In
SDNY Defense Counsel Withdraws
Based On Jailhouse
Conversation CJA Form Has AUSA
Name On It
By Matthew
Russell Lee, Periscope,
Patreon
SDNY COURTHOUSE,
April 24 – A man who had pled
guilty to maritime drug
trafficking and whose first
language is Albanian had his
lawyer withdraw from
representing him on April 24
but quickly got another free
lawyer in the U.S.
District Court
for the
Southern
District of
New York
courtroom of
SDNY Judge
Andrew L.
Carter. Leom
Kolmnema's
arrival from
the MCC was
delayed,
during which
time his
withdrawing
lawyer told
Judge Carter's
deputy that no
interpreter
was needed,
his client has
been in jail
so long he has
learned good
English.
The
reason for
withdrawal is
only barely
alluded to in
public: "I
recently
learned of
facts that
occurred after
the plea that
make it
impossible for
me represent
this defendant
any longer.
These facts
arose from the
fact that I am
also the
attorney for
one of Mr.
Kolmnela’s
former
cellmates and
certain things
that the
defendant in
this case has
told me. While
the Government
is aware of
most of the
facts to which
I am obliquely
referring, I
cannot
enumerate the
details in
this filing
without
harming my
client’s
interests.
Should the
Court require
it, I could
provide Your
Honor with
more detail in
an ex parte
letter or in
an ex parte
conference.
The defendant
also informs
me that he
does not now
have the
assets with
which to
retain
counsel. The
defendant has
previously
completed a
CJA Form and
had appointed
counsel. But I
will have the
defendant
complete a new
up-to-date
form and
perhaps the
substitution
might occur at
a conference."
The withdrawal
and replace
did take place
on April 24,
but only after
Judge Carter
astutely noted
that it
appeared that
the Assistant
U.S. Attorney
on the case
appeared to
have signed
Kolmnema's
financial
affidavit.
(There is, it
emerged, a
house in
California).
The AUSA
quickly said
for the record
that he had
not signed it,
that he is not
permitted to
look at the
finances of
the people he
prosecutes.
Index number
and more on
Patreon, here.
We'll have
more on this.
The
day before on April 23, a man
was denied bail on April 23
after naming his Instagram
account "Catch Me If You Can."
It in the SDNY arraignments
courtroom,
presided over
by this
week by retiring
Magistrate
Judge Henry Pitman.
A Mister
Crowder,
wearing a
"World Sacrifice Tour"
t-shirt, was
requesting
bail. But
Judge Pitman
asked about
the naming of
his Instagram
account, and
the two
excuses given, that
it was named
after a Leo
DiCaprio movie
("I've seen
it," Judge
Pitman said)
and that he
later changed
"if you
can" to "if
you could," were unavailing.
The marshals
took him back
into the cell
block Judge
Pitman
said to close
the door to,
less than an
hour before
affluent
opioids
distributor
Laurence Doud was
released on
$500,000 bail
and walked
with his
lawyer Mister
Gottlieb
across Foley
Square with
Inner City
Press asking
questions,
Periscope video here. We'll
have more on
this.
Back on
April 18 a
defendant pled
guilty to
selling marijuana and
having
a gun in
Manhattan, to
a plea
agreement
specifying 37
to 46
months. Magistrate
Judge Moses
asked the defendant
if he had
written his
allocation himself.
Sporting an
ACE bandage on
his right wrist, he
said Yes. Moments
later a Mr.
Butler, with
neck tattoo,
stepping up with a
financial
affidavit and
a lawyer, to
be appointed
as he is a
material witness.
So you work
construction?
Judge Moses asked. The
answer was
yes, and that
it was
seasonal - he was
not going to
work tonight
because it was
going to pour
rain. Judge
Moses asked,
Is it? And by
6 pm, there was
still no rain.
But her week
was over, and
not uninteresting,
including
disputes with
both the
Federal Defenders
and, less so,
with the
government. We
will continue
to cover this.
A defendant
accused in New York courts of
attempted murder but released
because not indicted in six
days was denied bail
on April 17
by
SDNY
Magistrate
Judge
Moses after
a contentious 5
p.m.
proceeding with
Inner City
Press the only media
present. The
Federal Defender
argued that
the NY ADA's
inability
to indict
within the six
day time frame
of NY CPLR 3030
meant there
really is no
evidence. The
Federal
Assistant
U.S. Attorney
said she had
called her
state
counterpart who
assured they
are
investigating.
Federal
Magistrate
Judge Moses said
she would not
credit
anything not
actually
before the
court - but
that attempted
murder sounds
serious. The defendant
is being
remanded and
held, it
seems, until a
hearing before
U.S.
District Court
Judge
Keenan.
Inner City
Press will
cover that as
well.
The day before on
April 16 a strange
proceeding took place in which
a material witness was
assigned a free lawyer by SDNY
Magistrate Judge Moses. His
financial
affidavit
had to be
updated - as
it turned out,
because he was
paying his
taxes. Then Judge
Moses accepted
it and assigned him a
lawyer and he
disappeared.
No index
number was
read out, and
his name to Inner
City Press the
only media
present
sounded like
Teepee. They acted
like it was a
private proceeding,
like the
visits by Assistant
US Attorneys
and FBI
agents through
the fire
door to see
the week's
Magistrate
judge. But
these are public
proceedings,
until
they are not.
Inner
City Press will have
more on
this.... A
Dominican defendant charged
with fentanyl was the last
case on April 16 SDNY
Magistrate's Court. There was
more preamble
that usual, as the
Assistant
U.S. Attorney
asked the FBI if
they had the
defendant's
wallet - they
did - and if
it contained his
Green Card. It
did, but there
still a
dispute of whether
this was
the same
defendant who
pled guilty to
narcotics
felony in
2009. It is a
common name:
Juan Pablo de
la Cruz Mendoza.
And for that
reason,
apparently,
the defendant
will spend
at least until
Monday, April
22 in the MCC.
Inner City
Press, the
only media
present in the
presentment,
wondered why
the issue of
his green
card,
uncontested by
the government,
became entwined
with this doppelganger's
plea. The person
present on April 16
said
audible, in
Spanish, that
he makes only
$500 a week,
and sends $100 to
a daughter in
Santo
Domingo. He
has four
children. It
was like observing
in an
operating room
when the
surgeons don't
know what to
do. Delay
it until
Monday was the
decision.
Inner
City Press
will be there.
Back on April 9 a
defendant pleading guilty to
entering the U.S. after a
prior deportation for drugs
asked for an expedited
sentencing, and presumably
second deportation to the
Dominican Republic in the SDNY,
before Judge
Deborah Batts.
But Judge
Batts declined
to give
earlier dates,
saying that the
Probation
Department is
understaffed
and
underfunded.
Defendant
Daniel
Francisco
Portes' lawyer
told
the court and
his client's
family that he
will nonetheless
ask Probation
to expedite
things. Judge
Batts said she
will wants the
parties to
comment on the
draft
pre-sentencing
report. It was
a moment in an
ongoing social
debate, in a large
courtroom
with only one media
present: Inner
City Press.
We'll continue
to follow this
case - but not
this one:
Abdul Odige's
criminal case
began in 2004
but on April 9
his
supervision
was removed.
He has passed
his marijuana
tests; he has
gotten a job
in health
care. He was
arrested for
driving with a
suspended
lisence - but
it was for a
fine he didn't
know he owed.
Probation
spoke up for him, and even the
Assist US Attorney. And so it
was over, a too rare positive
story. The case is, or was, US
v. Odige, 04 Cr.
196 (DAB)....
A
defendant brought before SDNY
Judge Paul Crotty on March 27
wanted to change lawyers. Then
he told Judge Crotty that his
outgoing lawyer had taken his
Honduran passport and ID and
he wanted it returned. The
matter was not resolved on the
record; the lawyer being
relieved, seeing Inner City
Press with a reporter's
notebook, came over and asked,
Why are you covering this?
Well, there is an absolute
right to cover the courts. And
when the allegation is that
legal identity documents are
taken and not returned, it
should be pursued. To
belatedly answer the
inappropriate question of the
lawyer being replaced, who
after Inner City Press' answer
of "Here I am" went and
whispered with the judge,
there was a break in the jury
instructions in a case
elsewhere in the courthouse
that Inner City Press is
covering. But really there is
no need for the press or
public to answer. Rather,
where are the documents?
Back on
March 8, another shooting in
The Bronx in October 2018 was
the subject of an ill-attended
conference in the SDNY.
Jerome Jackson
is described
as in a white
t-shirt with
silver handgun
on 2 October
2018 on
Freeman Street
- but in the
SDNY courtroom
of Judge Kevin
Castel he was
in jail house
blues and
shackles. His
lawyer Julia
Gatto
questioned
whether the
NYPD
detectives who
questioned
Jackson about
the shooting
were in fact
part of a
joint task
force with the
Feds - no,
Karin Potlock
for the
government
said, and on
that basis no
suppression -
and questioned
probable
cause. There
will be a
hearing on
that on April
Fools Day and
Inner City
Press aims to
be there. The
case is US
v. Jackson,
18 CR 760. A
week before on March 1 when
Statue of Liberty climber
Patricia Okoumou appeared in
the SDNY , it was to face
revocation of bail for more
recent climbs, all to protest
the separation of immigrant
families. SDNY Judge
Gorenstein did not revoke bail
but imposed house arrest. He
jibed that it appeared Ms.
Okoumou could only support
herself by donations garnered
by climbing. Afterward Inner
City Press asked her lawyer
Ron Kuby about this argument.
He said the judge has it
precisely wrong, or in
reverse: she raised money
because she is an activist,
she is not an actively in
order to make money. Ms.
Okoumou raised her fist, and
headed to Staten Island.
Photos here.
Inner City Press, which
interviewed Okoumou on
December 5 just after another
SDNY decision, in the Patrick
Ho / CEFC China Energy UN
bribery case, headed out and
streamed this
Periscope, and this Q&A,
with more to come, on this
case and others. How guns
eject shell casings was the
subject of expert testimony in
a Bronx gang trial on February
27 in the U.S.
District Court
for the
Southern
District of
New York.
Before Judge
Robert W.
Sweet, an ATF
agent traced a
bullet back to
Illinois;
under cross
examination he
said a shell
casing might
eject feet
rather than
yards unless
it bounced on
something.
Then testimony
went back to
2007, a
14-year old
with a gun
heading from
the Millbrook
projects to
the Mitchell
Houses. The
defense asked
for a mistrial
when the name
of a second
gang was
introduced;
the
prosecution
shot back (so
to speak) that
it came from
photos on the
defendant's
own Facebook
page. And so
it goes in
trials these
days. Back
on February 25 a prison
sentence of life plus five
years was imposed for a Bronx
murder by SDNY Chief Judge
Colleen McMahon on February
25. She presided over the
trial in which Stiven
Siri-Reynoso was convicted of,
among other things, murder in
aid of racketeering for the
death of Jessica White, a 28
year old mother of three, in
the Bronx in 2016. Jessica
White's mother was in the
court room; she was greeted by
Judge McMahon but declined to
speak before sentencing.
Siri-Reynoso was representing
himself by this point, with a
back-up counsel by his side.
Judge McMahon told him,
"You're a very smart man... a
tough guy, a calculating
person... You are a coward,
sent a child to do it for
you... Your emissary shot the
wrong person, a lovely lady...
It was a vicious, evil attack
against the good people of
that neighborhood." When she
imposed the life plus five
sentence, a woman on the
Jessica White side of the
courtroom cried out, yes
Ma'am, put the animal away!
Later, after Siri-Reynoso
ended asking how he can get
more documents about the case,
a woman on his side of the
courtroom said, "No te
preocupes, muchacho, Dios sabe
lo que hace" - don't worry,
God knows what he is doing.
But does He? Earlier on
February 25 when the
government tried to defend its
2018 change of policy or
practice on Special Immigrant
Juvenile status in the U.S.
District Court for the
Southern District of New York
Judge John G. Koeltl had many
questions about the change. He
asked, are you saying that all
the decisions before 2018 were
just wrong, under a policy in
place but not implemented at
the time? In the overflow
courtroom 15C the largely
young audience laughed, as the
government lawyer tried to say
it wasn't a change of policy
but rather an agency
interpretation of the statute.
Shouldn't there have been
notice and comment rulemaking
under the Administrative
Procedure Act? The government
said the argument proffered
for this was about the Freedom
of Information Act (on which,
as Inner City Press has noted,
the US Office of the
Comptroller of the Currency
has similarly reversed its
policy 180 degrees without
justification). SDNY Judge
Koeltl demanded t know if the
government is arguing that no
juvenile court in New York,
California (and maybe Texas
for other reasons he said) is
empowered to grant relief. The
answer was far from clear -
but where the ruling is going
does seem so. Watch this site.
The Bangladeshi Central Bank
which was hacked for $81
million in February 2016, on
January 31 sued in the US
District Court for the
Southern District of New York.
Now the first pre-trial
conference in the case has
been set, for 2 April 2019
before SDNY Judge Lorna G.
Schofield. Inner City Press
will be there.
In Dhaka, the
Criminal Investigation
Department which failed to
submit its probe report into
the heist on time has now been
ordered by Metropolitan
Magistrate
Sadbir Yasir
Ahsan
Chowdhury to
do so by March 13 in
Bangladesh Bank cyber heist
case.
In the U.S.
District Court for Central
California, the unsealed
criminal complaint against
Park Jin Hyuk lists four email
addresses involved in
spear-phishing Bangladesh Bank
and among others an unnamed
"African Bank;" one of these
addresses is said to also have
communicated with an
individual in Australia about
importing commodities to North
Korea in violations of UN
sanctions.
To the Federal
Reserve, Inner City Press has
requested records relating to
the Fed's role with response
due in 20 working days - watch
this site. In the SDNY, the
case is Bangladesh Bank v
Rizal Commercial Banking Corp
et al, U.S. District Court,
Southern District of New York,
No. 19-00983. On February 3 in
Dhaka Bangladesh Bank's
lawyer Ajmalul
Hossain
said it could take three years
to recover the money. The
Bank's deputy governor Abu
Hena Razee Hasan said those
being accused -- in the civil
not criminal suit -- include
three Chinese nationals.
Ajmalul Hossain said the Bank
is seeking its hacked million
plus interest and its expenses
in the case. He said US
Federal Reserve will extend
its full support and that
SWIFT, the international money
transfer network, also assured
of providing all the necessary
cooperation in recovering the
hacked money...
It is an
interesting twist on the SDNY
as venue for the money
laundering and FCPA
prosecution of Patrick Ho of
CEFC for bribery in Chad and
to Uganda - in this case, too,
the money flowed through New
York. Inner City Press intends
to cover the case.
***
Your
support means a lot. As little as $5 a month
helps keep us going and grants you access to
exclusive bonus material on our Patreon
page. Click
here to become a patron.
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
Box 20047, Dag Hammarskjold
Station NY NY 10017
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest
service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2019 Inner City
Press, Inc. To request reprint or other
permission, e-contact Editorial [at]
innercitypress.com for
|