In S.
Sudan, Kiir
Signs with Reservations,
UN Trashed by
Museveni, Ban
Ki-moon's
Partner on
Burundi
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
August 26 --
After the
South Sudan
peace
agreement was
not signed by
President
Salva Kiir,
still said to
have
reservations,
Inner City
Press on
August 18 (and
August 19)
asked UN
Associate
Spokesperson
Vannina
Maestracci for
the UN's
response, and
what it could
at least say
about fighting
in the
country, see
below.
Now on August
26, albeit
after
expressing
reservations,
Salva Kiir
signed the
Agreement.
Before he did,
Uganda's
Yoweri Museveni
advised
him to get the
UN out of the
country,
saying having
the UN is is a
sign of weakness
and that the
UN preserves
terrorism.
It is to
Museveni that
UN Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon has
been deferring
on Burundi,
still not
having named a
UN envoy as
the UN
Security
Council called
"imminent" two
weeks ago.
(Ban was in
France on
August 26, praising
the country's
ambassadorial
corps without
a single mention
of French
troops'
alleged rape
of children in
the Central
African
Republic,
covered up by
Ban's (French)
head of UN
Peacekeeping,
Herve
Ladsous.)
In fairness to
Museveni, his
reference may
have been in
part to
Ladsous'
MONUSCO
failing to act
on armed
groups in
Eastern Congo
-- including
the FDLR,
which also impinges
on Burundi.
We'll have
more on this.
In front of
the Security
Council on
August 26,
there was
loose talk
about Kiir
signing; an
African
diplomat told
Inner City
Press, "He
signed! He was
obliged!"
which no
mention of the
reservations.
The UN has no
noon briefing
today -- it
said it only
have one if
something
important
happened, this
is apparently
not important
- here are
answers from August
24 and August
25, Inner
City Press'
South Sudan
questions have
been not been
answered.
On August 25,
Ellen Loj, the
head of the UN
Mission in the
country UNMISS
told the UN
Security
Council that
Kiir is
expected to
sign the
agreement on
August 26.
Inner City
Press asked,
how might that
impact the
pending draft
resolution on
sanctions and
an arms
embargo?
After
consultations
on August 25,
Security
Council
President for
August Joy
Ogwu of
Nigeria
emerged with
Elements to
the Press
including:
“The
Council
members
expressed
concern on the
deteriorating
humanitarian
and security
situation.
They condemned
the continuing
fighting by
the parties
and underlined
the need for a
peaceful
resolution of
the crisis.
“They
expressed
optimism that
President
Salva Kiir
would follow
through on his
commitment to
sign the IGAD
Plus Peace
Agreement
without
reservation.
“They stressed
the importance
of full
implementation
of the
Agreement.
Council
members
underscored
the need to
remain engaged
on the
situation in
South Sudan.
In this regard
they expressed
their
readiness to
act
immediately if
President Kiir
does not sign
the agreement
tomorrow as he
has
undertaken."
Inner City
Press asked
Ambassador
Ogwu about
sending the
draft
resolution's
annexes to the
African Union
and IGAD, as
an African
delegation
told Inner
City Press
about. Ogwu
answered that
speed is
important, but
also that it
be concerted,
a consensus,
like an
orchestra, it
doesn't matter
who writes the
notes, but...
Periscope
video here;
here's fast
transcript of
Q&A from
InnerCityPro,
which also has
analysis:
Inner
City Press:
Some members
talked about
sending the
annexes to the
AU or IGAD.
Was there
discussion of
that? When you
say
immediately,
does it
include that?
Amb
Ogwu: We all
understand the
need for
urgency,
because the
situation is
urgent. But
also there is
the need for
concerted
action, for
consensus. It
is a stage and
all the
players must
act as an
orchestra,
play the
symphony, it
doesn’t matter
who writes the
notes but it’s
important to
act in unison,
act with one
voice.
Q: Can you
clarify, if he
does not sign
tomorrow, will
you vote on
the US draft
resolution?
Amb
Ogwu: We
decided that
we will take
immediate
action if he
does not sign,
or if he signs
with
reservations....
Inner City
Press: Any
discussion of
the military
situation?
Which side is
more
responsible
for the
military
action since
the Addis
meeting?
Amb
Ogwu: We are
seeking peace.
We are not
apportioning
blame to any
particular
side. We are
urging all the
parties to
come together
to relieve the
dire
humanitarian
situation and
to stop the
fighting.
Q: What about
justice? We
heard from
Stephen
O’Brien this
morning…
Amb
Ogwu: I don’t
think Stephen
O’Brien
mentioned
anything about
justice.
Q: He
spoke about
women being
raped,
atrocities.
Amb
Ogwu: Yes.
That is an
outcome. But
that is left
for another
department. I
would not want
to go into
that. But we
all agreed I
would say on
measures to be
taken that
anybody who is
found culpable
will be held
accountable.
There is one
voice in the
Council.
In her
national
capacity,
Nigeria's
Ambassador
Ogwu
emphasized the
need for an
arms embargo,
and to check
where the
weapons in the
country are.
Loj said, "a
Mini-Summit
has been
called for
tomorrow,
where the
Government of
the Republic
of South
Sudan, in the
interest of
peace, is
expected to
sign the
proposed
agreement.
Despite this
hopefully
positive
development,
the security
situation on
the ground has
been volatile
and tense.
Fighting in
the Greater
Upper Nile
region has
remained
intense and
further
escalation of
hostilities in
southern Unity
State has had
increasingly
severe
consequences
for the
civilian
population.
Major
offensives
conducted by
the SPLA and
its allied
militias into
Opposition-held
areas have led
to further
deterioration
of the
security and
humanitarian
situation
since April,
and have
resulted in
numerous
reports of
grave human
rights
violations.
Most recently,
on August 19,
fighting
occurred
between SPLA
and Opposition
forces around
Leer town,
with both
sides trading
accusations of
having
initiated the
attack.
Loj spoke of
discouraging
some from
entering the
UN's
"protection of
civilian"
camps, without
addressing the
blocking of
civilians
fleeing
fighting from
the UN's
Yambio camp,
which Inner
City Press has
repeatedly
asked about.
Nor did she
address if
UNMISS' radio
station, Radio
Miraya, kept
rigt on
broadcasting
amid a strike
by media in
the country to
protect the
assassination
of journalist
Peter Julius
Moi.
On August 18,
Inner City
Press asked UN
Associate
Spokesperson
Maestracci,
"do you have
any comment
on, or does
the mission
have any
comment on,
Salva Kiir
having said at
the airport on
his way to
Addis that 'if
anybody among
journalists
does not know
that this
country has
killed people,
we will
demonstrate it
one day, one
time'?"
By August 21,
after South
Sudanese
journalist
Peter Julius
Moi was
assassinated
in Juba, Inner
City Press
asked the next
UN Associate
Spokesperson
Eri Kaneko this question,video
here:
Inner
City Press: In
South
Sudan,
virtually all
media there,
the Union of
Journalists in
South Sudan
and the
Association
for Media
Development in
South Sudan,
have agreed to
a media
blackout in
mourning and
as a protest
of the murder
of the
journalist
Peter Julius
Moi.
They’re saying
that UNMISS’
Radio Miraya
is going to
keep
broadcasting.
Is that the
case? Is
Miraya part of
sort of the
media of
South, what’s
the position
of the UN on
this?
Associate
Spokesperson:
I’m not aware,
but I will
look into
that.
Eight hours
later and
counting,
there has been
no answer. Video here.
On both August
18 and 19 when
Inner City
Press asked,
UN
spokesperson
Maestracci
declined to
confirm or
deny any of
the fighting
in the country
-- a pattern
for UNMISS
under UN
Peacekeeping
boss Herve
Ladsous. On
August 19,
Maestracci
told Inner
City Press,
"As soon as I
have
[information],
I will give it
to you." None
came: also a
pattern.
But Inner City
Press sources
tell it of
ongoing
clashes in
Upper Nile, in
Pageri, East
Equatoria,
still ongoing.
The Juba –
Nimule road,
the only
"proper tarmac
road" in the
country,
remains
closed;
limited
communications
within the
fragmented
phone networks
confirm that
civilians are
being
targeted.
West
Equatorial
Governor
Joseph
Bakasoro is
still
detained.
Also, here is
UNMISS sit-rep
for insiders,
not meant for
the public,
apparently:
“Following
attacks in
Pageri on 18
Aug 2015 host
country
security
forces have
advised that
there is still
military
operation in
the vicinity
of Pageri town
(30 kms North
of Nimule).
UN Security
advises that:
·
UN/INGO
travels on the
Juba - Nimule
road are
currently
restricted.
·
UN Security
will re-assess
the situation
in the next 24
hours and will
advise
accordingly.
·
In the interim
all missions
should be
cleared with
UN Security
until further
notice.
·
Additionally,
UN/INGO
missions into
Pageri are to
be suspended
until a
clearer
picture is
established as
there are
reports of
heavy host
country
security
forces
deployed in
Pageri.”
... This is
how things are
at UN
Headquarters
and elsewhere
in the system,
especially in
UN
Peacekeeping
under Ladsous.
The Free
UN Coalition
for Access is
challenging
this.
On August 19
after UN
Deputy
Secretary
General Jan
Eliasson
briefed the
Council behind
closed doors -
he stopped and
told Inner
City Press is
was not a
short
consultation,
only a
scheduling
misunderstanding
- he stopped
on the way out
and spoke
again.
Inner
City Press
asked Eliasson
the question
the UN
Spokesperson
has for two
days declined
to answer:
"Have the two
sides started
fighting
again?"
Eliasson to
his credit
answered:
"There are
reports, they
are very
worrying. And
this is also
why, it is
important if
there is this
progress
towards
signing of an
agreement,
that it is
accompanied by
the need for a
ceasefire. A
diplomatic
solution
cannot be
found if there
is not a de
escalation."
Moments later
New Zealand's
Ambassador
Gerard van
Boheman
stopped and
spoke about
the US
submitted
draft
resolution
that the US'
Susan Rice had
alluded to the
day before,
that that it
"does deal
with an arms
embargo also
posits
additional
sanctions, if
the agreement
is not signed.
I think
there’s
general
recognition
that the
situation in
South Sudan is
not good,
there’s a
recognition
that the IGAD
and that the
IGAD plus
countries have
been doing all
they can. We
want to be
able to
support their
efforts.”
Ambassador van
Boheman said
that “it’s
quite a
technical
resolution. So
I think it
will take
quite a bit of
work to get
everyone on
the same
page.”
Could that
timing be
related to the
15 days from
August 17
deadline for
Salva Kiir to
sign?
Inner City
Press also
asked van
Bohemen about
Yemen, but
that's another
story.
on
South Sudan,
can the
Mission there,
or do you have
anything on
reported, an
attack by the
Government on
the opposition
in a place
called
Imatong?
And do you
have any
comment on, or
does the
mission have
any comment
on, Salva Kiir
having said at
the airport on
his way to
Addis that "if
anybody among
journalists
does not know
that this
country has
killed people,
we will
demonstrate it
one day, one
time"?
It's a comment
that CPJ has
criticized,
and I wonder
if the mission
has seen it
and what they
think of it.
Associate
Spokesperson:
So on Imatong
— is that what
it's called?
Correspondent:
Yeah.
Associate
Spokesperson:
I actually do
not have a
statement.
On South Sudan
and the
comments on
the media that
were made by
Salva Kiir,
yes, the
Mission told
us they were
very concerned
about, over
the curbing of
the press
freedom in
South Sudan,
including
recent closure
of media
houses and
threats to
journalists.
And they've
also
reiterated the
importance of
independent,
free and
pluralistic
press.
Question:
Is the Deputy…
I just wanted
to ask one
thing. I
saw that the
Deputy
Secretary-General's
schedule says
appointments
are
internal.
Did he come
back from
Addis?
Is there some
way…
Associate
Spokesperson:
He is on his
way back.
On August 19,
Inner City
Press asked
Maestracci
again - still
no information
on Imatong,
nor Upper
Nile, Pageri
or other
attacks since.
From the
August 19 UN
transcript:
Inner
City Press: I
wanted to ask
about South
Sudan.
I’d asked you
yesterday
about whether
UNMISS could
confirm
reports of
fighting and
now there’s
increased
reports of
fighting and
counter
charges by the
Government and
the opposition
of fighting in
Upper Nile
State, also
near the
Ugandan
border.
So I’m
wondering if
UNMISS, given
its presence
in the
country, it
seems
important to
know is this
taking place
and if so
which side is
instigating
it?
Associate
Spokesperson
Vannina
Maestracci:
We’re checking
and we’re
waiting for an
answer.
As soon as I
have one, I
will give it
to you.
Nothing was
given, but see
above.
Inner
City Press
asked DSG
Eliasson of
reports of
fighting in
South Sudan,
he
acknowledged
the reports, Periscope
video here. We'll
have more on
this.