Inner City Press Investigative Reporting from the SDNY Court, the United Nations, Federal Reserve, IMF and beyond
SDNY Courthouse — Inner City Press
In Other MediaFortune 2023, CJR, NY Mag, AJE, CSM  •  Contact us  •  These reports are usually available through Google News and Lexis-Nexis

As France Takes Over UNSC 2 Straw Polls and Peacekeeping Grudge Test Claimed Transparency

UN GATE / FEDERAL COURT, Aug 30 – France assumes the Security Council presidency September 1, a month expected to include two further straw polls in the selection of the tenth UN Secretary-General — more consequential timing than almost any other presidency this year.

As a permanent member, France's vote in those polls is not treated the same as the ten non-permanent members': straw-poll ballots for the five veto-holders are color-coded separately, precisely because their preferences, unlike everyone else's, can become a veto. 

France's relationship to the UN's own machinery runs deeper than a Council seat. By longstanding, informal P5 arrangement, France has held the Under-Secretary-General post for UN Peacekeeping Operations for most of the last three decades — a position with direct authority over missions across Francophone Africa, the region of France's own colonial history.

Inner City Press has reported before on how close that arrangement came to including Ambassador Jérôme Bonnafont himself: while Inner City Press still covered the UN in person, Bonnafont was a serious contender for (had in fact informally gotten) the Peacekeeping post, until he reportedly spoke too openly about expecting to get it, to jump to the then huge French Mission apartment on Park Avenue from New Delhi . The job went instead to fellow Frenchman Hervé Ladsous. The then AFP correspondent began moves using UNCA, the UN Correspondents Association, to try to get Inner City Press out, which later happened.

That history is worth keeping in mind now that Bonnafont holds the Council presidency itself, at the exact moment the Secretary-General selection he will help gavel through is unfolding.

On August 29, Inner City Press wrote to Ambassador Bonnafont with two distinct requests: that Inner City Press be included in France's September press conferences and given access to this month's straw-poll stakeouts, and, separately, a formal legal request under France's Code des relations entre le public et l'administration, asking what became of an earlier, unanswered letter sent to France as a Committee on Information member.  France has not yet responded to either. We will report on their response, and that of long time UN Spokesperson Stephane Dujarric.  It is not too late.

 Whether a presidency held by a diplomat who once nearly ran UN Peacekeeping himself will treat this September's process with more transparency than Denmark's August did is now, itself, the test. Watch this site.


More on X for Subscribers here and Substack here

Your support means a lot. As little as $5 a month helps keep us going and grants you access to exclusive bonus material on our Patreon page. Click here to become a patron.