On
UN
Sudan Trip, “Don't Ask, Don't Tell” About Bashir, Darfur Stop
Unmentioned
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
September 28, 2010 -- If 15 UN Security Council diplomats
travel to a country run by an indicted war criminal but no one can
take pictures of it, did the trip really take place?
That
was a
question being asked Tuesday at the UN, as details
leaked out to Inner City Press about
the Council's on again, off again and now on again trip to Sudan.
The
sticking point
had been whether Sudan would demand that the Council Ambassadors meet
with President Omar al Bashir, indicted by the International Criminal
Court for war crimes and genocide, and secondarily whether the
Council would first visit Khartoum or Juba in South Sudan.
Western
diplomats
bragged to Inner City Press on Tuesday morning that they had
prevailed on both points. The trip would go to Juba, and in all
probability to Darfur -- Darfur wasn't mentioned in the Council
Tuesday, one participate said -- before going to Khartoum.
“The Council
won't ask to meet with Bashir, and he won't ask to meet with us,”
one seemingly excited diplomat told Inner City Press about the trip
on Tuesday, adding that Bashir might conveniently be out of the
country, in Libya, he said.
The
“don't ask,
don't tell” trip, Inner City Press has dubbed it.
UN's Ban & Bashir, with some distance: don't ask, don't tell?
Bashir
has also
been invited to visit Cote d'Ivoire. Inner City Press asked the UN's
envoy to that country K.Y. Choi about this on Tuesday. Choi's
response, strangely, was to repeat that inviter Laurent Gbagbo and
his two main opponents are all committed to a peaceful first round of
elections on October 31.
This
perhaps is
the approach of the UN Secretariat to questions about war crimes and
impunity: to repeat talking points again and again, even if
unrelated. We'll see.
Footnote:
Just
how dysfunctional things have become between the Security
Council and the Office of the Spokesman of the Secretary General,
which has already been barred from the Council consultation meetings
they for years attended and summarized, is exemplified by that the
fact that less than a week before the re-scheduled trip, the Council
has not told the OSSG about any arrangements for press.
On
past trips --
Inner City Press accompanied the Security Council to Sudan, the
Congo, Rwanda, Cote d'Ivoire and elsewhere in 2008 -- the Council has
let the OSSG invite the press, arrange for visas, and attend.
Apparently not this time. Watch this site.
* * *
UN
Council
Trip to Sudan is Back On, After Obama and Taha Praise, US to
Announce
By
Matthew
Russell Lee, Exclusive
UNITED
NATIONS,
September 28, updated -- The UN Security Council is, after
delay and negotiations, going on a trip to Sudan, Inner City Press
exclusively learned on Tuesday morning. “The US will take the floor
and annouce it,” a well place source told Inner City Press.
The
issue was
whether Sudan would require the Security Council Ambassadors to meet
with and even take photos with President Omar al Bashir, who has been
indicted by the International Criminal Court for war crimes and
genocide.
The
US and UK, in
charge of different parts of the long planned Sudan trip, have been
trying to get Sudan to drop these demands, to avoid the photo op.
Now,
days after US
President Obama gave a speech about Sudan in which he mentioned
neither the ICC nor Bashir, and Sudan's Vice President Ali Osman Taha
praised the new US approach, the impasse has been resolved.
Bashir with UN Ban, Obama speech and UNSC trip not shown
Multiple
sources
say the trip will be announced later at Tuesday. But at what cost?
Watch this site.
Update of 11:23 a.m.
-- while that the "lead country" -- the US -- has agreed to the trip is
confirmed, other non Permanent Council members have still not been told
the basis of the US - Sudan agreement. It is assumed to be that a
meeting with Bashir will not be required.
* * *
In
Darfur,
UN Prepares To Hand Over Bashir's Enemies for “Blood
Money- Exclusive
By
Matthew
Russell Lee, Exclusive Must Credit
UNITED
NATIONS,
September 28, 2010 -- In Darfur, the Joint African Union -
UN peacekeeping mission UNAMID is preparing to turn over to the
government of Omar al Bashir five supporters of rebel leader Abdel
Wahid Nur who have been “accused by Sudanese authorities of having
committed crimes,” as shown by UNAMID documents obtained by Inner
City Press.
For
two months the
government of Bashir, who has been indicted by the International
Criminal Court for war crimes and genocide, has demanded that UNAMID
and the UN turn over the five, who “sought refuge in the Community
Policing Center of the Kalma Camp for Internally Displaced Persons”
after an outburst of violence in the camp.
Bashir's
government
imposed a blockade on the camp, not allowing in food or fuel or
medicine, and now seeks to close down the camp.
A
draft letter
from UNAMID chief Ibrahim Gambari to Sudanese Foreign Minister Ali
Karti recites that Bashir's government “explained its position of
principle that Sudan has the right to apply the death penalty as such
a penalty is not illegal under international law and is part of
Sudan's criminal code.”
Nevertheless,
Gambari
writes, “without prejudice to its position of principle,
the Government has undertaken to work in a co-operative manner with
UNAMID... with a view to bringing the issue to a mutually acceptable
conclusion.”
Click here to see
Gambari's letter, as obtained exclusively by Inner City Press.
In
the concluding
paragraph of his letter, Gambari “propose[s] that the issue of the
five individuals be brought to a conclusion... on the basis of the
additional
terms set forth in the attachment hereto... to ensure that
the five individuals concerned are transferred to the relevant
authorities of the Government.”
So
what are the
terms under which the UN, Gambari and UNAMID would turn over the five
to Bashir's government?
Click here to see
Gambari's and the UN's Additional Terms, as obtained exclusively by
Inner City Press.
Amazingly to some, under Gambari's
Additional Terms, “blood relatives of the victims of the alleged
crimes will be called upon to exercise their power to waive the death
penalty and seek payment of compensation in the form of 'blood money'
instead.”
UN's Ban shakes with Bashir, Kalma Five and blood
money not shown
This
in
reminiscent of an incident in Geneina, multiply described to Inner
City Press, in which UNAMID became involved in and even proposed the
payment of “blood money” by IDPs to janjaweed who came into the
camp beating up IDPs and demanding money for a person they said had
been killed.
The
“Additional
Terms of the Government's assurances for the transfer of the five
individuals from the Kalma CPC to the host country authorities”
ends with assurances that “UNAMID's Human Rights Division” could
visit the prisoners, and that Bashir's government will not “undermine
UNAMID's ability to conduct its activities.”
But
Bashir's
government has restricted the movement of UNAMID peacekeepers and
helicopters, as peacekeepers and civilians as in the Tarabat Market
early this money lay dying. The UN's human rights divisions in Sudan
have been accused by opposition leaders of failing even to come on a
timely basis to examine the body of a slain Darfuri student.
(The UN
says it tried, but the Government stopped it -- even if true, hardly
a basis for replying on the assurances in the Additional Terms. On
September 27, Inner City Press asked a series of questions to Gambari,
UN Humanitarian Coordinator Georg Charpentier and Under Secretary
General for Field Support Susana Malcorra, click here for
article, here
for video.)
In
this case of
the five, UNAMID would rely on “the Ajaweed traditional justice”
and, again amazingly, that “the President” -- indicted war
criminal Omar al Bashir -- “has the prerogative of mercy which he
has confirmed he will exercise in the event that the death penalty is
imposed on the accused.”
To
many, this is a
new low for the UN: accepting the promise of an indicted war criminal
not to kill again as a basis to turn over more of his enemies to him.
Watch this site.
* * *
After
Sudan
Tripartite Meeting, UN Paints A Happy Picture of Darfur, But
Questions Remain
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
September 27, 2010 -- Outside the meeting at the UN to
address Sudan restrictions on movements and humanitarian access,
Sudan's Permanent Representative told Inner City Press that
everything was going smoothly inside, no complaints.
Upon
exiting, the
chief of the UN Department of Field Support Susana Malcorra also
painted a positive picture. Inner City Press asked about restrictions
on the use of helicopters, and about the UNAMID peacekeepers in
Darfur not getting to part of Jebal Marra since February, and not
getting to the Tarabat Market, where over 50 were killed, earlier
this month.
UNAMID
chief
Ibrahim Gambari acknowledged that the response to Tarabat Market had
been too slow. But when Inner City Press asked if, going forward,
permission from the Sudanese authorities would still be required to
move, his answer wasn't clear. He said that Sudan could still cite
security as a basis to move allow movement.
UN's Malcorra, Gambari, Charpentier, a
Sudanese official UN Photo left unidentified
UN
Humanitarian
Coordinator Georg Charpentier talked about a meeting with Sudan's
Humanitarian Affairs minister, at which he said access was granted to
Jebel Marra.
Outgoing UN
Humanitarian chief John Holmes had spoken of
no access since February 2010. Equally at odds with that other UN
officials have told Inner City Press, Charpentier on Monday said on
camera that other than joint press releases, he has not shown his
press releases to Sudanese authorities. We'll see.
* * *
On
Sudan,
Obama Non-Mention of ICC Used for Support of Bashir by OIC
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
September 27, 2010 -- The omissions
in US President Obama's
speech at the UN's Sudan meeting on September 24 were noticed not
only by Sudan, whose Vice President Taha praised the new US approach,
but also by the wider Organization of the Islamic Conference.
Inner
City Press
asked OIC Secretary General Ekmeleddin Ihsanoglu at his September 27
press conference about Paragraph 21 of the OIC's September 24
Communique, that
“21.
The Meeting expressed its full solidarity with the Sudan under the
leadership of H.E. President Omar Hassan Ahmed Al-Bashir and renewed
its unflinching support for the various endeavors to achieve genuine
national reconciliation, lasting peace and stability within the
context of a sovereign and united country. The Meeting reiterated the
OIC principled position on the International Criminal Court’s (ICC)
indictment against the President of the Sudan and warned of its
implications on the ongoing Darfur peace process in Doha.”
In
response,
Ihsanoglu insisted that the OIC or at least he himself believes in
accountability for the crimes in Darfur, but believe that the
International Criminal Court through “certain of its statements”
has set up the ICC “as a political party, a contender to the
government.”
“Even President
Obama,” Ihsanoglu continued, “did not mention the International
Criminal Court” in which speech at the September 24 meeting on
Sudan.
Obama and PGA Deiss, mention of ICC or Bashir not
shown, OIC notices
Inner
City Press
reported
that day on Obama's failure to mention the name of Omar al
Bashir, indicted by the ICC for genocide and war crimes. Now the
OIC
is making much of Obama's failure to mention the ICC, as supporting
the OIC's statement of full solidarity with Bashir, and against the
indictments.
What
will Obama or
his State Department say? Watch this site.
Footnote: beyond
Obama's omissions, it has been argued to Inner City Press that the US
was behind the opening up the September 24 meeting to the Press and
public, against push back from parties unnamed. Openness is all the good - duly noticed.
Click
here
for an Inner City Press YouTube channel video, mostly UN Headquarters
footage, about civilian
deaths
in Sri Lanka.
Click here for Inner City
Press' March 27 UN debate
Click here for Inner City
Press March 12 UN (and AIG
bailout) debate
Click here for Inner City
Press' Feb 26 UN debate
Click
here
for Feb.
12
debate
on
Sri
Lanka http://bloggingheads.tv/diavlogs/17772?in=11:33&out=32:56
Click here for Inner City Press' Jan.
16, 2009 debate about Gaza
Click here for Inner City Press'
review-of-2008 UN Top Ten debate
Click here for Inner
City Press' December 24 debate on UN budget, Niger
Click here from Inner City Press'
December 12 debate on UN double standards
Click here for Inner
City Press' November 25 debate on Somalia, politics
and this October 17 debate, on
Security Council and Obama and the UN.
* * *
These
reports are
usually also available through Google
News and on Lexis-Nexis.
Click here
for a Reuters
AlertNet piece by this correspondent
about Uganda's Lord's Resistance Army. Click
here
for an earlier Reuters AlertNet piece about the Somali
National
Reconciliation Congress, and the UN's $200,000 contribution from an
undefined trust fund. Video
Analysis
here
Feedback: Editorial
[at] innercitypress.com
UN
Office:
S-453A,
UN,
NY
10017
USA
Tel:
212-963-1439
Reporter's
mobile
(and
weekends):
718-716-3540
Other,
earlier
Inner
City
Press
are
listed
here,
and
some are available
in the ProQuest service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright
2006-2010
Inner
City
Press,
Inc.
To
request
reprint
or
other
permission,
e-contact
Editorial
[at]
innercitypress.com
-
|