At UN,
Legal Fight of
Ban's Layoffs
Approved,
Censorship by
his Scribes
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
UNITED
NATIONS,
January 23 --
While the UN
more and
more dubiously
preaches
democracy and
even lack of
censorship
around the
world, in two
elections held
last month
inside the UN,
disputes and
decay were the
rule.
In the
UN Staff Union
election, in
which an
incumbent
sought to stay
on despite
term limits,
there were charges
of illegal
polling, and
an attempt to
stop paying
the Elections
Services
Company.
On the afternoon
of January 23,
though, there
was an
"Emergency
General
Meeting of
Staff" held in
the ECOSOC
Chamber, at
which a
resolution was
adopted
concerning
Secretary
General Ban
Ki-moon's New
Years Eve
layoff
notices. The
resolution
foresees a
legal defense
for staff, and
"decides" that
the incumbent
"should desist
from claiming
that she is
still president."
This situation
in New York
serves the Ban
administration,
even as
Catherine
Pollard meets
with its staff
in Geneva. In
New York
back on
December 20,
Inner City
Press asked
the UN's
acting deputy
spokesperson
Farhan Haq:
Inner
City
Press: On the
staff union
election that
just took
place, given
that it’s
budget crunch
time,
according to
the
Secretariat,
who is its
interlocutor?
Who is the
head of the
staff union,
the previous
incumbent or
the team that
was announced
as the winner
on iSeek?
Acting
Deputy
Spokesperson
Haq: Regarding
the staff
representatives,
it’s
ultimately up
to them
members of the
staff to
determine who
their
leadership is.
It would not,
you know, I
don’t think
it’s
appropriate
for this
Office to
intervene in
their affairs.
Inner
City
Press: So, who
do you speak
to now? If you
had to talk to
the staff
union, which
of the two
would you
call?
Acting
Deputy
Spokesperson
Haq: They will
have, like I
said, they’ll
have to
resolve it.
I’m not going
to say
anything
prejudicial to
their process,
nor do I think
that they
would
appreciate
that.
On December 17
Inner City
Press
published the
results, putting
the document
online here:
Winner
with 430
votes:
Ticket 1 [They
have thanked
voters]
President
Stephen
Kisambira
(DESA/PD)
First
Vice-President
Emad Hassanin
(DGACM/MPD/PS)
Second
Vice-President
Leonid
Dolgopolov
(DSS/DSSS/SSS)
2d
place with 231
votes:
Ticket 2
President
Nadir
A. Dirar
Bashir
(DGACM/MPD/PS/DTPU)...
Just before
the January 23
"Emergency
General
Meeting of
Staff" which
authorized
legal
fight-back at
the layoffs,
Ticket 2 sent
out an email
bragging that
"the
recent
responses of
the
Administration
to Leadership
ticket No. 2
are
clearly noted
and respected."
We
will continue
to cover that
showdown,
which is at
least
competitive.
Even more
decayed is the
UN's
Censorship
Alliance,
which while
not even
asking the UN
to hold
a briefing or
answer
questions
about the
crisis in
South Sudan,
re-emerged on
December 22
through once
and future
president Pamela
Falk of CBS
hyping fashion
photographs of
herself with
Ban Ki-moon.
Ban's UN hands
the first
question and
more to UNCA,
which does not
challenge Ban.
Technically
they're called
the United
Nations
Correspondents
Association,
and in
2012 its
leaders tried
to get the investigative
Press thrown
out of the UN,
pointing at a
factual
article Inner
City Press published
about Sri
Lanka, the UN
and conflicts
of interest.
Ban's
Secretariat
now admits on
Sri Lanka a
"systemic
failure" - his
Deputy Jan
Eliasson
repeatedly
says that --
but UNCA,
which still
has no rules
against trying
to throw
journalists
out of the UN,
nor apparently
any conflict
of interest
rules, makes
no admission,
no reforms.
It demands
the first
question at
press
conferences
even if it has
nothing to
ask, or the
answers will
never be
published.
Not
surprisingly
it is in
decay. ng
a 2009 trip to
Sri Lanka with
Ban Ki-moon
and UK
humanitarian
chief Sir John
Holmes not
only didn't
report Holmes
on the record
comment that
he deleted all
complaining
emails from
Tamils -- she
said the Press
reporting this
"ruined"
relations with
Holmes for her
and, for
example,
Reuters.
Though
over 2000
journalists
are accredited
at the UN, in
December 2013
only 111 even
tried to vote
in the three
days of
polling -- and
door to door
demands to
vote for --
the United
Nations
Correspondents
Association.
Seven of these
ballots
failed. The
incumbent
Pamela Falk of
CBS, running
unopposed,
still managed
to not
get 26 of the
104 votes
cast.
But as a
result of
UNCA's "Ball"
with Ban, she
got her fashion
photo in the
NYT Styles
section and
made sure to
hype it up,
online and
in the
briefing room
before being
handed, only
to waste, the
first of four
questions on
the South
Sudan crisis
on December
23.
Falk's
vote total of
78 was lower
than the 85
obtained in
December 2011
by her predecessor,
who was the
one who first
demanded that
Inner City
Press remove
an article
about Sri
Lanka from the
Internet,
click here for
that.
The
article UNCA
"leaders"
tries to
censor
reported on
the previous
financial
relationship
of Sri Lanka's
Permanent
Representative
with UNCA's
then
president, in
the context of
this president
screening in
the UN the Sri
Lankan
government's
war crimes
denial film,
without asking
or the consent
of Inner City
Press then on
the Executive
Committee of
UNCA.
No reforms in
UNCA were ever
instituted
after this.
Inner
City Press
after
withstanding a
kangaroo court
UNCA
proceeding
quit the
organization
and co-founded
the new Free
UN Coalition
for Access,
@FUNCA_info,
to actually
defend the
right of free
press and free
inquiry in and
about the UN
system.
In 2012 UNCA
"leaders"
tried to get
the
investigative
Press thrown
out of the UN,
as documented
by documents
obtained under
the Freedom of
Information
Act. Voice
of America
asked the UN
to "review"
Inner City
Press'
accreditation;
VOA
said it had
the support of
Agence France
Presse and
Reuters,
click here for
that.
The
Reuters first
vice president
of UNCA spied
for the UN,
giving them an
internal anti
Press UNCA
document three
minutes after
promising not
to (story
here, document
here, audio here).
While
he has stepped
off, the
Reuters
reporter he
supervised
(and who also
tried to get
the
investigative
Press thrown
out of the UN)
campaigned to
get on UNCA's
board,
demanded on
camera in a UN
noon briefing
to all
present, "Have
you voted?"
It's as if
Reuters has a
Permanent seat
on UNCA's
15-member
Executive
Committee,
like the P5 in
the Security
Council.
Here
are the
December 2013
results,
compared to
votes in
December 2011
for the
"candidate" or
their
predecessor
Dec
'13 Dec '11
Prez:
* 78 [85]
Pamela Falk,
CBS News TV
and Radio
1st VP
* 74 [79]
Kahraman
Haliscelik,
TRT Turkish
Radio & TV
2d VP
* 48 71 Masood
Haider, Dawn,
Pakistan
* 48
[71] Sylviane
Zehil,
L’Orient Le
Jour
3d VP
* 55 [62] Erol
Avdovic,
Webpublicapress
38 Ali
Barada,
An-Nahar/France
24
Trez *
81 [71]
Bouchra
Benyoussef,
Maghreb Arab
Press
Sect *
79 [81] Seana
Magee, Kyodo
News
Members
at
Large:
* 57
1. Nabil Abi
Saab , Alhurra
TV
* 57
2. Talal
Al-Haj
,Al-Arabiya
News channel
22 3.
George
Baumgarten ,
Jewish
Newspapers,
Nation Media
* 50
4. Sherwin
Bryce-Pease,
South African
Broadcasting
(SABC)
* 51
5. Zhenqiu Gu,
Xinhua News
Agency
* 69
6. Melissa
Kent,
CBC/Radio
Canada
* 56
7. Evelyn
Leopold,
Huffington
Post
Contributor
49 8.
J. Tuyet
Nguyen, German
Press Agency
DPA
* 67
9. Michelle
Nichols,
Reuters
41 10.
Edwin
Nwanchukwu,
News Agency of
Nigeria
27 11.
Cia Pak,
Scannews
*54
12. Valeria
Robecco, ANSA
* 54
13. Sangwon
Yoon ,
Bloomberg
Some
of the elected
are new and
their
positions on
UNCA Executive
Committee
members trying
to get other
(investigative)
media thrown
out of the UN,
and the need
to preclude
this and UNCA
leaders'
anonymous
social media
trolling, are
not yet known.
(Some not
elected were
among the
better / more
diverse
candidates.)
When
the UN
Correspondents
Association
leaders tried
stealthy to
get the
investigative
Press thrown
out of the UN,
and have
failed to
institute any
reform since,
it became the
UN's
Censorship
Alliance.
Party on.
Watch this
site.