Hedge
Fund Briber/Philanthropist
Huberfeld Got 7 Months, Asked
Transcript Redacted, Denied
By Matthew
Russell Lee, Periscope
video
NEW YORK CITY,
August 27 – Four days after
Norman Seabrook, former head
of the NYC Corrections
Officers union, was sentenced
to 58 months in prison by U.S.
District Court for the
Southern District of New York
Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein for
taking bribes to steer union
money into the failed Platinum
hedge fund.
Platinum's
Murray Huberfeld received a 30
month sentence for his role in
the bribery. That was on
February 12, 2019 and is
described below.
On December 18,
2020, Huberfeld having
succesfully appealed
reappeared before another SDNY
Judge, Lewis L. Liman.
(Seabrook's case is still
before Judge
Hellerstein).
Huberfeld's lawyers were in
email fight, conveyed to Judge
Liman, with the COBA union
about restitution.
On April 23,
Huberfeld seeking a sentence
of six months home
confinement, filed additional
redacted letters and articles,
including that people still
get COVID after vaccination,
and Judge Jed S. Rakoff's NYRB
article "Covid and the
Courts."
On June 22
Judge Liman held the
sentencing. He began by
recounting the history, noted
by Inner City Press, and
called the crime serious; the
previously 30 month sentence
was replaced by one of seven
months, followed by a year of
Supervised Release.
Now in August,
Huberfeld counsel asked for a
delay in surrender (to
prison), citing a civil case
before Judge Rakoff, Trott, et
al. v. Platinum Management
(18-cv-10936).
But on August 9,
Judge Liman denied the
extension, writing that "I
have spoken with Judge Rakoff.
Due to the situation with the
Delta variant there is some
question whether the civil
trial will commence on the
date scheduled. Given the
uncertainty, there is no
reason for Defendant not to
surrender and begin to serve
his sentence." So it remains
October 15.
And Huberfelt
asked to redact material from
the transcript. On August 27
Judge Liman correctly rejected
it: "ORDER as to (16-Cr-467-2)
Murray Huberfeld. Defendant
has submitted a motion to
redact the sentencing
transcript. Dkt. No. 416. The
motion is DENIED. The hearing
was in open court, and the
words spoken have entered the
public domain both through the
physical open court and
through the remote access the
Court provided. Those who were
present -- physically or
remotely -- were and are at
liberty to disclose what
transpired to anyone who is
interested. Defendant offers
no basis for the Court to hold
back the transcript that
reflects what everyone heard.
SO ORDERED. (Signed by Judge
Lewis J. Liman on 8/27/2021)."
On the same day,
in a sentencing before Judge
Rakoff, it was asked that
something said aloud be
redacted. We'll see.
Watch this site.
This case is now
US v. Huberfeld, 16-cr-467
(Liman).
Back in
February 2019 the physical
SDNY courtroom of Judge
Hellerstein was filled with
Huberfeld's family and
supporters, and the testimony
even from the government was
full of references to his
donations, many of them
anonymous. Huberfeld arranged
for the search and discovered
of a drowned boy in Australia.
He rehabilitated houses in
Moncie, New York for the large
families characteristic of the
Orthodox community - and some
resold them for big profits.
Huberfeld was also depicted as
having another person take the
registered representative test
for him, and reached two
settlements with the SEC.
"Why do
good people do bad things?"
SDNY Judge Alvin K.
Hellerstein mused, as he had
on February 8 before passing
sentence on Seabrook. He took
a similar 10 minute break.
Inner City Press rushed down
to get its electronics and do
a Periscope broadcast, here;
a similarly descending
clairvoyant predicted that
"long winded" Hellerstein
would come out at 30 months.
And so it was. He initially
ordered $19 million
restitution then stayed that,
too. Huberfeld's lawyers noted
they would argue on appeal
that only the $60,000 bribe
money was the appropriate
figure for restitution. They
said Huberfeld's recited
commitment to pay back $7
million to the union was based
on him remaining free. Now he
will remain free, at least
pending appeal.
Huberfeld's mother, who was in
the courtroom, is a Holocaust
survivor. Judge Hellerstein
described her hiding under an
animal trough and asked, How
can people be so cruel?
Huberfeld too teared up while
addressing hte court, asking
to be allowed to remain free
to serve people for example
through a soup kitchen program
he has been working with.
Judge Hellerstein called him
one of the most nobel
defendants to ever appear
before him - then imposed the
(delayed) 30 month sentence.
On the
government side prosecutor
Martin Bell brought up former
New York Knicks basketball
player Charles Oakley, who had
been in the courthouse
supporting Normal Seabrook on
February 8 (Inner City Press
photos on Alamy here,
Periscope below); he quoted
Knicks coach Pat Riley's book
about success being a danger
for a team and said it applied
to Huberfeld. This is a New
York case we will continue to
follow, along with other
cases. On February 8, a
victim's statement to the
court cited what it called
Seabrook's racist rant on
YouTube.
Afterward on Worth Street
Inner City Press asked
Seabrook about the YouTube
video - actually, an audio
file with an array of still
photographs. Seabrook
told Inner City Press they
doctored it to make him look
bad. His (actual) answer on
Periscope here
- and here
now audio file on YouTube,
here.
In the
SDNY courtroom it was
cognitive dissonance: Norman
Seabrook who rose from poverty
to head of a union with 10,000
members, who endorsed Michael
Bloomberg; Norman Seabrook who
asked for tens of thousands of
dollars to steer union money
into a Cayman Islands hedge
fund which failed.
Prosecutor
Martin Bell referred to a
Ferragamo bag visible in
Seabrook's house for months.
When Seabrook spoke he said it
was a gift with cigars, taking
a cigar out of his suit
jacket.
Seabrook's lawyer
Paul Shechtman
cited
Seabrook's
work on the
so-called
feces bill to
make throwing
excrement at a
corrections
officer a
felony. On the
hand Seabrook
was accused of
threatening
his board
members with
returning to
work in a
prison as
punishment,
and of going
after anyone
who dared run
against or
otherwise
oppose him.
Seabrook felt
that it was
his time to
get paid, that
he was bigger
than the cause
he began
fighting for,
Bell said.
Shechtman also
spoke after the sentencing.
Inner City Press asked him
about Judge
Alvin K.
Hellerstein's
seeming
reversal of an initial
position that it would be hard
to leave Seabrook out on bail
pending appeal. Shechtman
replied affably that he had to
win something, after the 58
month sentence. Video here.
An issue
on a appeal will be whether
Seabrook's second jury should
have heard about the $19
million loss.
Inner City
Press asked Shechtman about
the restitution, how much
would be paid by hedge funders
Murray Huberfeld, Jona
Rechnitz and perhaps (Judge
Hellerstein
indicated)
Jeremy Reichberg. Shechtman
told Inner City Press, If
Norman wins $19 million in the
lottery, we'll have about
that. For now, $2500 is due in
60 days, through the SDNY
Clerk, for the union. We'll
have more on this.
Exiting the courthouse after
Seabrook, with a bag of Utz
potato chips and a copy of the
Daily News was New York Knicks
icon Charles Oakley. He said
that there are others who need
to be locked up as well, and
that the Knicks need better
players. There was no
rebuttal. Periscope video here.
Upcoming in the
SDNY is a recently-filed
complaint by the Bangladesh
Central Bank for the $81
million hacking of its funds,
which were then wired through
the Federal Reserve Bank of
New York, a case
that Inner City Press will
cover. Times change. Watch
this site.
***
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
Box 20047, Dag Hammarskjold
Station NY NY 10017
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest
service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2021 Inner City
Press, Inc. To request reprint or other
permission, e-contact Editorial [at]
innercitypress.com for
|
,
