By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
July 7,
updated 5:44
pm & 7:44
pm -- Amid
reports that
in Syria, aid
deliveries
resumed to the
Yarmouk camp for
the first time
in six weeks,
in New York
Australia,
Luxembourg and
Jordan invited
other UN
Security Council
members'
Permanent
Representatives
to a meeting
on their draft
resolution at
5 pm on July
7.
With no UN
Television
camera outside
the Council -
and no other
media there --
Inner City
Press asked
Australia's
Permanent
Representative
Gary Quinlan,
"Is this the
showdown?"
Quinlan
genially
replied that
this is "the
big time." And
many but not
all Permanent
Representatives
filed in. How
might the
advances of
ISIS or the Islamic
State impact
the talks?
Update
of 7:44 pm -
while meeting
that began at
5 pm
continues,
here's what
purports to be
the draft,
with buzz the
Operative
Paragraphs 2
and 3 are
proving the most
troublesome:
Draft
Resolution
text
3 July 2014
The
Security
Council,
PP1
Recalling its
resolutions
2042 (2012),
2043 (2012),
2118 (2013)
and 2139
(2014), and
its
Presidential
Statements of
3 August 2011,
21 March 2012,
5 April 2012
and 2 October
2013,
PP2
Reaffirming
its strong
commitment to
the
sovereignty,
independence,
unity and
territorial
integrity of
Syria, and to
the purposes
and principles
of the Charter
of the United
Nations,
PP3
Being appalled
at the
unacceptable
and escalating
level of
violence and
the death of
approximately
150,000
people,
including well
over 10,000
children, as a
result of the
Syrian
conflict as
reported by
the Special
Representative
of the
Secretary-General
for Children
and Armed
Conflict,
PP4
Expressing
grave alarm at
the
significant
and rapid
deterioration
of the
humanitarian
situation in
Syria, at the
fact that the
number of
people in need
of assistance
has grown to
over 10
million,
including over
4.5 million
living in
hard-to-reach
areas, and
that over
240,000 are
trapped in
besieged
areas, as
reported by
the United
Nations
Secretary-General,
PP5
Deploring the
fact that the
demands in its
resolution
2139 (2014)
and the
provisions of
its
Presidential
Statement of 2
October 2013
(S/PRST/2013/15)
have not been
heeded by the
Syrian parties
to the
conflict as
stated in the
United Nations
Secretary-General’s
reports of 22
May 2014
(S/2014/365)
and 20 June
2014
(S/2014/427),
and
recognizing
that, while
some steps
have been
undertaken by
the Syrian
parties, they
have not had
the necessary
impact on the
delivery of
humanitarian
assistance to
all people in
need
throughout
Syria,
PP6
Commending the
indispensable
and ongoing
efforts of the
United
Nations, its
specialized
agencies and
all
humanitarian
and medical
personnel in
Syria and in
neighboring
countries to
alleviate the
impact of the
conflict on
the Syrian
people,
PP7
Reiterating
its
appreciation
for the
significant
and admirable
efforts that
have been made
by the
countries of
the region,
notably
Lebanon,
Jordan,
Turkey, Iraq
and Egypt, to
accommodate
the more than
2.8 million
refugees who
have fled
Syria as a
result of
ongoing
violence
including the
approximately
300,000
refugees who
have fled
since the
adoption of
resolution
2139 (2014),
PP8
Strongly
condemning the
continuing
widespread
violations of
human rights
and
international
humanitarian
law by the
Syrian
authorities,
as well as the
human rights
abuses and
violations of
international
humanitarian
law by armed
groups,
PP9
Expressing
grave alarm in
particular at
the continuing
indiscriminate
attacks in
populated
areas,
including an
intensified
campaign of
aerial
bombings and
the use of
barrel bombs
in Aleppo and
other areas,
artillery,
shelling and
air strikes,
and the
widespread use
of torture,
ill-treatment,
sexual and
gender-based
violence as
well as all
grave
violations and
abuses
committed
against
children, and
reiterating
that some of
these
violations may
amount to war
crimes and
crimes against
humanity,
PP10
Reaffirming
the primary
responsibility
of the Syrian
authorities to
protect the
population in
Syria and
reiterating
that parties
to armed
conflict bear
the primary
responsibility
to take all
feasible steps
to ensure the
protection of
civilians,
PP11
Recalling the
need for all
parties to
respect the
relevant
provisions of
international
humanitarian
law and the
United Nations
guiding
principles of
humanitarian
assistance,
PP12
Expressing
grave alarm at
the spread of
extremism and
extremist
groups, the
targeting of
civilians
based on their
ethnicity,
religion
and/or
confessional
affiliations,
expressing
further grave
alarm at the
increased
attacks
resulting in
numerous
casualties and
destruction,
indiscriminate
shelling by
mortars, car
bombs, suicide
attacks,
tunnel bombs
as well as
hostage
taking,
kidnappings,
and attacks
against
civilian
infrastructure
including
deliberate
interruptions
of water
supply,
condemning
terrorism in
all its forms
and
manifestations
and recalling
in this regard
its
resolutions
1373 (2001),
1624 (2005),
2129 (2013)
and 2133
(2014),
PP13
Deeply
disturbed by
the continued,
arbitrary and
unjustified
withholding of
consent to
relief
operations and
the
persistence of
conditions
that impede
the delivery
of
humanitarian
supplies to
destinations
within Syria,
in particular
to besieged
and
hard-to-reach
areas, and
noting the
United Nations
Secretary-General’s
view that
arbitrarily
withholding
consent for
the opening of
all relevant
border
crossings is a
violation of
international
humanitarian
law and an act
of
non-compliance
with
resolution
2139 (2014),
PP14
Emphasizing
that the
humanitarian
situation will
continue to
deteriorate in
the absence of
a political
solution to
the crisis,
reiterating
its
endorsement of
the Geneva
Communiqué of
30 June 2012
(Annex II of
resolution
2118 (2013))
and demanding
that all
parties work
towards the
immediate and
comprehensive
implementation
of the Geneva
Communiqué
aimed at
bringing an
immediate end
to all
violence,
violations and
abuses of
human rights
and violations
of
international
law, and
facilitating
the Syrian-led
process
launched in
Montreux on 22
January 2014,
leading to a
transition
that meets the
legitimate
aspirations of
the Syrian
people and
enables them
independently
and
democratically
to determine
their own
future,
PP15
Recalling its
intent,
expressed in
its resolution
2139 (2014),
to take
further steps
in the case of
non-compliance
with the
resolution,
PP16
Determining
that the
deteriorating
humanitarian
situation in
Syria
constitutes a
threat to
international
peace and
security in
the region,
PP17
Underscoring
that Member
States are
obligated
under Article
25 of the
Charter of the
United Nations
to accept and
carry out the
Council’s
decisions,
1. Reiterates
that all
parties to the
conflict, in
particular the
Syrian
authorities,
must comply
with their
obligations
under
international
humanitarian
law and
international
human rights
law and must
fully and
immediately
implement the
provisions of
its resolution
2139 (2014)
and its
Presidential
Statement of 2
October 2013
(S/PRST/2013/15);
2. Decides
that the
United Nations
humanitarian
agencies and
their
implementing
partners are
authorized to
use the most
direct routes,
including
across
conflict lines
and with
notification
to the Syrian
authorities
the additional
border
crossings of
Bab al-Salam,
Bab al-Hawa,
Al Yarubiyah
and Tal
Shihab, in
order to
ensure that
humanitarian
assistance,
including
medical and
surgical
supplies,
reaches people
in need
throughout
Syria, and to
this end
stresses the
need for all
border
crossings to
be used
efficiently
for United
Nations
humanitarian
operations;
3. Decides to
establish a
monitoring
mechanism,
under the
authority of
the United
Nations
Secretary-General,
to monitor,
with the
consent of the
relevant
neighboring
countries of
Syria, the
loading of all
humanitarian
relief
consignments
of the United
Nations
humanitarian
agencies and
their
implementing
partners, at
the relevant
United Nations
facilities,
for passage
into Syria
across the
border
crossings of
Bab al-Salam,
Bab al-Hawa,
Al Yarubiyah
and Tal
Shihab, in
order to
confirm the
humanitarian
nature of
these relief
consignments;
4. Further
decides that
the United
Nations
mechanism
shall be
deployed
expeditiously,
for an initial
period of 120
days from the
adoption of
this
resolution;
5. Also
decides that
all Syrian
parties to the
conflict shall
enable the
immediate and
unhindered
delivery of
humanitarian
assistance
directly to
people
throughout
Syria, by the
United Nations
and other
humanitarian
actors, on the
basis of
United Nations
assessments of
need and
devoid of any
political
prejudices and
aims,
including by
immediately
removing all
impediments to
the provision
of
humanitarian
assistance;
6. Notes in
this regard
the role that
ceasefire
agreements
that are
consistent
with
humanitarian
principles and
international
humanitarian
law could play
to facilitate
the delivery
of
humanitarian
assistance in
order to help
save civilian
lives, and
further
underscores
the need for
the parties to
agree on
humanitarian
pauses, days
of
tranquility,
localized
ceasefires and
truces to
allow
humanitarian
agencies safe
and unhindered
access to all
affected areas
in Syria in
accordance
with
international
humanitarian
law, and
recalls that
starvation of
civilians as a
method of
combat is
prohibited by
international
humanitarian
law;
7. Further
decides that
all Syrian
parties to the
conflict shall
take all
appropriate
steps to
ensure the
safety and
security of
United Nations
and associated
personnel,
those of its
specialized
agencies, and
all other
personnel
engaged in
humanitarian
relief
activities as
required by
international
humanitarian
law, without
prejudice to
their freedom
of movement
and access,
stresses that
the primary
responsibility
in this regard
lies with the
Syrian
authorities,
further
stresses the
need not to
impede these
efforts, and
recalls that
attacks on
humanitarian
workers may
amount to war
crimes;
8. Reiterates
that the only
sustainable
solution to
the current
crisis in
Syria is
through an
inclusive and
Syrian-led
political
process with a
view to full
implementation
of the Geneva
Communiqué of
30 June 2012
endorsed as
Annex II of
its resolution
2118 (2013),
pays tribute
to the efforts
of Dr. Lakhdar
Brahimi, and
calls upon the
United Nations
Secretary-General
to appoint a
successor as
soon as
practicable;
9. Requests
the
Secretary-General
to report to
the Council on
the
implementation
of this
resolution,
and on
compliance
with it by all
Syrian parties
to the
conflict,
within the
framework of
its reporting
on resolution
2139 (2014);
10. Decides in
the event of
non-compliance
with this
resolution or
resolution
2139 (2014) by
any Syrian
party to take
measures
directed
against that
party under
the Charter of
the United
Nations;
11. Decides to
remain
actively
seized of the
matter.
Update
of 5:44 pm --
UNRWA
Spokesperson,
Chris Gunness
said:
There
were dramatic
and chaotic
scenes today
as UNRWA
distributed
food in the
besieged
Palestinian
refugee camp
of
Yarmouk
in Damascus
for the first
time in six
weeks. We were
authorized to
resume food
distributions
following an
interruption
stretching
back to 23
May. In about
two hours of
action, an
UNRWA team
delivered food
parcels,
bread, jam and
vitamin
supplements to
209 civilian
families in
Yarmouk.
The UNRWA team
arrived at the
northern
Bateekhah
entrance of
Yarmouk at
11:00 hrs but
was held up on
account of
security
concerns. As
the team
waited at the
Bateekha
entrance in
the north of
Yarmouk,
gunfire inside
the camp
reportedly
resulted in
non-life
threatening
injuries to
two civilians.
The team
eventually
commenced its
work at 14:30
hrs at the
distribution
point adjacent
to Rama Street
inside
Yarmouk.
The
distribution
initially
proceeded in
an organized
manner in
spite of the
large crowds
of expectant
civilians
surging
forward in the
hope of
receiving food
assistance.
The flood of
people quickly
became
overwhelming,
bringing an
end to the
distribution
effort at
16:30 hrs. The
UNRWA team
persisted in
the hope that
order would be
restored
allowing more
civilian
families to
receive help.
However after
making a
further
unsuccessful
distribution
attempt at
17:00 hrs, the
UNRWA team
withdrew,
having
received
assurances
that food
distribution
will continue
on 8 July
2014.
UNRWA welcomes
the resumption
of its food
distribution
inside
Yarmouk. With
the support
and
facilitation
of Syrian
authorities,
we hope that
the
distribution
of UNRWA food
parcels will
in future
experience no
further
interruptions.
This will
ensure that in
every working
day of
distributions,
a
significantly
higher number
of Yarmouk's
civilians can
receive the
food and
nutrition they
desperately
need so that
their
suffering can
be alleviated.
UNRWA
as always
stands ready
to implement a
rapid
humanitarian
programme to
respond to the
immediate and
longer term
needs of the
civilians of
Yarmouk.
UNRWA
will maintain
its advocacy
for
continuous,
substantial
and safe
humanitarian
access to
Yarmouk, and
for the
protection of
Palestinian
and Syrian
civilians.
Any impact on
the
negotiations
in the
Security
Council?
After UN
Humanitarian
chief Valerie
Amos briefed
the Security
Council about
Syria on June
26, Australian
Permanent
Representative
Gary Quinlan
came out of
the Council to
speak to the
press about a
pending draft
resolution on
humanitarian
access.
Quinlan
said,
“we understand
the Syrian
government has
never made one
single
complaint to
the UN
anything other
than
humanitarian
material was
in any convoy,
any
humanitarian
convoy into
the country.”
Inner
City Press
remembered
there had been
an issue with
a convoy from
Turkey, and an
hour later
asked
Australia's
Mission to the
UN:
I want
to make sure I
understand
something --
Ambassador
Quinlan seemed
to be saying
there have not
been any
issues with
anything other
than
humanitarian
material in
any
humanitarian
convoy into
Syria. I
remembered
something,
then looked up
and found:
http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/fr/contents/articles/security/2014/05/turkey-syria-air-attack-humanitarian-convoy-lessons.html
and,
Al
Jazeera:
http://www.aljazeera.com/news/middleeast/2014/01/turkish-police-raid-charity-aiding-syria-201411411543616402.html