UNICEF
Speaks on
Child Soldiers
In Syria, FSA
Not Cited by
Lake
By
Matthew
Russell Lee,
Follow Up on
Exclusive
UNITED
NATIONS,
February 5 --
UNICEF
director Tony
Lake, former
US National
Security Adviser,
has spoken out
today about
the UN report
on child
soldiers in
Syria. But he
neglects to
mention that
the Free
Syrian Army,
supported by
the US and
many countries
on the UNICEF
board, is
shown to
recruit and
use child
soldiers.
After 6 pm on
February 5
UNICEF put
this out:
The
grave
violations
against
children cited
in the report
demand a
response.
UNICEF joins
the Secretary
General in
calling for an
immediate end
to the
targeting of
innocent
children and
civilians,
including the
use of weapons
that cause
indiscriminate
and
disproportionate
harm, such as
those employed
in a deadly
wave of
attacks across
Aleppo this
week.
In
a meeting of
the UNICEF
Executive
Board today,
UNICEF
Executive
Director
Anthony Lake
said that all
those involved
in the
conflict
and those who
have influence
over them have
an obligation
to do
everything
possible to
protect
children from
violence –
violence
that is not of
children’s
making, and in
which they
should play no
part.
Just as the US
is trying not
to directly
answer on the
implications
of the FSA
portion of the
report, under
the 2008 US
Child Soldiers
Prevention
Act, UNICEF
does not
mention this
aspect. But
might they act
on it?
Yesterday,
Lake answered
Inner City
Press'
question on
the looting
and use of
UNICEF backpacks
by the army of
South Sudan, a
US ally, video
here.
Amid reports
that the US
already
provides or is
ready to
provide aid to
armed groups
in Syria like
the Free
Syrian Army
(FSA), on
January 29
Inner City
Press first
highlighted
and then on
January 30
asked the US
Mission to the
UN a finding
in the UN's
then-unpublished
report on
Children and
Armed Conflict
in Syria:
"Throughout
the
reporting
period, the
United Nations
received
consistent
reports of
recruitment
and use of
children by
FSA-affiliated
groups."
The US
has cited the
recruitment
and use of
child soldiers
to suspend US
aid to armies
of governments
which had
previously
been receiving
it.
Inner City
Press asked,
so how could
the US provide
aid to a
non-state
group which
even the UN
has found
using child
soldiers?
The US Mission
to the UN was
asked, orally
and then in
writing, on
January 29.
Another
mission said
it would only
comment after
the
report was
published and
became
official.
On February 4,
the UK Mission
to the UN
provided this
response to
Inner City
Press:
"The
UK absolutely
condemns the
use of child
soldiers in
all cases, and
strongly
supports
international
efforts to
stop the use
of child
soldiers. We
urge all
parties in the
Syrian
conflict to
release any
children held
in detention.
"Armed
conflict
affects
millions of
lives around
the world, and
children are
among those
most
vulnerable to
the effects of
conflict. The
only way to
secure the
long-term
future of
Syria’s
children is to
find a
political
solution to
the crisis.
"We
have made
clear our
absolute
condemnation
of the use of
child
soldiers. As
noted in this
report, the
use of child
soldiers by
the opposition
is not
systematic and
is limited to
certain
elements. We
have provided
training to
the Supreme
Military
Council of the
Syrian
opposition on
the law of
armed
conflict, and
will continue
to work with
them to help
ensure that
they meet
their
obligations
under
international
law."
As
Inner City
Press noted,
that might be
OK for the
United Kingdom
-- but what
about the US,
including in
light of the 2008 Child
Soldiers
Prevention Act,
which provides
for example:
It is
the sense of
Congress that—
(1)
the United
States
Government
should condemn
the
conscription,
forced
recruitment,
or use of
children by
governments,
paramilitaries,
or other
organizations;
(2)
the United
States
Government
should support
and, to the
extent
practicable,
lead efforts
to establish
and uphold
international
standards
designed to
end the abuse
of human
rights
described in
paragraph (1);
There are
prohibitions
on funding
which can only
be overridden
for formal,
public
findings by
the President.
Given all
this, Inner
City Press on
February 4
again asked
two
spokespeople
for the US
Mission to the
UN its January
30 question:
"could the US
provide aid to
a non-state
group, the FSA
and its
affiliates,
which the UN
has found
using child
soldiers?"
Now we add:
(in)
consistent
with the Child
Soldiers
Prevention Act
of 2008.
The
report, now
issued as a
document of
the UN
Security
Council under
the symbol
S/2014/31,
goes on to
recount:
"Boys
aged 12 to 17
were trained,
armed, and
used as
combatants or
to man
checkpoints.
For instance,
a 15 year-old
boy reported
being
recruited in
April 2012 by
the FSA in
Tall Kalakh
(Tartus
governate),
and
participation
in military
operations....
Also
indicative was
the case of a
16 year-old
boy from Homs
who reportedly
joined the FSA
as a
combatant. In
March 2013,
his family
reported to
the United
Nations that
he was still
fighting with
the group."
And
is
this boy still
fighting with
the FSA? There
is more to be
said about
this UN
report, but as
to the US and
the recent
report it is
or is moving
toward aiding
the armed FSA,
what steps
will be taken
on this UN
report? Watch
this site.
Footnote:
While the US
does sometimes
answer
questions, and
is often
pleasant as
for example on a recent
inquiry with
the State
Department
about Sri
Lanka, too
often it does
not.
The US Mission
never provided
an explanation
of what
several
Security
Council
members told
Inner City
Press the US
Mission had
said about its
"policy" on
how to
described the
Rwanda
genocide;
the State
Department in
Washington
appears to
have a policy
of limiting
its most
timely
information
alternatively
to
"mainstream"
-- often
meaning dying
or
pro-Administration
-- media and
to those which
support its
positions.
But we will
keep asking.
Watch this
site.
* * *
These
reports
are
usually also available through Google
News and on Lexis-Nexis.
Click here
for Sept 26, 2011 New Yorker on Inner City
Press at UN
Click
for
BloggingHeads.tv re Libya, Sri Lanka, UN
Corruption
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
UN Office: S-303,
UN, NY 10017 USA
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest service,
and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2014 Inner City Press,
Inc. To request reprint or other permission,
e-contact Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
|