At
UN,
As Clinton Accuses Sudan of Harassing Witnesses, Karti Denies, Hague
Meets
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
November 16 -- US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton at the
UN
Security Council's Sudan meeting Tuesday morning referred to
Khartoum having arrested and harassed even people who met with the
Council in Darfur in October. She said "activists are arrested, some
merely for speaking to members of this Security Council."
Afterward
Inner
City Press asked UK Foreign Minister William Hague about the
statement, and what has been done by the UK, which led the leg of the
Council's trip that went to Darfur. Hague said he would be raising
the issue to the Sudanese later in the day.
As
the Council
meeting moved behind closed doors, Sudan's Foreign Minister Ali Karti
came out to take questions. His delegation urged two reporters to ask
Karti about improved relations with the United States.
Inner
City Press
asked Karti directly about the people arrested after the Security
Council traveled to the Abu Shouk camp for internally displaced
people outside El Fasher in Darfur. Karti insisted that these were
“gang members” apprehended by Sudan.
Minutes
later,
Karti and his entourage went into the Security Council chambers.
Inner City Press asked if this would be the Karti - Hague meeting,
and was told “yes.”
Sudan's Ali Karti meet UN's Ban, Kim & Le Roy,
harassment of witnesses not shown
Ten minutes
later, the Southern Sudan
delegation went in. Can't tell the players without a scorecard.
Footnote:
Inner
City Press also asked Karti about the statements by Hillary
Clinton and Hague that the US and UK are working on reducing Sudan's
debt. These are just talks, Karti said, while calling them positive.
Sudan's Permanent Representative then read off of a paper, “someone
asked about new good will with the US.” Karti lit up, said it seems
that this might be. A reporter asked about the International Criminal
Court. “The US is not a member,” Sudan's Permanent Representative
answered, smiling.
* * *
At
UN
on Sudan, Scratchy Mbeki, UN Silent on Bombs,
Hillary on Decoupling Darfur
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
November 16, updated below -- The UN Security
Council ministerial meeting
on Sudan was kicked off Tuesday morning by UK Foreign Minister
William Hague reading out a Presidential Statement, largely
boilerplate about the Southern Sudan referendum scheduled for January
9. On Darfur, it condemned “militia attacks on civilians,” then
government aerial bombardments.
The
day previous,
Inner City Press asked Secretary General Ban Ki-moon's acting Deputy
Spokesman Farhan Haq about one such bombing:
Inner
City
Press: over the weekend, there was this incident in which the
South Sudanese said that Khartoum or the Sudanese Air Force has
bombed Southern Sudanese territory. What has been found about the
casualties, injuries and what comments does the UN have on this
bombing in South Sudan territory?
Acting
Deputy
Spokesperson Haq: We don’t. We were trying to get some
information, but we didn’t have a confirmation of that particular
fighting. If we get any further details, including a confirmation,
we’d have something.
But
for the rest of
the day, and the following morning, no information was provided. As
with attacks in Darfur, the UN tries to not see and not report. And
to not be seen -- while envoys to Sudan Haile Menkerios and Ibrahim
Gambari are to brief the Council on Tuesday, it will be by video and
only in closed consultations, not allowing any questions from the
Press.
Among
the
questions Gambari is ducking is his negotiation with Sudanese Foreign
Minister Ali Karti, in attendance Tuesday, to turn over five
supporters of Fur rebel Abdel Wahid Nur to the government of Omar al
Bashir, indicted already for war crimes and genocide.
Gambari
has tried
to get a written commitment against the death penalty -- many doubt
its credibility -- while saying nothing about evidence that Sudan
engages in torture. To many, it is a new low for the UN.
The
Council itself
has shown a failure to follow through. After they visited the Abu
Shouk camp in Darfur on October 8, people who had planned and
attended the meetings were harassed and arrested by the Sudanese
authorities. So far nothing has been done.
The
UN's
humanitarian chief Valerie Amos, visiting a month later, at first
spoke of “fear,” then modified that to blame the internally
displaced people for not meeting with her.
While
the European
Union
held a session on Sudan on November 14, attended by some 60
people, many EU member states have yet to follow through on this
commitments to the “Basket Fund” for the Southern Sudan
referendum.
After
Hague read
out the Presidential Statement, Ban Ki-moon read a speech. On Darfur,
he blamed the rebels for not joining the supposedly successful Doha
negotiation process, moribund until December 19.
Hillary
Clinton
walked in, rebuffing a question about what she expected from the
meeting. One might have asked, why did you decouple Darfur?
Hillary and Hague preivously, before Darfur decoupled
In
the chamber,
Thabo Mbeki spoke by scratchy video link which few could understand.
Hague said there had been a power failure in Jo'burg, which Mbeki
denied. He would be followed by Ali Karti, Pagan Amum of the SPLM
then Hillary.
In
order
thereafter, Spindelegger of Austria -- which hosted a human rights
reception on Monday night, no mention of Nobel Peace Prize winner Liu
Xiaobo, Sven Alkalaj of Bosnia, Odein Ajumogobia of Nigeria, Henry
Okello Oryem of Uganda, Takeaski Matsumoto of Japan, Antonio de
Aguiar Patroita of Brazil then mere Ambassadors. Watch this space.
Update
of
10:37 am - Ali Karti says his government met its responsibilities
to the referendum, denounces Darfur rebels as “saboteurs” who
hide behind civilians. Outside the meeting, so far two people have
fallen on the stairs, including the EU's representative Rosalind
Marsden. An African diplomat tells Inner City Press the AU shound be
running the show.
A
sad
and telling e-mail from the UN Department of Public Information:
Subject:
Correction - the Security
Council meeting is on the Sudan NOT on
Darfur
From: Dpi Mdc [at] un.org
Date: Tue, Nov 16, 2010 at
10:18 AM
Media
Documents
Centre
Update
of
11:03 am -- Hague, speaking for UK, says “What I have heard
today from our four distinguished briefers convinces me that there
can be peace and stability in Sudan.” But this was written BEFORE
any of the four briefers spoke. It seems doubtful that Ali Karti of
Sudan shared his statement with the UK before he delivered it. Hague
as clairvoyant?
Update
of
11:10 am - while Hillary Clinton says Darfur important, says
journalists and activists arrested “some merely for speaking to
members of this Council,” she does not explain why Obama
administration now offers to take Sudan off terrorism sanctions list
without regard to what they do in Darfur. Will she take a question on
this?
, 
