Nikola
Founder Milton Insists 30 Days Needed On
New Charge & New Emails Produced by US
By Matthew
Russell Lee, Patreon Video Podcast
BBC
- Guardian
UK - Honduras
- ESPN
SDNY COURTHOUSE,
June 27 – Just after the
indictment of electric vehicle
maker Nikola's founder Trevor
Milton was unsealed on July
29, 2021 a press conference
was held in the Southern
District of New York
prosecutors' office. Inner
City Press went and asked
about the SEC complaint's
reference to Milton targeting
"Robinhood investors." Video
here.
US
Attorney Strauss and her SEC
colleague (on the job for all
of one week) both deferred
comment on particular
companies or phenomena like
Robinhood, or Elon Musk, or
SPACs. But it seems there will
be more prosecutions coming -
including in the
crypto-currency space?
On
September 15, the assigned
District Judge Edgardo Ramos
held an oral argument. Milton
wants to move the case to Utah
or Arizona, with a sealed
motion. (Manafort's lender
Steve Calk asked the same, to
move to Chicago, which was
denied). On September 15 Inner
City Press live tweeted here
(and podcast here)
In March
2022, Milton withdrew his
Second Circuit appeal of
venue. On March 22, the US
Attorney's Office filed
a joint schedule: "Dear Judge
Ramos: The Government
respectfully writes to advise
the Court that the parties
have, following the dismissal
of the defendant’s
interlocutory appeal,
conferred and agreed to a
revised schedule with respect
to the exchange of certain
material and information prior
to and during trial pending
confirmation of the currently
scheduled trial of July 18,
2022, as a firm trial date by
the committee of the Southern
District of New York charged
with assigning trial dates. 1
The schedule is as follows:
June 6, 2022: The Government
provides to the defendant
material covered by 18 U.S.C.
§ 3500, including material
pursuant to Giglio v. United
States, 405 U.S. 150 (1972).
Full letter on Patreon here.
On June 20 -
Juneteeth - Milton's lawyers
filed their proposed voir dire
questions for jurors, and
their request to charge. They
want jurors asked if any
relative or close friend ever
worked in the automotive or
heavy trucking industry? Any
experience in hydrogen fuel
cell or battery technology?
Are you a risk taker? Are you
short seller? What platforms
do you use to trade - E*Trade,
TD Ameritrade, Charles Schwab,
Robinhood..."
On June 22, the
prosecutors informed Judge
Ramos of a superseding
indictment with a new charge:
"The Government respectfully
writes to advise the Court
that the grand jury returned a
superseding indictment earlier
today in the above-referenced
case, and to request that time
be excluded under the Speedy
Trial Act until the trial date
of July 18, 2022." New
indictment on Patreon here.
Then Milton asked
for a 30 day adjournment and
Judge Ramos set a hearing. The
US responded that as a
courtesy they would agree to a
week, no more: "the Government
would not object to a one-week
adjournment of the trial, no
delay is warranted and
certainly an adjournment of
greater than one week would be
contrary to the 'ends of
justice. Letter on Patreon here.
The government
followed this up in Sunday
letter docketed on Monday,
June 27: "Dear Judge Ramos:
The Government requests that
the Court impose a deadline of
July 1, 2022, for the
defendant to provide clarity
to the Government and the
Court regarding whether the
defendant intends to pursue an
advice of counsel defense, and
the precise subject matter
about which he will assert
that defense. As set forth in
the Government’s motions in
limine (Dkt. No. 121 at
21-22), in recognition of the
practical and logistical
difficulties of addressing
advice-of-counsel notice,
disclosure, and legal issues
mid-trial, courts have
routinely required a party
considering whether to mount
such a defense to give notice
of its decision before trial."
Full letter on Patreon here.
Later on June 27,
Milton's counsel reiterated
that a 30 day adjournment is
needed: " demand a sharp pivot
in trial strategy, which to
date has focused on
so-called “retail investors”
who bought stock on Nasdaq
allegedly based upon Mr.
Milton’s public statements on
“social media and in
television and podcast
interviews” and on Mr.
Milton’s alleged motive to
increase the price of Nikola
stock. See Indictment ¶¶ 22,
26. Those public
investors, unlike the private
seller of the real property in
Count Four, had no
direct interactions with
Mr. Milton. Defense counsel
must investigate, subpoena
documents from entities
and individuals outside this
district, and possibly retain
experts concerning the value
of the real property,
the authenticity of a key
piece of evidence produced by
the government, and the
pricing and practices of block
stock sales and options in a
private transaction.
Motions challenging the
new charges based on, inter
alia, a lack of venue, also
must be considered.
There are additional issues
that defense counsel must
explore fully and discuss with
Mr. Milton concerning
the new count. The government
recently produced emails
between counsel to the
individual described in Count
Four and corporate lawyers at
defense counsel’s law
firm relating to the
options and/or the block stock
sales, suggesting at least
some possibility that
lawyers from the same law firm
defending Mr. Milton at trial
could be called as fact
witnesses relating to
the alleged conduct “designed
to lull.” Although these
emails – and other
lawyer emails that the
government has not produced –
may simply be ministerial in
nature, counsel is
unable to say at this early
point without appropriately
exploring and considering
these issues. A
continuance of 30 days is
warranted."
Inner City
Press will continue to cover
the case.
Back on July 29
at 12:30 pm Milton was
presented before SDNY
Magistrate Judge Sarah
Netburn, and freed on consent,
on $100 million bond. Inner
City Press was in the
Magistrates Courtroom and live
tweeted it, here:
(and podcast here)
From
July 29:
Lawyers whispering about a
property in Utah. Seems he'll
be freed on bond.
In the front:
Milton and four defense
lawyers. Three
@SDNYLIVE prosecutors,
including Jordan Estes and
Nick Roos. Two Marshals.
Awaiting Magistrate Judge
Netburn. All rise.
Milton
surrendered at 8 am. Case is
assigned to District Judge
Edgardo Ramos (who's also in
One Coin cases.)
Milton pleads not
guilty. Freed on $100 million
bond. Less than Tom Barrack's
$250 million
Milton can travel
Utah, Wyoming, Idaho, Arizona,
Virginia and DC (for
lobbying?) No contact with
investors unless Milton has a
relationship with them.
Morgan, Utah property
appraised over $30 million
(contrary to the Pre Trial
Services report)
Milton's lawyer
says his income is down, no
$50 million in bank. Judge
Netburn approved free today on
$100 million bond. Surrender
guns.
The case is
US v. Milton, 21-cr-478
(Ramos)
***
Your
support means a lot. As little as $5 a month
helps keep us going and grants you access to
exclusive bonus material on our Patreon
page. Click
here to become a patron.
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle
500 Pearl Street, NY NY 10007 USA
Mail: Box 20047, Dag
Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest
service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2021 Inner City
Press, Inc. To request reprint or other
permission, e-contact Editorial [at]
innercitypress.com
|