For
Enabling
Jeffrey
Epstein Some
Claims Head to
SDNY Trial
Against JPMC
& Deutsche
Bank
By Matthew
Russell Lee, Patreon Maxwell
book
SDNY COURTHOUSE,
March 20 –
J.P. Morgan
Chase and
Deutsche Bank
were sued for
their enabling
of Jeffrey
Epstein, in
lawsuits filed
on
Thanksgiving
in the U.S.
District Court
for the
Southern
District of
New York,
where Inner
City Press
found them in
the docket.
The separate
lawsuits
allege that
"without
exorbitantly
large amounts
of cash,
Epstein's
operations
could not run,
as newly
recruited
victims were
each paid
hundreds of
dollars in
cash
immediately
after Epstein
sexually
abused them,
as hush
money."
The
JPM Chase
complaint is
on Patreon, here.
On March
20, 2023 Judge
Jed S.
Rakoff in a
bottom line
order
dismissed some
but not
all claims,
in the Epstein-related
cases against
JPMC and Deutsche
Bank:
"ORDER
granting in
part and
denying in
part (37)
Motion to
Dismiss;
granting in
part and
denying in
part (43)
Motion to
Dismiss in
case
1:22-cv-10018-JSR;
granting in
part and
denying in
part (31)
Motion to
Dismiss;
granting in
part and
denying in
part (44)
Motion to
Dismiss in
case
1:22-cv-10019-JSR;
granting in
part and
denying in
part (38)
Motion to
Dismiss in
case
1:22-cv-10904-JSR.
On February 1,
2023, and
February 7,
2023,
defendants
filed motions
to dismiss the
operative
complaints in
the
above-captioned
cases. Upon
consideration
of all
parties'
written
submissions
and oral
argument, the
Court hereby
grants those
motions in
part and
denies those
motions in
part, as
specified
below. An
opinion
explaining the
reasons for
these rulings
will follow in
due course.
The Clerk is
respectfully
directed to
close entry
numbers 37 and
43 on the
docket of
22-cv-10018;
numbers 31 and
44 on the
docket of
22-cv-10019;
and number 38
on the docket
of
22-cv-10904.
SO ORDERED..
(Signed by
Judge Jed S.
Rakoff on
3/20/2023)
Filed In
Associated
Cases:
1:22-cv-10018-JSR,
1:22-cv-10019-JSR,
1:22-cv-10904-JSR
(kv).
Inner
City Press put
the order on
its
DocumentCloud
here.
On March
7, 2023 JPM
Chase filed a
third party
complaint
against James
Edward Staley,
including "At
no point did
Staley
disclose to
JPMC, nor did
JPMC otherwise
know, the
information
about Staley’s
personal
activities
contained in
paragraphs 22
through 33..
Staley, not
JPMC, is
responsible
for any
injuries
Epstein may
have caused...." 3d
Party
Complaint on
Inner City
Press'
DocumentCloud
here.
On
March 13 in
order argument
before Judge
Rakoff,
JPMorgan
Chase's lawyer
amplified
this,
emphasizing
that Staley
was not aware
of any
exchange of
money, or of
trafficking. Deutsche
Bank's lawyer
emphasized DB
had paid a
fine to NYS
regulators -
that is, they
gave at the
office. Judge
Rakoff promised a
bottom line
decision by
the end of
March, if not
before.
On
March 16, starting
after 4 pm and
running past 8
pm, Judge Rakoff
held a
hearing,
including
settling
(most) trial
dates and
threatening to
summon or
worse the head of
FinCEN,
to get the Suspicious
Activity
Reports or SARs. Inner
City Press
tweeted, including:
OK -
now at
Epstein-related
case of US
Virgin Islands
vs JPMorgan
Chase, in
which Dimon
discovery has
been ordered,
and JPMC has
filed a
third-party
complaint
against Jes
Staley.
Judge
Rakoff: So,
I'm not going
to move trial
dates. For Doe
v. Deutsche
Bank it's
August 8; for
Doe v. JPM
Chase, and
USVI v. JPM
Chase, it's
September 5. I
am willing to
move motion
dates, but not
the trial. Any
suggestions?
Linda Singer:
I'll open the
bidding.
Judge
Rakoff: Who's
here for Mr.
Staley?
Brendan
Sullivan: I'm
here, and I'm
fine with any
date except
tomorrow,
which is St.
Patrick's Day.
That's a Holy
day. I know
nothing about
this case. I
was only
notified of it
8 days ago.
[Judge
Rakoff
recounted when
Brendan
Sullivan
appeared
before him.
Looking it up,
there are two
cases: US ex
rel. Edward
O'Donnell
(2012-14), and
Cendant
Corporation v.
Forbes (1999)
Judge
Rakoff:
Plaintiffs'
counsel, how
long a trial,
assuming one
overall trial?
A: Ten to 14
days.
Judge Rakoff:
What about
October 23,
for three
weeks, which
would be more
than enough?
Judge
Rakoff:
JPMorgan has
created this
situation. The
banks had
years to know
what they
thought of
him. And they
could have
served him
personally. So
JPM has
created the
problem with
Mr Staley.
Maybe we
should sever
it, or justice
or pay-back,
however you
call it
Judge
Rakoff rules:
I will move
the JPMorgan
trials, and
Jes Staley, to
October 23. If
Deutsche Bank
doesn't want
to join it, it
can remain
August 8. Or
Sept 5. Let me
know quickly,
by close of
business
Monday.
USVI lawyer Mimi Liu, slamming Dimon
and Chase's knowledge
Update:
the JPMChase
(Epstein-related)
case is still
going. Judge
Rakoff: You
have to spell
out each
search term:
not just
Jeffrey but
also Jeff.
Counsel: We
are doing
that. Judge
Rakoff: I'm
glad we had
this
discussion.
Judge
Rakoff: If
this case goes
to trial I
Iearn a party
held back
information, I
may impose
sanctions.
Such as
striking your
case.
Plaintiffs'
counsel: We
have requested
the SARs that
were filed by
JPM Chase or
DB, they say
they need
FinCEN's
permission.
Judge
Rakoff: I
think I can
override that.
And I just
decided to.
Bank counsel:
I think this
is statutory.
Judge Rakoff:
This will be
fun. If they
oppose it, I
will set a
time and place
but no later
than next
week, I will
want a
decision maker
present
Judge
Rakoff: And if
they don't
appear, I'll
have no choice
but to ask the
Marshals to
bring them
before me....
I think the
government,
once they know
the situation,
will be happy
to comply. I'm
not sure I
don't have the
power. The
Supreme Court
may consider
it.
Counsel:
There's a
deposition set
for Jes Staley
next week. We
don't want to
be put out of
the room.
Judge Rakoff:
Call me from
the
deposition. If
I'm on the
bench, my
clerk will
inform you to
call during my
next break.
Let's resolve
it right then
and there.
Judge
Rakoff: I
notice most of
the audience
has wimped out
long ago.
[Inner City
Press still
covering it].
Back in
December 2022,
US Virgin
Islands filed
suit against
JPMorgan
Chase, stating
that "JP
Morgan
knowingly
facilitated,
sustained and
concealed the
human
trafficking
network
operated by
Jeffrey
Epstein from
his home and
base in the
Virgin Islands
and financial
benefited from
this
participating
by failing to
comply with
federal
banking
regulations."
Judge Rakoff
ordered:
"ORDER:
Barring any
objection from
plaintiff
Government of
the United
States Virgin
Islands, which
must be made
by joint
telephone call
to Chambers no
later than
5:00 PM on
January 4,
2023, this
case is hereby
consolidated
for all
pretrial
purposes with
Doe v.
Deutsche Bank,
22- cv-10018
and Doe v. JP
Morgan Chase
& Co.,
22-cv-10019."
Then the
USVI Attorney
General who
sued Chase was
fired: “I
relieved
Denise George
of her duties
as attorney
general this
weekend,” Gov.
Albert Bryan
Jr. said. “I
thank her for
her service to
the people of
the territory
during the
past four
years as
attorney
general and
wish her the
best in her
future
endeavors.
Assistant
Attorney
General Carol
Thomas-Jacobs
will serve as
acting
attorney
general.”
Still, on
January 23
Judge Rakoff
signed off on
Letters
Rogatory in which is
seeking from
Cathy
Alexander, Epstein's
former co-manager
on Little St.
James, all
communications
with Epstein,
Maxwell, Bella
Klein, Daphne
Wallace, Harry
Beller, Leslie
Groff, Sarah
Kellen aka
Sarah Kensington
aka Sarah
Vickers, Erika
Kellerhals, Richard
D. Kahn
and/or Darren
K. Indyke.
Full 19
pages on
Patreon here.
And on
January 30,
Judge Rakoff
signed off an
another letter
rogatory to
Barclays Bank,
for its
communications
with the UK
Financial
Conduct
Authority
about Jes Staley
and his relationship
with Jeffrey
Epstein
including,
reportedly, 1200
emails between
the two.
On February 17,
USVI
filed with the
court a copy of a
subpoena to
Leslie Wexner,
on Patreon here.
On November
29, the Doe
v. bank(s)
cases were
assigned to SDNY
Judge Jed S.
Rakoff, as
"related" to a
previous case
against Deutsche
Bank he has.
Both had
a proceeding
on December 5
that Inner City
Press covered.
In the
courtroom along
with David
Boies, Bradley
Edwards,
Sigrid
McCawley et al
was former
SDNY
prosecutor Robert
Boone (Inner
City Press
covered him in
the Michael
Avenatti -
Stormy Daniels
criminal
case), now representing
JPMorgan
Chase.
Both
cases have the
same pre-trial schedule,
going
forwar. But for now they
have different
trial dates: "
barring
further order
of the Court,
trial of the
cases will
proceed
separately,
with
22-cv-10018-UA
starting trial
on August 7,
2023 and
22-cv-10019-UA
starting trial
on September
5, 2023. SO
ORDERED.
(Signed by
Judge Jed S.
Rakoff on
12/5/22) Filed
In Associated
Cases:
1:22-cv-10018-JSR,
1:22-cv-10019-JSR."
Deutsche
Bank complaint
on Patreon here
Maximum
Maxwell book here.
Meanwhile,
the UN has yet to
answer Inner
City Press on
why SG Antonio
Guterres maintained a
rep on the
board of
Ghislaine
Maxwell's
Terramar
Project (instead
bannign the
Press); Norway
won't answer
on its
AMbasador Mona
Juul and
Terje Roed Larsen
taking $130,000
personal loan
from Epstein.
The
JPMC case is
Doe 1 v. JP
Morgan Chase
& Co.,
22-cv-10019
(Rakoff)
Also now
Government
of the United
States
Virgin Islands
v. JP Morgan
Chase Bank,
N.A.,
22-cv-10904
(Rakoff)
Watch
this
site.
***
Your
support means a lot. As little as $5 a month
helps keep us going and grants you access to
exclusive bonus material on our Patreon
page. Click
here to become a patron.
Feedback:
Editorial [at] innercitypress.com
SDNY Press Room 480, front cubicle
500 Pearl Street, NY NY 10007 USA
Mail: Box 20047, Dag
Hammarskjold Station NY NY 10017
Reporter's mobile (and weekends):
718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner City Press are
listed here,
and some are available in the ProQuest
service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-2022 Inner City
Press, Inc. To request reprint or other
permission, e-contact Editorial [at]
innercitypress.com
|