On
Palestine, Ban
on
Accountability
But Not ICC,
Transcript
Censored
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
July 9 -- When
UN Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon held a
rare press
availability
on July 9
about Israel
and Palestine,
Inner City
Press asked
Ban for his
position on
Palestine
joining the
International
Criminal
Court.
Here's
how the UN
transcribed
it,
compare to UN
Video, here, from
Minute 11:49
,,
Inner
City Press: I
wanted to know
- Mahmoud
Abbas has said
those who
feared courts
should refrain
from
committing
crimes.
This has been
interpreted as
basically a
statement that
they are
closer than
they were
before, going
to the
International
Criminal
Court.
And I wanted
to know, what
do you think
is the place
of
accountability
on both sides
and what would
you think of
Palestine
seeking to
join the
International
Criminal
Court?
SG Ban Ki-moon:
On many
occasions,
including this
time -
yesterday, I
had condemned
in the
strongest
possible terms
and I have
also asked
that the
perpetrators
should be
brought to
justice.
When it comes
to
accountability,
when it comes
to justice,
the United
Nations has
been
maintaining
and will
continue
maintaining
the same
principled
position –
that there
should be a
clear and firm
principle of
accountability
and justice
for any
perpetrators
of , of
course,
violation of
human rights
and
humanitarian
laws.
While
appreciated,
the ICC part
of the
question was
not answered.
Tellingly, the
UN in
transcribing
it took out
Inner City
Press' statement
that it was
good for Ban
to finally
take questions
this time, and
thanks from
the new
Free UN Coalition
for Access.
We note this
because the UN
chose to leave
in a reference
to the old UN
Correspondents
Association,
which as summarized
here
and documented
under the
Freedom of
Information
Act here
and here
has come to
function as
the UN's
Censorship
Alliance -- outright
censorship.
If the UN can't
accurately and
even-handedly
transcribe its
press
conferences,
what can it
do?
Ban
is set to
brief the
Security
Council on
July 10 at 10
am. Things are
moving fast. As
Inner City
Press reported
on July 7, the
issue of Hamas
has been
raised in UN
negotiations
of a
“ministerial”
text to
accompany the
High Level
segment of the
Economic and
Social Council.
There
is a
previously
agreed
Paragraph 24
about removing
obstacles to
development
for people
living
occupation, in
the UN phrase.
It was
agreed to last
year.
This
year the US,
Israel and
Canada have
proposed a new
Paragraph 25
essentially
about Hamas, a
source
exclusively
informed Inner
City
Press, saying
if “people
living under
occupation” is
in, the
anti-Hamas
language
should be
included too.
Inner City Press
asked Israel's
Ambassador Ron
Prosor about
it; he began
replying then
said that
Inner City
Press was
"pulling his
tongue." Watch
this site.