UNCA
& VOA Said
They Imposed
Conditions on
Free Press
with Reuters
& AFP
Help, FOIA
Shows
By
Matthew
Russell Lee
WASHINGTON,
January
10 -- The
final nail in
the coffin of
the UN
Correspondents
Association
and its
argument that
its move to
expel Inner
City Press
and get
it
dis-accredited
from the UN
was not about
censorship or
the
content of its
coverage is
revealed by
internal Voice
of America
documents
obtained under
the US Freedom
of Information
Act. New
documents
listed below.
While
the UNCA
Executive
Board was
meeting daily
demanding that
Inner City
Press take
articles off
the Interest,
VOA's Margaret
Besheer wrote
to
her bosses in
Washington and
described the
"charges"
against Inner
City Press.
All
involved
written
content,
ranging from UNCA
conflict of
interests
involving Sri
Lanka to
coverage of
the French
Mission to the
UN and
French
head of UN
Peacekeeping
Herve
Ladsous.
As
previously
reported, Besheer
told her
bosses that
Reuters
and Agence
France-Presse,
on one whose boards
Ladsous served,
both
supported the
move to get
Inner City
Press
dis-accredited
from the
UN.
A stealth
complaint
against Inner
City Press by
Louis
Charbonneau
of Reuters was
fastened on by
VOA as
supporting its
position.
On
June
20, VOA's
Steve Redisch
wrote to the
UN's Stephane
Dujarric
asking that
Inner City
Press accreditation
status at the
UN be
reviewed.
Dujarric wrote
back "thanks,"
and said
he would call
Redisch. Besheer
wrote to
Redisch and
others in
Washington,
"thanks." Click
here for that,
published for
the first time
here.
This
however was
the turning
point, new
documents
show.
As recounted
in e-mails
from
Besheer to her
bosses in
Washington,
Inner City
Press asking
about
the attempt to
dis-accredit
it at the June
21 UN noon
briefing was a
problem (along
with publishing
Redisch's
request).
Click
here for that,
published for
the first time
here.
Later on June
21, the
Broadcasting
Board of
Governors
which oversees
VOA was
fielding
requests from
Congress about
this attempt
to get an
investigative
journalist
thrown out of
the UN.
Inner City
Press filed a
Freedom
of Information
Act request,
which UNCA's
president, now
outgoing, and
past and
apparently
future First
Vice President
Lou
Charbonneau
told
Inner City
Press to
withdraw the
FOIA request.
But Inner City
Press
does not
withdraw FOIA
requests. To
the contrary:
Inner
City
Press is a
media amicus
in
this
just
filed brief
in McBurney
v.
Young,
No. 12-17 of
the US Supreme
Court.
By June
25, BBG
officials were
hoping for "no
more
surprises."
Click
here for that,
published for
the first time
here.
By June
27, five
Governors
on the
Broadcasting
Board of
Governors were
asking for
information
and records,
including
those Inner
City Press had
requested
under
FOIA.
One
of the
Governors
started
pushing for an
open BBG
meeting on the
subject. Click
here for that,
published for
the first time
here.
BBG's lawyers
argued
that it was
somehow a
"personnel
matter,"
although Inner
City Press did
not and would
not work for
VOA.
BBG's David
Ensor wrote to
the
Governors and
then Congress
(but never
Inner City
Press or the
UN)
admitting that
the request to
get the UN to
dis-accredit
Inner City
Press "was not
appropriate."
In preparing
his late July
spin,
David Ensor
wrote "the
quote from
Reuters will
definitely
help!" There's
more, but for
now this is
enough.
Ensor told the
BBG Governors
that
Inner City
Press had
"been given a
warning --
both verbal
and in
writing --
about his
behavior when
on UN
premises."
Redisch
wrote that
conditions had
been imposed
on Inner City
Press using
"UN
rules
regarding
boundaries of
coverage."
No
censorship?
Hardly.
And not
only Voice of
America, but
the UNCA
Executive
Committee,
particularly
but not only
Reuters' Lou
Charbonneau
and AFP's Tim
Witcher, were
instrumental
to this
censorship
campaign.
UNCA crossed a
Rubicon of
censorship. something
is sick within
UNCA, and its
fixed
election,
ending today,
will not
fix it.
The response
of Inner City
Press has been
to launch a
new and
needed
organization
actually
fighting for
media rights
with regard to
the UN: the Free UN Coalition for Access, FUNCA.
Its fliers
have been
defaced and
torn down but
there will be
no stopping
it. Watch this
site.