onto
the sidewalk,
it called the
New York
Police
Department,
which said it
had no
recourse at
all, the UN
controls even
the sidewalk
in front of
it.
While
the UN certain
does some good
work, is this
censorship and
impunity
something New
Yorkers should
be represented
as supporting?
We'll have
more on this.