Coinbase
Brooks at OCC Will Not Regulate Entities
Or Obey SDNY or CRA Now True Lender
By Matthew
Russell Lee, Patreon
BBC
- Guardian
UK - Honduras
- CJR -
PFT
UN GATE / SDNY
COURT, Sept 1 – Acting U.S.
Comptroller of the Currency
Brian Brooks, as Coinbase’s
chief legal officer, was
paid $1.4 million in salary --
separate from the stock
options -- in the year and a
half he spent with company,
which had weighed seeking a
charter through the OCC before
making other moves to access
the banking system."
Now Brooks
says, "I'm increasingly
thinking of this agency as an
activities regulator, not an
entity regulator." But since
the Community Reinvestment Act
is enforced with regard to
entities, this is an even more
egregious attach on CRA than
Otting engaged in. Combined
with Brooks open contempt for
rulings of the U.S. District
Court for the Southern
District of New York, it shows
why he should be removed as
Comptroller.
Now "[a]
proposal by the regulator of
the nation’s largest banks
would allow predatory lenders
to do an end-run around state
interest rate caps, exposing
people to high-cost loans with
minimal consumer protections,
according to a comment letter
being submitted today to the
Office of the Comptroller of
the Currency (OCC) by 13
national consumer and civil
rights groups. Most of these
groups also joined a shorter
comment letter being submitted
today by more than 100
community based organizations
across the
country.
The Center for Responsible
Lending, National Consumer Law
Center (on behalf of its low
income clients), Americans for
Financial Reform Education
Fund, Consumer Action,
Consumer Federation of
America, the Leadership
Conference on Civil and Human
Rights, NAACP, National
Association of Consumer
Advocates, National
Association for Latino
Community Asset Builders,
National Coalition for Asian
Pacific American Community
Development (National CAPACD),
Public Citizen, UnidosUS, and
U.S. PIRG strongly oppose the
OCC’s “true lender”
rule.
The proposed rule would
facilitate fraudulent
predatory “rent-a-bank”
schemes where a non-bank
lender launders a loan through
a bank (which is not subject
to state rate caps) in
order to charge interest rates
beyond what state law
allows.
The OCC’s proposal provides
that a bank “makes” the loan
and thus is the lender -- so
that state interest rate laws
do not apply -- so long as the
bank’s name is on the loan
agreement or the bank funds
the loan. This rule would
prohibit courts from looking
behind the fine print form to
the truth about which party is
running the loan program and
is the “true lender.” The head
of the agency has said that he
intends for this rule to
shelter rent-a-bank
arrangements from litigation.
Just days before the speech,
the District of Columbia
(D.C.) attorney general sued a
high-rate rent-a-bank lender,
Elevate, for violating state
rate caps; and California just
launched an investigation into
LoanMart, another rent-a-bank
lender. Currently, 45 states
and D.C. have interest
rate caps on at least some
installment loans to protect
residents from high-cost
predatory
lending.
The groups urged the OCC to
abandon its proposal in its
comment letter to the OCC.
But some
groups are even being blocked,
or Brooks-ed, from commenting
through Regulation.gov. Watch
this site.
On his
conflicts of interest, Inner
City Press asked - and then
requested under FOIA - what
are the "other tech firms" as
to which Brooks is
acknowledging a conflict.
The
OCC wrote to Inner City Press,
faux apologizing for
withholding information it has
requested about Otting until
after he had left the agency.
Inner City Press immediately
wrote back requesting a copy
of Brooks' ethics letter and
list of companies as to which
even he acknowledges a
conflict of interest.
On June
18, that simple request was
denied and so a FOIA request
was filed, see below.
And now
more than a month later on
July 22 the OCC has provide to
Inner City Press under FOIA a
copy of the ethics memo that
Brooks is recused on: Amazon
(minus AWS), Avant, Aventas,
Merrill Lynch, CoinBase,
EarnUp, Spring Labs, TextIQ -
and Citibank N.A. residential
mortgage business." We'll have
more on this.
From Inner
City Press' FOIA request:
"This is a request under FOIA
on behalf of Inner City Press
and in my personal capacity
for all records concerning
conflicts of interest or the
appearance of conflict of
interest by Acting Comptroller
Brian Brooks, including but
not limited to the Ethics
letter Inner City Press
requested from the OCC, below,
and Coinbase, Avant, OneWest
and any other firm.
Inner City Press in responding
to a request by OCC to "close
out" a FOIA request still not
completed asked "I do have an
OCC public information /
transparency question - for
the Acting Comptroller's
ethics filing - can it be sent
to me at
Matthew.Lee@innercitypress.com?
To identify it: "Brooks has
submitted a letter through the
agency's ethics office
outlining companies he'll
steer clear of because of
potential conflicts of
interest, including Amazon.com
Inc., Bank of America Corp.'s
Merrill Lynch unit, Coinbase
and a number of other tech
firms he's worked with." What
are those companies? Thanks,
-Matthew Lee, Inner City
Press" Days later and
minutes ago Inner City Press
received this: Good Morning
Mr. Lee.... I don't know
the answer to the question you
asked. You should file a
FOIA request for the records
you seek regarding the Acting
Comptroller. " This is that
request, on which expedited
treatment should be granted -
such disclosures are among the
very purposes of FOIA."
Watch this site.
Amid
all this, Fair Finance Watch
and Inner City Press /
Community on the Move have
launched a new project. And so
far, Brooks' national banks
have been among the worst.
Watch this site.
***
Your
support means a lot. As little as $5 a month
helps keep us going and grants you access to
exclusive bonus material on our Patreon
page. Click
here to become a patron.
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle
500 Pearl Street, NY NY 10007 USA
Past
& future at UN: Room S-303, UN,
NY 10017 USA
Mail: Box 20047, Dag
Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest
service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2020 Inner City
Press, Inc. To request reprint or other
permission, e-contact Editorial [at]
innercitypress.com
|